-
@muhdsyarif: its strange that any point that goes against your argument is automatically an outlier. Half of your argument is "this is an outlier, thats an outlier, also an outlier" and its always whe...
-
@johndeyvido: My claim was that the shield absorbs energy, never said all of it, just a large portion. Of course an explosion still occurred, they fired the beam a hundred meters away from them. Howev...
-
@johndeyvido: It is incredibly ironic you're demanding more evidence when you literally have provided nothing for Carol despite me asking several times.Anyways the shield of the Harvesters absorb ener...
-
@johndeyvido: Yes you can, do you not understand the physics at play if the other object has a kinetic absorbing shield? Or the physics at play when a object thats heavier than mars literally rams a m...
-
@johndeyvido: No I'm not, your entire argument is banking on "smaller surface area means more force" to a ridiculous point despite the massive differences in feats. Hence why I am asking you directly,...
-
@johndeyvido: I know thats how regular physics works, I literally pointed it out two posts ago. What I'm telling is that your examples are not a reflection of those actual physics and are merely surfa...
-
@deltahuman: Thanks, the Harvester ship really is a prime example of "size can matter" in fiction. Personally out of curiosity I searched for Independence Day threads on this site and found it quite i...
-
@Aristeaus: Well he didn't make any calcs regarding the second movie, I meant that the series got a calc from him. It was in regards to the first movie. Also he isn't exactly just a rocket scientist, ...
-
@deltahuman: Oh definitely more than millions of nukes. I know this site doesn't take calcs all too well (personally I'm more of the skeptical side of things), but over at Spacebattles there exists ca...
-
@deltahuman: The main problem isn't its size alone, its the shields that yes you would need to be far higher than just a continent buster to even pierce through. The shield withstood kinetic impacts f...
-
@johndeyvido: I'm not misunderstanding anything, your the one using fictional instances in different series to argue that a massive difference in energetic impacts will for some reason not matter in a...
-
@johndeyvido: Yes theres a difference between a grenade and an armor piercing round, however the comparison you're trying to make here isn't a valid one and misunderstands the physics involve. First o...
-
@amonfire1776: for some reason its showing thats its not notifying you, so scroll up to see my reply.
-
@amonfire1776: Well being fair, they only "lost" in the second movie due to the fact that the Alien Queen left the ship to pursue the last living member of a race her entire species hate to the point ...
-
@shaquilleotmeal: Despite Thor standing at the center, the explosion's shockwave and energetic output went away from him at a vertical motion, Its the same thing that happened to Tony who also stood p...
-
@thakidd: What feats does she have to "eventually" take down a literal small planet sized ship.
-
The fact people believe MCU main Cap Marvel can penetrate the shield itself, is frankly ridiculous. The ship literally rammed the top of the moon, we're talking exatons of energy here. Heck the ship i...
-
@kaijuking: Dont put words in my mouth, I saw you were lying about specific claims about another site and wanted to counter it. Has nothing to do with me as how I see you as a person. Also nothing abo...
-
@kaijuking: Where am I whining? I pointed out that all the other sites besides spacebattles have similar rules to that no sniping rule and merely copy and pasted them, thats it, this was jus to correc...
-
@kaijuking: Sniping isn't a bs rule, its literally just a rule to ask others not to be shit people that would just clog down debates. Also literally all of these sites except KMC have rules about bein...
Log in to comment