Right, except, that neither has.
1) The only character that could possibly one-shot Lady Shiva, due to skill alone, is Karate Kid, someone who keeps up with kryptonian level characters on a daily-basis, due to his skill.
2) The instance that you're refferring to, was Lady Shiva's lowest showing ever, on all continuities, and it was Jason's highest, and its the reason why no-one takes Jason seriously anymore on the battle threads, people just make jokes about him now, like "jason oneshots, obviously" and stuff like that.
It also toke place on Jason's own title, on which he has been written far above the level on which he's written on the other titles.
3) When people bring up that instance, they conviniently forget to say, that on that same series, a few issues earlier, Lady Shiva had overwhelmed Jason easly and she even told him that she was disappointed with him...and he only escaped due to blowing his helmet on her face, which certainly isn't a skill feat.
And when Jason beat Shiva, he admitted, that she teached him a few special shortcuts, just in case Jason ever faced a opponent of Lady Shiva's caliber (Jason's own words) clearly indicating that Jason isn't as good as Shiva, otherwise he wouldn't need to use them.
4) Also, when it comes to skill alone, even in the New 52, that instance was easly both Jason's best showing, and Shiva's worst...Jason's best skill feat besides that one, its stallemating a holding-back Batman...while Lady Shiva has beaten Batman and Robin together, defeated Nightwing, etc...the inconsistency, its pretty notorious.
5) And for the record, Pre-New-52 Lady Shiva >>>>>New 52 Lady Shiva, at all levels.
Log in to comment