• 107 results
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3

This topic is locked from further discussion.

Posted by k4tzm4n (34887 posts) 7 months, 18 days ago

Poll: Comic Book Question of the Week VOTING: Favorite Spider-Man Writer (245 votes)

Brian Michael Bendis 29%
Dan Slott 28%
David Michelinie 2%
Gerry Conway 2%
J.M. Dematteis 3%
J. Michael Straczynski 14%
Peter David 2%
Roger Stern 2%
Stan Lee & Steve Ditko 23%
Tom DeFalco 1%
Other (Specify below) 1%

It's a big week for Peter Parker. Not only is his latest movie, The Amazing Spider-Man 2, opening in the U.S. (check out our review here), but Spider-Man also has a brand new volume starting this week! To celebrate the popular hero's big news, we want to reflect on his history in comics. We've already discussed our favorite villain in his rogues gallery, but now we want all of you -- yes, that includes you -- to think about all of the talented minds that have made an impact on the wall-crawler's life. We've added 10 names to the poll (plus "other" because adding every single big name would be a mess) and we want to see who your favorite one is.

Need some time to think about all of the web-slinger's stories? Totally understandable and we're not going to make you rush to a conclusion. Voting will stay open until Thursday morning (ET), so hopefully that's enough time for you to give this question a proper amount of thought. After you select a writer, be sure to tell us why the person earned your praise. Make your post awesome enough and there's a chance we'll highlight it in the updated feature. Now, go re-read some Spidey stories and then vote, Viners!

The Amazing Spider-Man 2 opens in U.S. theaters this Friday. Be sure to check the homepage on Thursday for an updated results article!

#1 Posted by Squalleon (4834 posts) - - Show Bio

Tough choice...

#2 Posted by RD189 (1568 posts) - - Show Bio

TOOOUGH. Without ignoring Yost and Zeb Wells, It comes down to Bendis and JMS, which is nearly an impossible choice.

#3 Posted by k4tzm4n (34887 posts) - - Show Bio

Kraven's Last Hunt possibly influenced my vote...

#4 Posted by averywetfrog (381 posts) - - Show Bio

Easy question. Roger Stern.

#5 Edited by silent_bomber (2186 posts) - - Show Bio

Why "Stan Lee & Steve Ditko" why not just Stan Lee?

Anyway, my choice is Stan Lee/John Romita then I guess, which is not represented in the poll.

Mary Jane is shown and finally starts playing a part, Pete and Gwen start dating, Pete and Harry become friends, Norman Osborn tension (will he regain his memory?), hanging out at the Coffee Bean Barn and parties, Gwen and Mary Jane trying to one-up each other, Kingpin, Rhino, and Shocker introduced, Spider-Man No More, Horns of the Rhino, Doc Ock Wins etc

#6 Posted by Krypton-115 (476 posts) - - Show Bio

Whitout Stan Lee there wouldn't be a Spider-Man, just saying...

#7 Posted by tparks (5363 posts) - - Show Bio

Brian Michael Bendis for Ultimate Spider-Man.

Online
#8 Posted by Fallschirmjager (18925 posts) - - Show Bio

@tparks said:

Brian Michael Bendis for Ultimate Spider-Man.

This.

Although the voting results are making me lol atm.

#9 Posted by butters911 (296 posts) - - Show Bio

I like the Lee/Ditko years the most of any Spidey run. Much more than Stan lee's stuff after Ditko left.

A close second was JMD.

#10 Edited by k4tzm4n (34887 posts) - - Show Bio

@silent_bomber: Ditko was a major player in what happened, and while Stan Lee later worked on the book without him, it felt odd having Stan Lee put up there twice, you know? If your favorite work is under Stan Lee, just give that option your vote.

#11 Posted by Jonny_Anonymous (34908 posts) - - Show Bio

Me and Bendis disagree with a lot of things but Spider-Man and Daredevil are not one of them.

#12 Posted by silent_bomber (2186 posts) - - Show Bio
@k4tzm4n said:

@silent_bomber: Ditko was a major player in what happened, and while Stan Lee later worked on the book without him, it felt odd having Stan Lee put up there twice, you know? If your favorite work is under Stan Lee, just give that option your vote.

I'm not really a big fan of Stan Lee/Steve Ditko, I'd vote for three or four other people on the list before them to be honest.

#13 Posted by Captain13 (3564 posts) - - Show Bio

Bendis

#14 Posted by LCazT1996 (532 posts) - - Show Bio

I'm not proud in saying that pretty much the only writer I've read of Spider-Man's (extensively, at least) is Dan Slott... But I've really enjoyed his run! It's just the only one I've read more than just a few issues of.

#15 Posted by Wardishy (908 posts) - - Show Bio

Sadly I've only read recent Spidey stuff. So I guess it's between Bendis and Slott for me.

#16 Posted by Darkseid_Prime (188 posts) - - Show Bio

David Michelinie

#17 Posted by LiveForever (312 posts) - - Show Bio

Ughhhhh, hate to see Dan Slott winning. And I'm not just butthurt about Peter dying. I just think his writing is clumsy. I'll give him points for enthusiasm.

I don't think he's ever had an extensive run on the book, but Joe Kelly has written some incredible issues. First one that springs to mind is the Rhino issue of the Gauntlet.

#18 Posted by godzilla44 (3658 posts) - - Show Bio

Stern or Bendis for me

#19 Edited by GraniteSoldier (8819 posts) - - Show Bio

Tough choice. Lee obviously shaped Peter and gave him his personality and who he is. Dan Slott, despite Superior, has made great progress in Peter's life and evolved his character. Bendis' work on Ult Peter was amazing (see what I did there?) but I also love JMS work as well. Zeb Wells work was good but he isn't on the list.

Really tough, I'm holding onto my vote for now.

Online
#20 Posted by averywetfrog (381 posts) - - Show Bio

Wow. Slott is starting off strong. didnt expect that. My other picks besides Roger Stern would be

2.Brian Michael Bendis

3.J. Michael Straczynski

4.Stan Lee

5.Dan Slott

#21 Posted by dondave (38882 posts) - - Show Bio

Dan

#22 Posted by PunyParker (12536 posts) - - Show Bio

Jesus,Slott's winning........

#23 Posted by Wolverine08 (45538 posts) - - Show Bio

Haha, Slott's winning!

Online
#24 Edited by Ninjablade09 (3193 posts) - - Show Bio
#25 Posted by kriminal (657 posts) - - Show Bio

Jesus,Slott's winning........

some people liked superior. didn't get mad because he tried a new idea and delivered a story.

#26 Edited by Sovereign91001 (4983 posts) - - Show Bio

JMS for me embodied the archetypal Spider-Man run. He had some of the very best Spider-Man stories of the past 14 years and I'd argue some stories that'll be looked at classics in years to come. Yes there were missteps Sins Past and OMD come to mind, although the later was more on editorial and was the reason he quit the book.

But there were also awesome stories as well; The Other Saga, Back In Black, and my personal favorite: ASM 500 which bounces between the beginning of Peter's costumed career highlighted by some of his greatest triumphs and failures along the way; his present day struggle and a haunting Dark Knight Returns esque portrayal of a future Peter Parker hunted down by the NYPD during his last days as Spider-Man.

It ends with one of the most heartwarming moments I've ever seen in not just a Spider-Man comic but comic books in general Peter get's a chance to talk to his Uncle Ben one last time, as a birthday gift from Doctor Strange.

But beyond that JMS did a lot of new and exciting things with his run, he introduced more supernatural elements into Spidey's mythos with Morlun, The Other, Shathra and Ezekiel. May learned Peter's secret identity, MJ and Peter were reunited after being estranged and Peter wasn't surrounded by the familar crew of the Daily Bugle but was potrayed as a school teacher, something that jived well with Peter's personality imo.

He wasn't afraid to shake up the status quo with changes that (for the most part) felt organic to the character and that above all else is why JMS' run is my favorite run.

After that I'd give it to Slott.

#27 Posted by Billy Batson (58293 posts) - - Show Bio

Why "Stan Lee & Steve Ditko" why not just Stan Lee?

Well to quote Brian Cronin from CBR...

Exactly, Stan Lee got the top spot AND the number two spot. He just had to share the top spot with Ditko, which is fair since Ditko, you know, co-wrote the issues. Again, for the last year or so of their run (the precise issue is hard to pin down), Ditko did not even speak to Lee. He would deliver the issues fully drawn without any input from Lee whatsoever. Lee would then script these fully drawn pages. Of course, Lee’s dialogue was an important addition to these pages (hence him getting the credit, as well), but the notion that Lee should be termed the sole writer of issues that he had no involvement with until they were fully drawn is, at best, absurd.

I mean, even before it got to that point, Ditko was likely the driving force in the plotting of the series, but that stuff is at least open to interpretation (at worst, he was an equal to Lee in the plotting of the issues. No one, not even Stan, has ever tried to claim that Lee was the driving force of the plotting of the early Ditko/Lee issues. It is just open for discussion how much of the early plotting was joint plotting and how much was Ditko-driven. Either way, at worstDitko was equal to Lee in the formation of the early Spider-Man plots). The later issues, though (including the Master Planner Arc, only one of the most famous Spider-Man stories ever), are not up for discussion. They were clearly solely plotted by Ditko with Lee adding his script to the stories after they had been fully drawn.

BB

#28 Posted by Shallbecomeabattoo (368 posts) - - Show Bio

JMS. His run was the only Peter Parker Spidey run ever that held my interest from beginning to end. The only Spidey run I love.

I really like Slotts Superior, but his Amazing run before didn't do anything for me.

#29 Posted by TheTrollDance (192 posts) - - Show Bio

1. Lee & Ditko

2. Bendis' USM run

3. Roger Stern

3. JMS before he became a drug-addict

4. Peter David

5. Tom DeFalco

That's my top 5.

#30 Posted by thewalkingdeadpool18 (386 posts) - - Show Bio

@punyparker:

Well Superiors only the most intresting thing to happen to Spider-Man in like 10 years....

#31 Posted by _Linea_11 (26 posts) - - Show Bio

Jesus,Slott's winning........

I don't believe it...how can someone like Slott's writing? 127 issues and only No One Dies was good...2 out 127.

I loved JMS, Bendis' Ultimate...DeMattis' Kraven's Last Hunt was one of the best Spidey story...the other were also Gold Writer. How can Slott win this race?

Lee/Ditko for me please

#32 Posted by xphilsa97x (5 posts) - - Show Bio

There should be a poll question about favorite Spider-Man artists.

#33 Edited by BR_Havoc (1339 posts) - - Show Bio

I'm going JMS before Joey Q screwed everything up.

#34 Edited by PunyParker (12536 posts) - - Show Bio

@kriminal said:

@punyparker said:

Jesus,Slott's winning........

some people liked superior. didn't get mad because he tried a new idea and delivered a story.

No no no,Superior is his best Spider-Man work!!.....his Amazing isn't so much.....that's why i posted this.

#35 Posted by PunyParker (12536 posts) - - Show Bio

3. JMS before he became a drug-addict

Wait,what?.....

@punyparker:

Well Superiors only the most intresting thing to happen to Spider-Man in like 10 years....

Then any comicbook for the last 10 years(and more) is un-interesting.......because this is an example of a "stunt" story.And "stunt" stories tend to have fast developments.
Will you follow Amazing with the same passion?!

If you don't,then your "That's why Slott's better" arguement is invalid.

@punyparker: I know how is that possible?

Some people started reading comics when Slott was writing,and doesn't have a clue what a "Peter David" is.....

#37 Posted by Anjales (543 posts) - - Show Bio

It's hard to pick one, but the most impactful four are definitely J.M Dematteis (Kraven's Last Hunt, Death of Harry Osborn), Roger Stern (Hobgoblin, The Boy who Collects Spider-Man), Dan Slott (New Ways to Die, Last Legs, Big Time, Spider-Island, Ends of the Earth, Superior Spider-Man), and Bendis (Ultimate Spider-Man, Spider-Men). I also have to give a shout out to Gerry Conway (Death of Gwen Stacy, the introduction of the Punisher, and the first Ben Reilly saga before it became a mess).

Ultimately, and I really hate to ride the bandwagon, but I have no choice, I'll have to go with Dan Slott. People seem to only reference Slott's more recent run, when he has been writing Spidey for a while before that. He is one of the writers who helped guide and re-establish Peter in the Brand New Day Era, adding new villains and supporting cast members.

What exemplifies Slott's run is that, he allowed Peter to do something most writers are afraid to do, he allowed Peter to grow, as a person and as a hero, while maintaining the core values that made him popular in the first place. Look at Slott's run alone, and see how far Peter has come along. And weather you like the guy or not, there's one thing you can't deny, he's one of the top 3 most daring Spider-Man writers ever, willing to go places others wouldn't (the other two being Dematteis and Conway).

His run featured Spider-Man becoming a think tank scientist, Flash becoming Venom, hooking up with Carlie Cooper (who was given more depth as a character), Peter announcing that while he's around No One Die, re-establishing villains like, Doc Ock, Sandman, Hobgoblin Alistair Smyth and the Scorpion, the introduction of Anti-Venom, the return of Norman Osborn to Spider-Man comics (twice), establishing Spider-Man as a major member of the Avengers, and finally who could forget Superior Spider-Man. Not only did Superior add new found depth to Octavius, but it also showed how much Peter's core values as a character have made him different than others, and that he is not just another colorful super-hero, he truly is a unique character, the one and only Spider-Man that can never be duplicated.

I don't think he's ever had an extensive run on the book, but Joe Kelly has written some incredible issues. First one that springs to mind is the Rhino issue of the Gauntlet.

I was wondering when someone would bring up Joe Kelly, even though it was only a 2 part story that took place in the middle of the Gauntlet saga, the Rhino story is one of the strongest SM stories I've ever read, it re-defined the Rhino and added a new sense of tragedy to Peter himself. He also wrote American Son, a very powerful story involving Spider-Man and the Osborns, and how Peter is dealing with Norman's Dark Reign, and it featured Spidey fighting Bullseye, Venom, Iron Patriot and Daken.

#38 Posted by fACEmelter88 (598 posts) - - Show Bio

Who did Grim hunt? And the Ben Reily must die story that introduced Raptor? Kaine was starting to show back up had a beard...
#39 Posted by IDontLikeBirds (423 posts) - - Show Bio

I almost voted for Dan Slott (you all know why!), but then I saw Bendis and had to give it to him. Though Ultimate Spider-man is a different version, he made me love the character all over again. He made me love a character that I wrote off years ago.

#40 Edited by angelalfonso (1133 posts) - - Show Bio

WTF... Dan is winning, i'm not saying he is bad writer, but how come Stan "the man" Lee is not on top followed by Bendis

#41 Edited by fACEmelter88 (598 posts) - - Show Bio

PS Whoever wrote the arc about Osborn knocking up Gwen can rot in hell...is that writer listed?

PPS

I don't think he's ever had an extensive run on the book, but Joe Kelly has written some incredible issues. First one that springs to mind is the Rhino issue of the Gauntlet.

Yea but the issue that left me breathless was the conclusion of Rhino's Gauntlet story when his girl died and he put his suit back to fight the Mecha-Rhino and Peter is pulling Alexi as hard as he can then eventually Peter is in street clothes leaving bloody foot prints . . . one of the most powerful issues of Spider-Man ever. Did Joe Kelly write that?

#42 Posted by InkInk (188 posts) - - Show Bio

Really sad that Slott is in the lead, He is not a great Spidey writer I would think of him as an average one his run has been mediocre since it began. I guess there is just a ton of young readers on the site that did not see the impact of JMS or David.

#43 Edited by Squalleon (4834 posts) - - Show Bio

What?Dan Slott wins even though his Spider-man run is mostly meh...It only strengthen my case that current runs, writers etc. shouldn't be in polls because the poll is often swayed, by new readers who still haven't delved into the characters or by excitement about the recent run(etc. etc.) which is fresh in the memory.

Voted JMS, I love (most of) his run. He wrote some of my favorite Spider-man stories and I feel that his run is a modern classic that is often overlooked by casual comic fans.

#44 Posted by fACEmelter88 (598 posts) - - Show Bio

PS Whoever wrote the arc about Osborn knocking up Gwen can rot in hell...is that writer listed?

PPS

@liveforever said:

I don't think he's ever had an extensive run on the book, but Joe Kelly has written some incredible issues. First one that springs to mind is the Rhino issue of the Gauntlet.

Yea but the issue that left me breathless was the conclusion of Rhino's Gauntlet story when his girl died and he put his suit back to fight the Mecha-Rhino and Peter is pulling Alexi as hard as he can then eventually Peter is in street clothes leaving bloody foot prints . . . one of the most powerful issues of Spider-Man ever. Did Joe Kelly write that?

#45 Edited by Wolverine08 (45538 posts) - - Show Bio

Online
#46 Posted by PunyParker (12536 posts) - - Show Bio

@punyparker said:

Jesus,Slott's winning........

I don't believe it...how can someone like Slott's writing? 127 issues and only No One Dies was good...2 out 127.

I loved JMS, Bendis' Ultimate...DeMattis' Kraven's Last Hunt was one of the best Spidey story...the other were also Gold Writer. How can Slott win this race?

Lee/Ditko for me please

EXACLY!!!
So many Spider-Man writers ,who left a golden mark in Parker history......and he's winning!!

#47 Posted by Anjales (543 posts) - - Show Bio

@facemelter88:


Yea but the issue that left me breathless was the conclusion of Rhino's Gauntlet story when his girl died and he put his suit back to fight the Mecha-Rhino and Peter is pulling Alexi as hard as he can then eventually Peter is in street clothes leaving bloody foot prints . . . one of the most powerful issues of Spider-Man ever. Did Joe Kelly write that?

I feel the exact same way. Yes Joe Kelly wrote it, and he also wrote American Son.

And the writer who wrote the Gwen/Osborn affair story is J. Michael Straczynski, who also wrote One More Day, but to be honest those were his very few misses, and OMD was bad mostly due to editorial, but he also wrote some very powerful stories, like, The Spider-Totem saga that featured Ezekiel and Morlun, The Conversation, that featured a very powerful moment between Peter and Aunt May after she finds out he's Spider-Man, Happy Birthday where Peter gets reunited with Uncle Ben, The Other and Back In Black.

#48 Edited by Squalleon (4834 posts) - - Show Bio

And what about Wolverine? I heard he is written well these days...

#49 Posted by thewalkingdeadpool18 (386 posts) - - Show Bio

@punyparker:

Stunt or not the comics was good and the most intresting thing to happen to Peter basically withint the last 10 years? How does that mean comics have been unintresting before Superior? It just means Spider-Man has been boring for 10 years before. Because Spider-Man has sucked before superior for about 10 years it was the same boring repetitive bullcrap it was unbelievable. While other characters were getting intresting arcs or even just intresting writing everything good from Spider-Man was before 2000 until Superior. I plan on giving Amazing Spider-Man a chance but last i heard it's not Slott writing it is it? Then why should i read Amazing? i will to see if Spider-Man continues to be intresting and the aftermath of Superior could be intresting but if it goes back to the same boring reptitive bullcrap i will probbably drop the comic.

The mindset that it's nothing but a stunt so it sucks is why Spider-Man has sucked for the last 10 years before Superior. So anything major that happens in comics is just a stunt and sucks? So comics should continue to do what Spider-Man did before Superior and tell you the same repetitive bull crap over and over again?

#50 Posted by Anjales (543 posts) - - Show Bio

I also have to mention Mark Millar's Marvel Knights run, one of the more darker Spider-Man stories. It featured Spider-Man going up against the Sinister TWELVE, a new Venom, having his identity almost exposed, the abduction of Aunt May, and almost reliving the Gwen Stacy experience with Mary Jane, all part of a grand master plan orchestrated by the Green Goblin.

I also have to mention Peter David, who wrote the Death of Jean DeWolf, another Dark Spider-Man story that featured a team-up with Matt Murdock and a major character development for Peter himself.

I see a lot of Slott hate on here, people seem to think the only reason he's in the lead is because of younger readers, and while that is probably one of the reasons, Slott has solidified himself as at least one of the strongest Spider-Man writers. To summarize my earlier comment, Slott's Spider-Man actually grew, instead of getting stuck in the typical status quo and also showed what makes him different from other characters. Spidey could easily be written as just another colorful, fun super-hero, but Slott's run showed that no matter how much things change, Peter's core values will always define him and make him the character he is today, a character that is imitated but never duplicated. This is notably shown in the story-lines called No One Dies, Alpha, and Superior Spider-Man.