moonsault86's X-Men #5 - Battle of the Atom Chapter 3 review

    Avatar image for moonsault86
    • Score:
    • moonsault86 wrote this review on .
    • 1 out of 1 Comic Vine users found it helpful.
    • moonsault86 has written a total of 2 reviews. The last one was for

    Awesome art and team dynamics... Jubilee just went for a nap?

    There are some great concepts about this book that I enjoy a lot. I totally dig the idea of an all female X-Men book. I tension from the perceived leaders of this team (Rachel and Ororo) is a concept that has been used before in the past yet Brian Wood writes in a way that it makes it fresh.

    I have only been getting Marvel comics for eighteen months and these two ladies are quickly becoming two of my favorite characters. It does appear that Rogue and Kitty Pride are taking sides already, which I feel adds a new dimension to the story. Young Cyclops and Jean Grey appear to be developing their personalities slowly which is understandable as they are not the heroes everybody knows.

    I don't really see what Jubilee is bringing to this book and yet I remember reading on early articles that she was going to be the central character in this series. After getting half an issue last month (where according to what I read on the forums could well have been her farewell) she just shows up, point out the obvious, comes back later saying she is tired and goes for a nap. I felt like that I might have missed a page or two where she did anything that mattered.

    I feel that she has no contribution to the story and yes, I understand that this is a crossover whose central characters are the main cast of a different book but every other cast member (Storm, Rogue, Rachel and Kitty Pryde) contribute to the plot. One has to wonder whether B.Wood has decided to change his strategy for this book completely and downgrade Jubilee from protagonist to background character.

    To leave on a positive note, I love the idea of a conflict of interests between good guys and the absence of a big bad.

    Other reviews for X-Men #5 - Battle of the Atom Chapter 3

      Tracking Cyclops and Jean 0

      WARNING: THIS REVIEW WILL SPOIL THE EVENTS OF BATTLE OF THE ATOM SO FAR!Battle of the Atom kicked of last week, and boy was it one brilliant start, and has made me even more excited about this series than I've already been. This series has also been extremely amazing itself, having four outstanding issues, with this also being the first part of Battle of the Atom not to be written by Brian Michael Bendis.PlotThe X-Men along with the future X-Men head off in search of the younger Cyclops, and Jea...

      11 out of 11 found this review helpful.

      Past, Present, Future...Headtrip 0

      I want to start this by saying I am not reading Battle of the Atom. I did not have the extra cash for all the tie-in crossovers and stand alone issues to the event, so I am just sticking with my monthly X-Men pickup. X-Men issue 5 is clearly entrenched in the middle of this event. Because I am not reading it, it makes it difficult to review this issue. For those familiar with all the X-Men titles no explanation is needed, but as I did not keep up I was somewhat lost.Now I am aware there is the ...

      2 out of 2 found this review helpful.

    This edit will also create new pages on Comic Vine for:

    Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.

    Comment and Save

    Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Comic Vine users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.