Who Played Sabretooth Better, Tyler Mane or Liev Schreiber?

Schreiber is overrated. He wasn't that good. Tyler played the role of the silent muscle better than the not so intimidating or cunning big bad. Lol movie tried to play him up as being this horrific nightmare when all he's done is get stomped in petty cat fights with Wolverine along with some smart remarks

Liev, his performance was very good (better than of the Hugh, that is protagonist), I wanted to see him again.

Tyler out of these two. Creed as Logan's bro is a cheap soap opera trope.

Tooth would've been perfect if he was something in between in terms of characterization tho, but who could be the cast for such an incarnation, is million dollar question.

Liev.

Liev's at least had some personality

Liev I honestly forgot about Sabretooth in the original Xmen

Liev for sure.

In the comics Sabretooth is incredibly scheming and conniving with a silver tongue on him. Tyler's portrayal showed none of that; he was impressive in terms of fighting but other than that he was a forgettable, dumb brute.

Liev in a stomp. Tyler Manes Sabertooth was cool when i was 5 but when i got older and started reading more Sabertooth it become very clear that Liev played a perfect Sabertooth. The only thing has over Liev as Creed is his height of about 6-9 or 6-10 but other then that he was meh.

I may despises the movie but Schreiber slaughters here

Schreiber's Sabretooth, spite. He was more than just brawn. Mane's performance was about on par with Jeep Swenson's portrayal of Bane in Batman & Robin.

Schreiber.