Kaore

Surely it's entirely circumstantial, right?

"DD Vader" was essentially a vision, no? WBW Anakin actually exists.

2 without a doubt. Dooku is already a close match, another would be overkill.

Stops at 2 if AoTC Dooku ~ RoTS Dooku, which I see no reason to doubt. If AoTC Dooku is substantially weaker somehow then definitely stops at Mace.

Probably stops at 1, definitely stops at 2

Luke should win, but it's close

Anakin & Dooku is a hard call. I'd probably back Tyranus, but it's close either way. Ahsoka should be able to take on Baylan, though, and after that Dooku can't handle both Anakin & Ahsoka 2v1...

BoBF Luke tires out his reckless younger self

I think using gameplay can be a little shaky when comparing Cal to other characters, since game mechanics being solid are prioritised over consistency with lore, but Cal is still crazy strong. Nice th...

People are underselling Ben Solo's chances here. Kenobi is a more accomplished duelist by a good degree, but Solo is still a talented fighter and in profoundly better physical condition.In power, they...

Ventress is a solid enough distraction to close the gap between Maul & Dooku.Team should win, maybe 6/10?, but they don't beat Vader.

@frozen: How do you reconcile Vader talking about the weakness remaining that he initially saw in their last duel, then? Especially when we hear that very trauma in the form of the pit flashbacks to R...

Maul has been trained by the greatest Sith in galactic history as a true successor since childhood, and trained by one of the most lethal warrior cultures in the galaxy prior. He's contended with the ...

@thespartanb345t: Unfortunately scaling in Syar Wars debating is ridiculous

@redsithdisciple: It's definitely close. Qui-Gon is very close to Maul, and all of Sidious' apprentices are at least roughly comparable.Qui-Gon was trained by one of the greatest duelists in the Jedi ...

@gioppy37: "Strong enough to fight this Lord Sidious, you are not."Obi-Wan is less powerful, less skilled and astronomically less experienced than Yoda during RoTS. He then sits in a desert for 10 yea...

Qui-Gon is probably a better duelist, but Luke can definitely contend seriously. Skywalker is the stronger Force user, although inexperienced.Considering their respective performances against Darths M...

@gioppy37: I'm not convinced Sidious is that much stronger post-O66 VS pre-O66. It's an argument I see floated around a lot lately, and I'm not exactly sure why. I also don't see any notable differenc...