Here are the facts, and or most likely scenarios, as I see them:
Batman clearly wins a hand to hand fight. This is assuming he avoids point blank optic blasts which is likely.
Cyclops clearly wins a medium to long distance fight. I'd say Batman has "medium" range with his batarangs and etc, but Scott's ability to shoot down small projectiles has been part of his training since day one of the X-men. The likelihood of Batman landing a worthwhile batarang hit is about on par with the likelihood of Cyclops landing a pointblank optic blast.
Batman will be caught off guard by the first optic blast. The "rules" say nothing about pre-existing knowledge so I assume there is none. Bruce will have no logical reason to assume that because Cyclops has weird glasses on that his eyes can produce optic energy blasts. That's just ridiculous.
Batman will likely have an opportunity to get the jump on Cyclops, but will not take advantage of it. Cyclops isn't going to be robbing a bank, or mugging somebody. Cyclops doesn't do that. Unless he's in the middle of committing a crime, Batman will not take Scott down with a stealth attack before making his presence known and assessing that a fight is to follow. The fight is going to start with both characters aware of the other's presence and hostile intentions, therefore, any stealth advantage Batman wants to use will have to be regained after giving up his position. This is certainly possible, so all I'm really saying here is that there is no possibility of Scott being taken out immediately from the shadows with no fight.
Neither Cyclops or Batman will consistently (in a best of 10 scenario) be able to out maneuver the other tactically. Batman is clearly seen as an excellent tactician and quick problem solver, but Scott is one of the greatest tactical minds in the Marvel Universe. That's pretty much all he does. He sits back and watches the chess pieces that are his various field teams, keeps them in communication, sends in new members, retrieves those that no longer need be in battle, and analyzes the best way to take down whatever ridiculous threat the X-men are facing at that moment in time. Having said that, a big blow to Cyclops' tactical prowess will be that he is all alone in this fight, but he still knows battle movements, enemy analysis, likely weak points, and zones of attack. After all of this, I'm going to call the tactical debate a complete draw.
So the outcome will really come down to whether Batman can successfully reattain his stealth advantage and fool Cyclops long enough to close to melee distance. The sheer force behind Cyclops' blasts should honestly be enough that a single blast with a solid connection is enough to win. Even if the first blast does not incapacitate Batman (which is entirely possible given his impressive armor), he will surely be stunned long enough for a series of followups. Also possible is that Batman is buried in rubble from a near miss, holding him steady long enough for a followup blast.
Honestly, my vote was that the fight was too close to call, but with Batman almost surely being caught off guard by the first optic blast, and the above likelihood of a single connecting blast being enough to, if not flat out win itself, set up the win, I think Cyclops will actually take the edge.
Log in to comment