• ShootingNova posted a message in the forum topic Luke (ROTJ) vs Anakin (AOTC). on the Battles board

    Luke.Film versions only, Anakin, of course.

  • ShootingNova posted a message in the forum topic Jacen Solo VS Count Dooku. on the Battles board

    @jashro44: In that case, not sure. Jacen is noticeably more powerful, if not considerably, but how useful this will be in a fight isn't exactly evident. He's also sporting some physical edges (probab...

  • ShootingNova posted a message in the forum topic Darth Sidious vs. Darth Caedus+Lumiya. on the Battles board

    Sidious won't be able to Mind Control Lumiya, certainly not whilst under the strain of Caedus's relentless assaults.

  • ShootingNova posted a message on the post Top 10 Lightsaber Duelists.

    Regarding Vader vs Maul, I think it's pretty clear that Maul is the more skilled combatant, but the edge might be getting exaggerated here. The additional element of Maul's clearly superior speed and ...

  • ShootingNova posted a message in the forum topic Uatu the Watcher vs Spectre. on the Battles board

    I'm pretty sure the Spectre's sheer power outclasses Uatu's, even if he's been compared to Galactus before and even if his fight with another Watcher shakes the universe.

  • ShootingNova posted a message in the forum topic Quinlan Vos vs. Corran Horn. on the Battles board

    I can't see a real argument being made for Quinlan. He actually has telekinesis, but that's about his only edge. He's shown vulnerability to various mental attacks like Illusions which Corran can make...

  • ShootingNova posted a message in the forum topic Yoda/Obi-Wan Kenobi vs. Kotor team. on the Battles board

    @thevivas: Well, it's mostly an outlier source. Yoda is depicted by several other sources as a match for Palpatine, and lost because of positioning and weight. Then again, there's also an outlier sou...

  • ShootingNova posted a message in the forum topic Yoda/Obi-Wan Kenobi vs. Kotor team. on the Battles board

    @thevivas: You actually quoted the RotS novel, where Palpatine flat-out overpowers Yoda.

  • ShootingNova posted a message in the forum topic Aryn Leneer vs Quinlan Vos. on the Battles board

    I'd say they're either fairly similar in skill or Aryn is slightly behind, depending on where you rank Malgus, but in terms of telekinetic proficiency, Aryn's ahead and it's not even comparable.

  • ShootingNova posted a message on the post Top 10 Lightsaber Duelists.

    @shroudofsorrow: 1. There was also his Djem So advantage, per the RotS novelization, and likely also a strength advantage.2. Dooku held his own against CW Obi-Wan and Anakin. This is RotS Anakin.But h...

  • ShootingNova posted a message in the forum topic Darth Vader Vs Darth Malgus. on the Battles board

    Probably still Vader, since this is Deceived Malgus who doesn't quite match up to him in sheer skill or power.

  • ShootingNova posted a message in the forum topic Darth Vader vs Anakin . on the Battles board

    @eisenfauste said:How is it not? He hasn't displayed this sort of raw power before. Consistently he's in the multi ton range with TK not the several hundred tonne range. . .Force potential is nice and...

  • ShootingNova posted a message in the forum topic Jedi strike team vs. CIS. on the Battles board

    Lots of fodder on team 1, and they can't really bypass Essence Transfer, either. With powers like Storm and Drain or even just Lightning at his disposal, Palpatine has a good chance of at least demoli...

  • ShootingNova posted a message in the forum topic Rune King Thor vs Old King Thor. on the Battles board

    OKT loses. NKT wins. Again, if RKT is around or slightly above Galactus level, like he's usually hyped to be, then OKT could have a brief bout with him but lose. NKT would still win decisively, though...

  • ShootingNova posted a message in the forum topic Xesh/Daegen Lok vs Cade Skywalker/Darth Talon. on the Battles board

    @thevivas: Depends on how easily Talon gets taken out.

  • ShootingNova posted a message in the forum topic Ventress/Malgus/Mara Jade vs. Jaina/Ulic/Katarn. on the Battles board

    Kyle just seems like a weak link, to be honest.@i_like_swords said:I'd favour Ulic over Ventress in an excellent fight as well, due to a slight edge in strength and a noticeable power gap which could ...

  • ShootingNova posted a message in the forum topic Darth Vader vs Anakin . on the Battles board

    Anakin's feat with the Dreadnaught is in no way inconsistent. It's just a showing of his immense Force power. Anakin lost Force reserves after the event on Mustafar, which is why at the end of the nov...

  • ShootingNova posted a message in the forum topic Kit Fisto vs Plo Koon vs Shaak Ti. on the Battles board

    TCW's Magnaguards aren't comparable to Dark Lord Magnaguards or OCW Magnaguards, because there was clearly different authorial intent behind them, and clearly different intentions for their skill leve...

  • ShootingNova posted a message in the forum topic Kit Fisto vs Plo Koon vs Shaak Ti. on the Battles board

    @wildbantha88: No, she hasn't, really. Her fight with the Magnaguards is circumstantial and relied on her using an electrostaff against their expectations, but even provided that they adapted, the lo...

  • ShootingNova posted a message in the forum topic Darth Vader vs. Jaina Solo. on the Battles board

    lol Why did you actually listen to them.And Vader doesn't compare. He doesn't have any level of mastery of powers like Force Body similar to that of Jacen so push his body beyond its limits, and he re...