Hulk vs superman

i know is been done like a milliom time but im a bit curious ....who would win in a slugfest, no dodging no superpowers(speed, heat vision, etc etc) ... just a game of both trowing and taking punches at the same time, who would go down first?

i think supes win this one if he go with all from the start but i think he wouldn't he never do and when the time comes hulk would be so angry that hes strength would be too much !!

hulk (world breaker) vs superman (infinite crisis)

In theory Hulk would eventually win

Superman.

Hulk would win. (especially World Breaker)

My reason being Hulk fought Thor for several days once, and Thor never KOd him. IMO Thor and Supes are very similar strength-wise, so Supes wouldn't be able to KO Hulk, who would eventually grow strong enough to overpower Supes.

@RIKR2: Superman is much stronger physically than any version of Hulk, even Hulk's strongest version that you have here. And this is why ....

Superman is stronger than Hulk by thousands to millions of tons at least, he can toss a ship the size of a small moon like its nothing and thats not even when he's trying ....

when he's trying he pulls a third of the planet...

when he's trying hard he pulls a planet (its a dead planet, but still a whole planet) with a harness that only allows him to grasp the whole planet, he can't pull it with out it ...

when he's trying even harder he pushes war world .....

When he's trying his hardest, he pulls something with the same mass of Jupiter (weight of our solar system excluding the sun) .....

Hulk in this scenario. His potentail is limitless. Supes might have the upperhand at first, but that will only serve to further enrage the Hulk.

Superman

this has been done to many times.

@ChaosBlazer said:

My reason being Hulk fought Thor for several days once, and Thor never KOd him. IMO Thor and Supes are very similar strength-wise, so Supes wouldn't be able to KO Hulk, who would eventually grow strong enough to overpower Supes.

This is perfectly logical.

If it's base Hulk then Superman should win.

Been done ad nauseam.

IBTL

@Ancient_0f_Days: Hulk is extremely durable though, and even though Superman's base power is stronger, it would still not be enough to KO Hulk and therefore Hulk will eventually pass Superman in strength.

BUT, if Superman manages to KO Hulk before he gets to mad than he wins.

Superman

If he is going all out to begin with he should knock Hulks head off.

@Immortal777 said:

Superman

If he is going all out to begin with he should knock Hulks head off.

could hulk regenerate his head?

Dam c'mon Comicvine. This battle is clearly in Hulks favor, Superman doesn't have his speed, abilities, or dodging, while a slugfest is Hulks specialty, but it looks like Superman wins due to majority.

Has Hulk ever won a battle on the vine??!

@BlackLace said:

@TERMINATOR1234: Yes why not?

I've never seen Hulk regenerate from having his head removed... I think its possible though cause of his healing factor. so removing his head i don't know if it would help or not.

@XImpossibruX said:

Dam c'mon Comicvine. This battle is clearly in Hulks favor, Superman doesn't have his speed, abilities, or dodging, while a slugfest is Hulks specialty, but still people think he can Superman can win.

Has Hulk ever won a battle on the vine??!

yes .... he's beaten spiderman. wolverine, deadpool, Hawkman and Hawkgirl ..... Starfire .... other people .... you get where this is going ..... but as far as kryptonians go ..... without special stipulations ..... no, he hasn't really won yet .........

I don't get it, some one makes a thread like this Thor vs Superman, Hulk vs Superman etc but then people hate it when you bump an old thread?

But Hulk should win this, seeing how it is World Breaker.

@TERMINATOR1234: No if Hulks has never shown he can regenerate his head he cant.

@Ancient_0f_Days said:

@XImpossibruX said:

Dam c'mon Comicvine. This battle is clearly in Hulks favor, Superman doesn't have his speed, abilities, or dodging, while a slugfest is Hulks specialty, but still people think he can Superman can win.

Has Hulk ever won a battle on the vine??!

yes .... he's beaten spiderman. wolverine, deadpool, Hawkman and Hawkgirl ..... Starfire .... other people .... you get where this is going ..... but as far as kryptonians go ..... without special stipulations ..... no, he hasn't really won yet .........

LOOL man either Marvels hero's are really underpowered or DC's heros are waaaaaaaaay strong.

Because Hulk apparently took on the Avengers and almost won, but he can't even beat a Kryptonian, Green Lantern, or a Speedster.

PS. Hasn't Spiderman beat Hulk once already?

@BlackLace said:

@TERMINATOR1234: I think you are making a common physiology mistake. You know how people when they talk about being in love reference their hearts? Well that is not the case, so your question is kind of like "If Superman punched out the Hulk's heart, could he ever love again?" The healing factor of your body is not really controlled by your brain, except I suppose in that it is the main organ connecting the nervous system. Granted this is an ability which doesn't really exist, but animals that can regenerate in nature do not have any trouble with having their heads cut off. In some if you cut them in two both sides grow back whole. So as far as this question goes, I would think that the Hulk's regenerative ability is in his body as a whole and not specifically his head. Of course the brain he grew back might be completely undeveloped.

true.

the hulks strength and durability isnt what keeps him regenerating and from dying... its his dna. that dna thats inside the hulk is what keeps him so close to indestructable if i recall.

@Immortal777 said:

@TERMINATOR1234: No if Hulks has never shown he can regenerate his head he cant.

I didn't know, but if he could i'd love to see a scan, video or link that proves he can.

@BlackLace said:

@TERMINATOR1234: Agreed. Though to say it is in his DNA might also not be correct, but who knows as it is a superpower.

I remember in the Hulk movie for example the first one the hulks dad injected that green stuff inside of bruce banner when he was a baby..i'm assuming that dna is how comic version of hulk became hulk, but i could be wrong.

@TERMINATOR1234: How I see it If he has never shown he could then he just cant. If he healed like Deadpool from a finger or something then I would give it to him but he hasn't so there is no reason to believe he can.

@XImpossibruX said:

@Ancient_0f_Days said:

@XImpossibruX said:

Dam c'mon Comicvine. This battle is clearly in Hulks favor, Superman doesn't have his speed, abilities, or dodging, while a slugfest is Hulks specialty, but still people think he can Superman can win.

Has Hulk ever won a battle on the vine??!

yes .... he's beaten spiderman. wolverine, deadpool, Hawkman and Hawkgirl ..... Starfire .... other people .... you get where this is going ..... but as far as kryptonians go ..... without special stipulations ..... no, he hasn't really won yet .........

LOOL man either Marvels hero's are really underpowered or DC's heros are waaaaaaaaay strong.

Because Hulk apparently took on the Avengers and almost won, but he can't even beat a Kryptonian, Green Lantern, or a Speedster.

PS. Hasn't Spiderman beat Hulk once already?

Spider-man unlimited #11 yes. Some of the biggest pis you will ever see in a comic.

@Immortal777 said:

@TERMINATOR1234: How I see it If he has never shown he could then he just cant. If he healed like Deadpool from a finger or something then I would give it to him but he hasn't so there is no reason to believe he can.

very true, unless this battle was world breaker hulk who regenerated from being hit with an astroid, but i don't remember if that astroid even damaged hulks bones.

still with supermans heat vision, flying, freezing breath and so on i'm giving it to supes because with flying abilities superman can stay away from hulk within a distance.

@XImpossibruX said:

@Ancient_0f_Days said:

@XImpossibruX said:

Dam c'mon Comicvine. This battle is clearly in Hulks favor, Superman doesn't have his speed, abilities, or dodging, while a slugfest is Hulks specialty, but still people think he can Superman can win.

Has Hulk ever won a battle on the vine??!

yes .... he's beaten spiderman. wolverine, deadpool, Hawkman and Hawkgirl ..... Starfire .... other people .... you get where this is going ..... but as far as kryptonians go ..... without special stipulations ..... no, he hasn't really won yet .........

LOOL man either Marvels hero's are really underpowered or DC's heros are waaaaaaaaay strong.

Because Hulk apparently took on the Avengers and almost won, but he can't even beat a Kryptonian, Green Lantern, or a Speedster.

PS. Hasn't Spiderman beat Hulk once already?

well ....... no, Spiderman staggered him .... he said he could beat him, possibly ..... but the reason why Hulk almost can beat the avengers is because most of them are humans .... and most of them since they are human, don't have super speed, or durability ...... so besides Thor among a few others who are not apart of the main 9 Avengers, none of the others really have a chance .......

the Justice league on the other hand are mostly alien, humans with epic tech, humans who have the most useful powers or just not human ....... and a there are three members of the league that are almost as powerful as each other in almost every way outside of what they do best ..... I have no Idea why people put Hulk against them in the first place thinking the Avengers = the Justice when that isn't the case at all ........ but hey, I guess you can say those few DC heroes are over powered when compared to that specific branch of the marvel universe

@Ancient_0f_Days: @jashro44:

Beats him with literally no effort.... oh Marvel how you never fail to disappoint.......

@XImpossibruX said:

@Ancient_0f_Days: @jashro44:

Beats him with literally no effort.... oh Marvel how you never fail to disappoint.......

......................................... no comment ..... actually, comment. How is a cement truck > the Hulk .... that's worse than helicarrier > Sentry ....

@XImpossibruX i think hulk win if the slugfest goes to overtime

People put Hulk against people he cant beat then complain that he cant beat them. Why continue to put him against Superman then expect the outcome to be different some how. Every time Hulk is put against a Superman lvl character that character has to be Handicap shouldn't that tell you something.

HULK 

Yes, it has been done millions of times, and in each of those threads you can talk about how it would go down if it was just a slugfest.