Comic Vine Review

4 Comments

New Avengers #17

4

What happens when there's a giant threat causing destruction in New Jersey? The New Avengers take it on in full force. There's some big things coming their way and this issue is just the beginning.

If you read issue #16.1, you know the New Avengers will soon be facing the return of a deadly villain. If that wasn't bad enough, a giant robot is attacking in New Jersey.

The Good

What could be better than seeing the New Avengers fight a huge robot determined to cause as much destruction as possible? Maybe having it drawn by Mike Deodato and Will Conrad. Ultimo is attacking Stark Resilient and and the New Avengers are on the scene. Sometimes this is exactly what we want to see, a giant battle with loads of destruction. We don't often get to see the team simply cut loose. The sense of mystery as to why this battle is occurring adds to the suspense of the story.

What's interesting is the team almost fights without direction. They see a giant threat and they go at it. There's no need for anyone to bark out orders and they have assessed the situation and know where to attack...or do they? Of course the kicker is in who is really responsible for the attack and the reason why. This is the beginning of some dark times for the New Avengers.

Mike Deodato and Will Conrad's combine art explodes off the page. With all this big action, you want nicely detailed panels. This kind of art is the kind I like to just look at again after reading the issue.

The Bad

As fun as the battle was, it did almost feel a little odd the way the New Avengers were just attacking and Iron Man was trying to get them to listen to him. It would have been nice to see Mockingbird in action with her new abilities rather than be stuck on pilot duty. We're thrown straight in the middle of the action, which isn't a bad thing but you can't help but wonder how this fits in with Fear Itself and the New Avengers Annual. Minor things that don't necessarily ruin this story but caused a tiny distraction for me.

The Verdict

There's some big things coming for the New Avengers. While fighting a giant threat in New Jersey, we find out there more to the attack than there appears to be. Every once in a while it's great to get an issue with over the top action. Having Mike Deodato and Will Conrad draw it makes it even better. We don't always get to see the New Avengers simply cut loose on their enemies but here they simply attack as soon as they arrive on scene. Iron Man's appearance and attempt to direct the team felt odd but seeing the seeds that are being planted for the next issue and arc is enough to get you salivating.

4 Comments

Avatar image for owie
owie

9569

Forum Posts

286670

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 16

User Lists: 0

Edited By owie  Moderator

I got this because Daredevil is joining the team, and he's ON THE COVER.

And yet, he is not anywhere to be found inside. I mean, I know covers are not always accurate, but that's majorly annoying.

Plus, this just is a weirdly put-together team. You've got all these street-levelers without any powers beyond the kinds of things that come in handy in H2H: Daredevil (in absentia), Mockingbird, Spider-Man, Iron Fist, Jessica Jones, Wolverine (plus occasionally Victoria Hand and Squirrel Girl). Plus two strong guys with no other powers besides being strong, so they are duplication city: Luke Cage and Thing. Then you have two that have powers way above the others: Ms. Marvel and Dr. Strange. So generally either it's going to be a fist-fight, and these two powerful ones have nothing to do (Ms. Marvel can join in, but she would clean up any street level bad guys too fast for any of the other guys to be worth anything, and certainly Dr. Strange is super-overkill in a fist-fight), OR they're super bad guys who Dr. Strange and Ms. Marvel have to strain against, and the others are useless. I know this isn't how it always shakes out in the actual comics because of PIS, but I just don't get the team makeup.

Avatar image for donovan_montgomery
Donovan Montgomery

5751

Forum Posts

2822

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 3

User Lists: 17

@Owie said:

I got this because Daredevil is joining the team, and he's ON THE COVER.

And yet, he is not anywhere to be found inside. I mean, I know covers are not always accurate, but that's majorly annoying.


This ^^
Avatar image for sexuallobster
SexualLobster

995

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

Edited By SexualLobster

@Owie: Iwas thinking the same thing, I like Logan, Spidey the Thing and Ms. Marvel, but everyone else doesn't seem to 'fit'. Daredevil? Against any real threat, let's face it he's kinda useless. Dr. Strange I agree, he's just super overkill and should be on a team with people on his level (or at least closer to his level overall anyway).

It seems kinda forced to put these names into comics with popular name like Logan and Spiderman to get the a little more 'juice' in their own respective comics.

Avatar image for donovan_montgomery
Donovan Montgomery

5751

Forum Posts

2822

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 3

User Lists: 17

@SexualLobster: DD doesn't  need any promo help, Bendis just wants to mess with us some more >=p[ 
 
P.S. he owes me $5.25 for my N.A. #17!!