Watchmen (2009) or Avengers: Infinity War (2018)?

Watchmen

It's a toughie for me. Both are in my top 5 CBMs of all time. I'll have to think long and hard about this.

Watchmen stomps.

IW is a great popcorn flick to watch with the kids. I need to be in the right state of mind for watchmen. For me, watchmen.

IW by a landslide

watchmen.

Watchmen

Watchmen and it's not close.

IW for sure

This.../\

Watchmen. Not really close even though I love IW.

Watchmen one shots.

My top 5

1-The Dark Knight

2-Batman Begins

3-V for Vendetta

4-Watchmen

5-Logan

Watchmen is the better movie, but Infinity War's hype was unparalleled besides Endgame, and it was more fun.

Endgame is better than IW. Watchmen but its close.

This ^, Infinity War was the better movie on first watch but Watchmen got better for me on re-watch so Ima go with it.

Infinity War stomps

Both are incredible movies and deffo top 10 CBM movies.

I'll go with Watchmen, but it's extremely very close, and certainly not a stomp.

Both are top CBMs for sure

IW stomps tho

Really surprised so many people went with Watchmen. I thought people really didn't like that movie?

I do think Watchmen’s low reviews is kind of strange. It’s basically really good in most general categories.