If you want him stronger, what powers would you give him. If weaker, what powers would you want taken away? The Superman I'm talking about is the one in the main DC universe. New Earth or Earth-1 I think.

weaker, make his strength lower and he can't fly so fast.

Weaker. 
I would get rid of his super speed while running, because it makes the Flash a little less amazing (Flash fans understand). He should still fly super fast though.
Get rid of all his breath powers. Replace heat vision with laser vision. 
Lower his strength so that he can barely hold up two 747 air crafts. 

 Stronger
More powerful than he has ever been and give him threats that no one else can handle but him because of his power and with more power and the threat is so insurmountable only Superman deals with it he becomes the DCU's major power player and deals with these Earth shattering threats also that might make the JLA more valuable as if he has to team with the JLA then something is very dangerous and he becomes more generous and pure of heart with the more power he gains. 
 
And it's Earth Zero.

Weaker, and make him slower aswell as remove his super speed (outside of flight).

...

Stronger MUCH STRONGER, have his power gradually increase over time and have him eventually become something akin to Superman Prime DC One Million.

Make him stronger,Slow him down so the Flash haves something to contribute,Drop the Justice League.

Weaker. He was best during the Golden Age. And I mean the real golden age not Earth 2 during the Silver Age. The Superman who can't fly but just leap really really high. Not invincible but just more durable than normal men. Faster only than a speeding bullet not faster than light.
 
If they can't bring him to that level then at least give back the consistency of the Byrne era. I don't like how he got stronger over time even though it was already post crisis.

"Stronger MUCH STRONGER, have his power gradually increase over time and have him eventually become something akin to Superman Prime DC One Million. "

Weaker? He is the definition of THE Superhero. He is supposed to be the World's Strongest non-magic Superhero. Too many writers screw with him for no good reason. They fail to realize what Superman is supposed to stand for and symbolize. He's not just an icon in comics, but in life as well. He's an icon to a lot of people who look up to him. They see him as a symbol of hope, and if he is crushed and defeated, what hope is there?
 
And I agree that he should become stronger, but not in one shot. He should be able to match the Flash in speed, but that comes slowly over time after racing the Flash over and over. He slowly and gradually increases his speed, eventually one day matching the Flash in speed, and the Flash is surprised by this, questioning if he truly is the World's Fastest Man. Now, this should be of course to a limit. Flash has been shown to be able to go through dimensions and time by surpassing light speed by tapping deep into the Speed Force, and he should still be allowed to do that, but Flash should realize that Superman can match him on normal terms if Flash didn't tap deep into the Speed Force and allow himself to travel through dimensions and time. I don't think Superman should travel through space and time, but like I said on normal terms, where Flash goes light speed only using a little bit of the Speed Force, Superman should be able to match him in speed.
 
Same thing with his strength. His strength should increase gradually and slowly, eventually Superman performing sun-dipped strength feats without being sun-dipped.
 
Everything slowly, though. Not in one shot.

Weaker.
Then maybe weak, unimaginative writers will stop using the excuse he's too powerfull and boring.
Don't take any powers but dial down what he's got.
 
Truth is we seem to only get bad stories from a massively powerfull superman. 
That and the fact that it makes supes less and less relatable.

See the thing is any one askin' for a stronger Superman aren't really thinkin' it through. 
Superman's not just an idea. He's the central character of a serious of stories. It is very difficult to write exciting, interesting stories with a character who's too powerfull so ultimately makin' Big Blue more powerfull would result in poor comics.

" See the thing is any one askin' for a stronger Superman aren't really thinkin' it through.  Superman's not just an idea. He's the central character of a serious of stories. It is very difficult to write exciting, interesting stories with a character who's too powerfull so ultimately makin' Big Blue more powerfull would result in poor comics. "

I think Superman is good as he is now.

Tone him down a bit.  No one should be surviving a collision of two planets, exploding stars, and whatnot.

stronger, he lacks his intimidation like in the past.  Not sure what powers, there are some that could work, but not sure about.  He should be stronger and his intimidation factor needs work. 

" Tone him down a bit.  No one should be surviving a collision of two planets, exploding stars, and whatnot. "

" Tone him down a bit.  No one should be surviving a collision of two planets, exploding stars, and whatnot. "

Stronger. He's Superman. Not above-average superhuman man. SUPER. He's the first. He's the best. It's time he showed that again.

" I think he needs better super villaisn to challange him DC supervillains are crappy, mabye import some marvel ones to fight him. "

" @Norbit said:

" I think he needs better super villaisn to challange him DC supervillains are crappy, mabye import some marvel ones to fight him. "

Lex Luthor, Darkseid, Doomsday, Brainiac, Parasite, Metallo, Mongul, Bizarro, Mr Mxyzptlk, Zod. "

" @FadeToBlackBolt said:

" @Norbit said:

" I think he needs better super villaisn to challange him DC supervillains are crappy, mabye import some marvel ones to fight him. "

Lex Luthor, Darkseid, Doomsday, Brainiac, Parasite, Metallo, Mongul, Bizarro, Mr Mxyzptlk, Zod. "

I think Norbit was talking about strength wise. Lex can match wits, The rest of them (besides Mr. Mxyzptlk) can match strength. Zod doesnt seem as much of a villain to superman any more, that might change soon but at this point its more like they just dont see eye to eye but their on the same page.
 

" @FadeToBlackBolt    Galactus, Thanos, Apocalypse, magneto, juggernaught, Dr doom, venom, red Hulk, The Leader  , Loki, The Absorbing Man , Omega red, Exodus, need i say more the list goes on a lot longer than yours, and with characters who actually are powerful enough to give him a *real* challange.     "

Make superman stronger but put him in more lose-lose situations. 

I think Superman personally should have ridiculous power, live up to the name "Superman" 
 
I honestly loved Silver Age Superman, Golden Supes they are so cool IMO...normal Superman is fine but I think should be between his name and DC's first character top 5 most powerful guys in DCU, he's easily top 10 for sure.

Weaker

 
 Superman  shouldn't be able to lift planets,  his strength level should be lower down a little bit, he shouldn't  be able to survive planet explosions, his speed should be the same as lightspeed, he shouldn't be able to go pass light speed, but he should be able to out speed Flash on occations. Superman should lose the ice breath, seeing how he doesn't use it that much. His heat vision should be the same heat level as the sun,but not hotter. He shouldn't have the same abilities he had in Silver and Golden age.  I think we could be able to read more awsome stories if he was a little bit weaker. I know he is Superman,but his powers are not what makes him Superman, I mean he could be Superman without powers. The thing that makes him Superman is the same with other heroes, he never gives up, he always tries his best, he is able to get through tough times, he tries to fnd a quick ways  to solve things. That is all I can think of for right now,but I think there are more. Anyways it is not the powers that make him super, it is how he deals with things that makes him super.  He is the only one who was able to show how to deal with these things the right way  that is why he is one of the first super heroes and why he is "SUPERMAN".

" Stronger MUCH STRONGER, have his power gradually increase over time and have him eventually become something akin to Superman Prime DC One Million. "

i heard once that he was able to knock planets out orbit with a punch, if that's true, then he should be that strong all the time

Weaker.

"stronger, he lacks his intimidation like in the past.  Not sure what powers, there are some that could work, but not sure about.  He should be stronger and his intimidation factor needs work.  "

Why do you people hate his freeze breath so much?

Honestly, I would leave him as is, except for his superspeed.  I would take much of that away.  
 
It makes the speedsters a little more pointless if he can much of what they can while also being invulnerable and strong.
 
I would cut his ground speed to a few hundred mph, still fast enough to be faster than normal eyes can track at close range, but not enough to make him take away the speedsters role.

stronger and give him stronger enemies, he can't lift planets whoever said he could