Rorschach vs. Sherlock Holmes

Rorschach

Sherlock Holmes

Conditions

• Feats from RDJ movies only
• All feats for Rorschach allowed
• Standard gear
• No outside help

Rounds

Round 1:

• 1 day prep each, set in neutral city in the 21st century; assume both are familiar with technology, customs etc.
• In-character
• Each thinks the other is a killer
• Both have no info on each other
• Whoever finds the other first wins

Round 2:

• No prep
• Pure hand-to-hand
• Standard gear
• Morals off
• Set in hospital

Who wins?

------------------------

For the rest of my battles, click here!

Round 1: Sherlock.

Round 2: Rorschach. Much better fighter.

Rorschach was able to figure out Ozy's plan mostly by himself, that show he is a very skilled detective, i say he wins round 1.

Round 2 is stomp for Rorschach, he just puts Sherlock inside a fridge and wins.

Sherlock.

Rorschach in both rounds. Unless Holmes knows who Rorschach is and where he is, there's not much specifically either can do with the prep.

Sherlock both rounds.

Rorschach both rounds.

Rorschach. He breaks bad guy's fingers . That makes him stronger than Sherlock

Sherlock clears.

Sherlock clears