keith71_98's Detective Comics #879 - Skeleton Key review

    Avatar image for keith71_98

    Another strong and rock solid issue...


    "Detective Comics" #878 was a phenomenal book in nearly every regard. Not only did it feature stellar writing and a picture-perfect tone, but it packed one of the most jaw-dropping endings you'll find. So naturally I had high expectations for issue #879. But even with Scott Snyder's amazing ability to construct a story and put together great dialogue, this solid issue wasn't what I was expecting. 

    I'm running out of adjectives to describe how great Snyder's run has been on this book. This issue is tightly written and structured just like the previous books and carries that signature Snyder dark tone. Throughout the book there are dual stories being pushed forward. One features Jim Gordon trying to either satisfy or silence his suspicions about his son James, Jr. The other features the Joker being moved within the walls of Arkham Asylum. Neither feel connected at first but as the book progresses there grows a disturbing, almost macabre congruency. Snyder flourishes with dark material and it's evident here but I have to say I was expecting a little more. This story certainly relates to the shocking end of the previous book but only from a distance. Maybe it's just my impatience but I was hoping it would have been dealt with more directly this issue. 

    My biggest gripe with this book is the art. While I'm not the biggest fan of Francesco Francavilla's work, it's not his pencils that bothered me. I really disliked the colors particularly the saturated oranges, pinks, and reds. I understand the intent behind using them but for me they did more to distract than to set a tone. Some colors were effective especially on the final few pages, but I really wished they would have toned them done a little. The pencils are simple but perfectly fitting and if not for the colors the art would almost match the high quality of the story. 

    Scott Snyder's run on "Detective Comics" is destined to be a classic one. Sadly it feels like the great ideas he has for the book will be some of the bigger casualties of the DC relaunch. This is another fine issue and one that leaves me itching for the next book. You definitely should be reading this series

    Other reviews for Detective Comics #879 - Skeleton Key

      Can't get a 5 when the art is a 2.5! 0

      Alright, alright, let me halt the hype train that is word of mouth about Detective comics. Scott Snyder has been doing excellent, excellent work writing this, researching it and coming up with wonderful twists on villain motivations. In "Hungry City", he researched banks and the reader really feels the difference when they are talked up to for a change! His Tiger Shark has an interesting way of speaking to Batman through his henchmen and is part of a sort of lineage of ancient pirates and sea pe...

      9 out of 11 found this review helpful.

      Stuff Nightmares Are Made Of. 0

      Hands down, this has to be one of the best issues of Detective Comics that doesn't even involve Batman.  And why should it?  This is between blood.   One of Scott Snyder's main strengths lies in his ability to build tension and give the appropriate pay off.  Snyder's run on Detective Comics has been incredible.  His arcs have gotten more and more personal for the characters and they've been reaching darker territory.  Black Mirror explored the challenges of being tested in Gotham and possiblity ...

      5 out of 6 found this review helpful.

    This edit will also create new pages on Comic Vine for:

    Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.

    Comment and Save

    Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Comic Vine users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.