Mace Windu VS Luke Skywalker

Luke Skywalker VS Mace Windu

After I pit Luke against Dooku, I wanted to see how well you think Mace would do as he is equal with the latter, give or take.

• Luke from Return of the Jedi, Windu at the end of The Clone Wars
• Fighting in the Death Star
• Morals on
• Win by Kill

Round 1: Sabers only

Round 2 : All out

Luke looks pretty derpy in that pic

Excuse me?

@luckystrike: *derpy

I had to change the position of his eyes in the pic so he'd be looking at Mace, thanks for the critique however.

@luckystrike: It's better than anything I can do

As to the fight, this is pretty close to a stalemate, though I may give Windu the slight edge.

Windu.

Windu.

Mace wins a slight majority via expirience and greater power.

Samuel L. Jackson

I see, so really this is Luke Skywalker VS fanboys

@luckystrike: Weren't you the one who made this thread? And also, Mace beats RoTJ Luke, Tharwn Trilogy Luke wins a majority, D.E. Luke wins handily every time and GM Luke SLAUGHTERHOUSE, but RoTJ isn't Mace's level.

And I'd honestly place them as on par as duelists, Mace just has more power and experience.

So basically Windu wins due to fanboyism

@luckystrike: lol I don't even like Windu that much. And based off of feats, he wins. Their skill is on par IMO, but Luke up to RoTJ doesn't have enough power feats to win a majority. If RoTJ Luke had better Force feats he'd win. Read my reasoning please. And if you're going to reply, counter my points atleast instead of calling everybody here fanboys.

Luke.

I think it'd be better if everyone stops posting in Lucky's threads. What's even the point if he already made up his mind on the victor and insults everyone who thinks otherwise?

@sxe619: i agree

@wollfmyth209: I suggest not responding to him. Whenever he doesn't like your response (or for whatever reason only known to himself) he'll just say that one party is winning because of fanboyism. There's nothing he says that's worth listening to.

And on-topic, Mace wins.

Luke looks like he has been on that Kush.

Bump.

Windu, probably.

More training & combat experience with a greater understanding of the force than Luke.

Mace. Luke never of been able to challenge Sidious like Mace did. I think it's highly possible Palpatine threw the fight, but Mace still made Palpatine strain.

Luke.

@alextheboss: He only made Palpatine strain because of Vapaad (if Legends). The novel states they fought as equals, then Mace won when Anakin's fear amped him even further.

Bump.