shawn87's Batman: Year One #1 - Batman: Year One review

    Avatar image for shawn87
    • Score:
    • shawn87 wrote this review on .
    • 6 out of 6 Comic Vine users found it helpful.
    • shawn87 has written a total of 597 reviews. The last one was for

    Rise Of The Dark Knight

    The Story:  
    The focus is on the first year of Batman's career as the Dark Knight. James Gordon arrives in Gotham and begins his quest to bring justice to the city. Selina Kyle begins her masquerade as Catwoman and the public confuse her as being Batman's assistant to her displeasure. The beginning of a mutual friendship between Batman and Gordon begins.  

    My Thoughts:  
    Written by legendary writer Frank Miller, this story was scribed before I was even born. The story still holds up for coming out back in 1986. What I didn't expect was that the primary focus seemed to be on Gordon rather than Batman. While I did like his part in this comic a lot, I felt he overshadowed Batman in it. Gordon's part was well written though and very interesting. From the beginning where the other police don't accept him as one of them, to his kiss with Sarah Essen and lastly to the beginning of his alliance with Batman. For me, Gordon stole the show in this. Batman's part was great, don't get me wrong. It was fun to see some of his first stunts as the Caped Crusader and how he developed into a symbol for justice.

    One thing I didn't like was the lettering in some parts. Some of it was hard to read. I had to pull the comic closer to my face to attempt to distinguish the letters a lot. I don't like having to do that when reading comics. 

    The art is by David Mazzucchelli who has garnered a considerable amount of praise for his artwork on this series. Call me crazy but I don't see what the hype is about. At first glance I didn't like it at all but by the end of the comic it did grow on me a little. But overall I didn't like the art that much. It feels really outdated and in my opinion doesn't hold up in this day and time. I definitely stuck it out for the story, not the art.

    Even though I don't think this is as good as most people think, I would still recommend reading this especially for all Batman fans. It's an essential piece of his characters history and deserves a spot in your collection.  

    Rating: 4/5

    Other reviews for Batman: Year One #1 - Batman: Year One

      Batman Begins 0

      Amazing, just like Batman Begins movie (is it a coincidence? That the movie just came out in 2005?). It's the most appropiate word for this excellent piece of art, Mazzucchelli and Miller really nailed the very nature of the Batman with this 4-part arc, i don't know if it's because i'm a BIG fan of the Batman (since i was a kid, like Mazzucchelli) Or it's because i own this story on it's 2005 reprint that features afterwords by Mazzucchelli and Miller themselves. The writing it's pretty strong, ...

      10 out of 10 found this review helpful.

      Frank Miller has done it again! 0

      After the stunning "The Dark Knight Returns," Frank Miller has again written a Batman story reguarded to be among the best ever written. After exploring the end of Batman in "TDKR" Miller now shows us his vision of the beginning of Batman, Batman: Year One. This is a brilliant book. Gotham City is literally a dump. Mazzucchelli perfectly illustrates Batmans world. Everything looks muddy and grimy. The characters all look stunning too, the art work is just great, I'm seriously lost for words.Year...

      7 out of 7 found this review helpful.

    This edit will also create new pages on Comic Vine for:

    Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.

    Comment and Save

    Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Comic Vine users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.