@turoksonofstone said:
@Jekylhyde14 said:
@turoksonofstone:
"Classic" Superman? Turok, I know that you're aware that Superman wasn't created in 1987. That's why statements like this puzzle me. In my opinion, it was Byrne's Superman who was always the pretender. Morrison's New 52 Superman is much closer to the genuine article.
Any and all versions previous to DCNU are "Classic" IMO, though there were several versions they were all revamps of the original concept and only had minor variations. DCNU Superman is essentially a different character. Byrne's Superman more closely resembled the golden and silver age versions in costume, character, and concept.
I completely disagree. Byrne made serious changes to Superman's character from the man who existed Pre-Crisis. First off, he allowed Ma and Pa Kent to live into Superman's adulthood which no previous version had. He also made Superman land in a "birthing matrix" so technically Superman could be born on Earth as an American. Byrne's Superman also feared and felt self-conscious about his Kryptonian heritage whereas all previous versions revered their alien roots. He was also pretty self-deprecating compared to the blatant egotism Superman used to show.
The New 52's version is much closer to the Pre-Crisis version in personality. He has tremendous self-belief as evidenced by his willingness to trust in his blind reactions to defeat Captain Comet. He has bold plans to try and solve the world's problems just like how the Pre-Crisis Superman was obsessed with ending crime for good. His development and childhood is much closer to Pre-Crisis than Byrne' who only gained his powers when he was a teenager and never joined the Legion of Superheroes as a boy. Morrison's Superman is a leftist, social crusader just like the Golden Age version. He's also not as attached to the Clark Kent identity as the Post-Crisis Superman was.
I'll give you the fact that his costume is a lot different. That's about it. In my opinion, the New 52 Superman is the return of Superman from all the Post-Crisis mistakes.
Log in to comment