if you could charge heroes....

if you had to build a legal case against heroes, who would it be?  and why?
 what would be the charges?

anybody think heroes are just as bad as the criminals they catch or worse?


phase two                                                                                                                                                                                                     


now how as a goverment law enforcement agent go, about arresting and enforcing the law?

working with only the general public knowledge and government intel of the characters..

using reasonable tactics and knowing your yearly budget  will be reviewed..

Punisher would probably be the easiest

really? i figure ironman....with the hulk fiasco...

kidnapping, false inprisonment.. public endangerment.. vigilantism 1st degree murder  2nd degree mur

Vigilantism?  He's a registered hero and head of SHIELD.  There's no vigilantism in it.

Kidnapping?  False imprisonment?  The Hulk (despite what certain people said during that series) is a murderer.  Maybe he wasn't in control of himself and maybe he's made up for it with heroics but there's no question that the Hulk is a danger to the public.  Even during Civil War, everybody he had arrested had broken a law.  The negative zone prison was probably illegal but most of what Iron Man has done lately was simply unethical, not illegal.

"Vigilantism?  He's a registered hero and head of SHIELD.  There's no vigilantism in it.

Kidnapping?  False imprisonment?  The Hulk (despite what certain people said during that series) is a murderer.  Maybe he wasn't in control of himself and maybe he's made up for it with heroics but there's no question that the Hulk is a danger to the public.  Even during Civil War, everybody he had arrested had broken a law.  The negative zone prison was probably illegal but most of what Iron Man has done lately was simply unethical, not illegal."

that movie rocked better then the last one

"here is justice here is punishment.."

"that movie rocked better then the last one

"here is justice here is punishment..""

"Vigilantism?  He's a registered hero and head of SHIELD.  There's no vigilantism in it.

Kidnapping?  False imprisonment?  The Hulk (despite what certain people said during that series) is a murderer.  Maybe he wasn't in control of himself and maybe he's made up for it with heroics but there's no question that the Hulk is a danger to the public.  Even during Civil War, everybody he had arrested had broken a law.  The negative zone prison was probably illegal but most of what Iron Man has done lately was simply unethical, not illegal."

"castleking said:

"that movie rocked better then the last one

"here is justice here is punishment..""

I thought the first Punisher film was lame... the one with Thomas Jane was much better"

Superman

he is an illegal immigrant after all :P

"Superman

he is an illegal immigrant after all :P"

"Vigilantism?  He's a registered hero and head of SHIELD.  There's no vigilantism in it.

Kidnapping?  False imprisonment?  The Hulk (despite what certain people said during that series) is a murderer.  Maybe he wasn't in control of himself and maybe he's made up for it with heroics but there's no question that the Hulk is a danger to the public.  Even during Civil War, everybody he had arrested had broken a law.  The negative zone prison was probably illegal but most of what Iron Man has done lately was simply unethical, not illegal."

he also overcomes the speed limits....

and doesn't show a passport when he goes to another country :P

"Really ? Wow.. thats something
"

"Superman

he is an illegal immigrant after all :P"

and he makes fun of bald people, poor Lex probably has a disease :P

"you  know taking the law into your own hands is illegal right.. and everything he did was before the registration act..

and being in charge of a government agency doesn't make your action less punishable..."

"If you are in charge of a Governent Agency it doesnt automatically make you able ot do whatever you want....you can still be tried in court...If you are using your power like Tony was to accomplish your own ends, not uphold the law then it is indeed vigilantism- and illegal."

how did he work within the law may i ask...

good one on the firearm  and intoxication..

but i think we can get him on more then just  a firearm with the suit.

what's higher  then fire arm  weapons of mass destruction maybe

Batman would be at the top of my list.

Nick Fury would be pretty easy too. With the whole Secret War thing.

"Nick Fury would be pretty easy too. With the whole Secret War thing."

"how did he work within the law may i ask..."

senting hulk away against his will in a shuttle..

kidnapping.. false inprisonment

Foolkilller

have you seen the stuff that guy does

"senting hulk away against his will in a shuttle..

kidnapping.. false inprisonment"

hmm.. coming back and destroying the city 2nd degree man slaughter for  ironman and it is still a crime regardless if the government backed it up... which is why alot of times Gov. make black ops missions..

BATMAN THE MOST OBVIOUS VIGILANTISM unregistered vehicles

I would say conspiracy charges would be in order for the whole of the Illuminati.

true they thought about it and planned it

"you  know taking the law into your own hands is illegal right.. and everything he did was before the registration act.."

"and being in charge of a government agency doesn't make your action less punishable..."

Daredevil-Vigilantism,reckless endangerment,kidnapping,torture,manslaughter

now how as a goverment law enforcement go about arresting and enforcing the law?

working with only the general public knowledge and government intel of the characters..

using reasonable equipment and tactics. knowing your yearly budget  will be reviewed...

"She-Hulk-indecent exposure"

wolverine..  serial murderer, concealed wpn charges. multiple identities.. fraud

Moon Knight-nuff said

"Vance Astro said:

"She-Hulk-indecent exposure"

Lol.

I <3 She Hulk.  Comic books are allowed to be fun."

Public Indecency.
Walking around or while fighting,  stretching legs while flying showing intimate muscles in public.


WHITE QUEEN, PSYLOCKE, WONDER WOMAN, BLACK QUEEN, MOONDRAGON
INCREDIBLE HULK, JAMIE BRADDOCK (it must be the braddock genes' to show alot of themselves in public)
 

Superman - the sheer scale of collateral damage he's caused is incalculable. Metropolis would be in debt up to their heads and beyond, not to mention the occasions he travels out of the city.

Moon Knight for cutting faces off

Kitty Pryde= harboring an unlicensed exotic animal, illegal alien and fire hazard.