Inigo Montoya vs. Madmartigan

"Prepare to die."

vs.

"I am the greatest swordsman who ever lived."

---------------------------------------------

-In Character

-Not Bloodlusted, but they both have their reputation to uphold

-Madmartigan has a broadsword, Inigo has his father's sword

-Fight takes place on Weathertop

Best Thread Ever.

@texasdeathmatch said:

Best Thread Ever.

seconded. but now i need to go back and rewatch these movies :p

Montoya

My name is Inigo Montoya. You killed my father. Prepare to die

because of this Montoya wins

Madmartigan killed a dragon though! With two heads!

Madmartigan would dominate this.

"I don't love her, she kicked me in the face!"

@texasdeathmatch: Willow was great but im here for The Princess Bride reference myself. dissapoint I cant find anything on youtube to remind me of madmartigan's skill.

Baah ill go with Inigo cause he was a BOSS

"My mother RAISED us on Blackroot! Puts hair on your chest!"

"My mother RAISED us on Blackroot! Puts hair on your chest!"

The sword fight in The Princess Bride was one of, if not the, best action scene that I've ever seen. Over 20 years later and it still holds up. What movie is Madmartigan from? Never heard of him.

@Pokeysteve: Willow, great flick. He kills a hydra and is generally a badass throughout the entire movie, with some great quotes under his belt as well.

Can't believe the amount of awesominess in this fight il go with Mad Mardigan

@OmegaDynasty said:

@Joygirl said:

"My mother RAISED us on Blackroot! Puts hair on your chest!"

That made me smile.

I'll say Inigo

@Joygirl said:

@Pokeysteve: Willow, great flick. He kills a hydra and is generally a badass throughout the entire movie, with some great quotes under his belt as well.

I'll have to check that out. Princess Bride is one of my favorite movies though so I'll always lean towards Inigo =]

Inigio is more technically sound and my personal favourite of the two but I think this goes to Madmartigan

batkevin74 hit the nail on the head. One's a fencer, and one's a fighter. Inigo CAN win here, but I would put my $$$ on the battle hardened warrior, Madmartigan, to take the majority.

Bump for a second round of action.

Madmartigan has an intense variety of barfighting mixed with soldiering mixed with overall luck. Though Inigo actually gets stabbed several times and still manages a fight, and still manages to extract justice, Martigan has a tendency to run boozefaced into battle and win because he's that darn great. Plus a hydra! How many people can say they were turned into a pig and still managed to beat a hydra?

Maddie for the win!

@texasdeathmatch said:

Best Thread Ever.

Bump!

Montoya wins

Martigan wasn't all that impressive

@OmegaTheDestroyer: He killed a hydra bro.

In a strait up sword fight I'd say Montoya wins.

Mad mardigan ftw,,both are highly skilled but inigo doesn't have the feats to compete with mad mardigan

Bumpz

Awesome thread. I have no idea who would win.

indigo because of that mustache

This is a pretty good battle. Killing a two-headed dragon is definitely more impressive then anything Inigo did. I also see defeating General Kael as more impressive then defeating Count Rugen, but I guess that could be a separate debate.

It pains me a little because I like Inigo more, but Madmartigan clearly has the better feats. Therefore I say Madmartigan after a long hard fought battle.