I solved the One To Rise, One To Fall, One to Die Mystery

#1 Posted by BlueLantern1995 (2448 posts) - - Show Bio

Only part I am kinda not sure about is the rises part the rest is officially solved(in my mind anyway):

Tim Drake rises to Robin(reason why not sure is because he may already be Robin at beginning of game...though I doubt he is), Aqualad "falls", and Tempest(if he's playable he's a member) dies. Makes perfect sense to me.

#2 Edited by cattlebattle (12768 posts) - - Show Bio

I would think Dick Grayson ascends and Tula dies. One thing I have learned from Young Justice is...expect the unexpected though, so I really do not even know anymore

#3 Posted by cattlebattle (12768 posts) - - Show Bio
@BlueLantern1995 said:

@cattlebattle: Tula does die but Tempest couldn't live without her...we all know he joins the team but no evidence has been shown that she does. I predict Tempest's death. Zatanna could be the one to rise...rise is a unknown variable the other 2 are pretty firmly cemented in my mind anyway.

Well, Its possible that Tula and Garth broke up over the time skip so him not being able to live without her is questionable, Garth, Kaldur and Tual were all life long friends, her death could have been what cause Garth to leave the team
 
I would figure Tula was on the team being Nightwing referred to a mission she was apparently on when she died
 
I agree..any of the hints could mean anyone, I would be prone to think Nightwing rises due to him not even being team leader at the end of season 1
#4 Posted by X9 (757 posts) - - Show Bio

That sentence "One will rise. One will fall. One will die" appears when the backgroud image is from the group of the first season. That being said, I think the one who rirses is Robin (to the leader position as Nightwing) the one who "falls" is Aqualad (pretending to join forces with his father) and the one who "dies" is Artemis (she fakes it, but, to most characters, she's really dead and she's gonna be treated as if she was by the other from now on)

And honestly I think we've had enough of these speculations...

#5 Posted by CrimsonCake (2677 posts) - - Show Bio

Maybe they'll reveal it in the game.

#6 Posted by Bestostero (5618 posts) - - Show Bio

@CrimsonCake said:

Maybe they'll reveal it in the game.

Seeing that the tagline is specifically for the game. I'm sure it will. Should also note that because the game takes place during the five year gap, anything that occurs post the time skip can't be it (i.e. Artemis fake death)

#7 Posted by papad1992 (6829 posts) - - Show Bio

@X9 said:

That sentence "One will rise. One will fall. One will die" appears when the backgroud image is from the group of the first season. That being said, I think the one who rirses is Robin (to the leader position as Nightwing) the one who "falls" is Aqualad (pretending to join forces with his father) and the one who "dies" is Artemis (she fakes it, but, to most characters, she's really dead and she's gonna be treated as if she was by the other from now on)

And honestly I think we've had enough of these speculations...

That actually sounds really plausible and the one speculation that really makes any sense!!

#8 Posted by Twentyfive (2845 posts) - - Show Bio

@X9 said:

That sentence "One will rise. One will fall. One will die" appears when the backgroud image is from the group of the first season. That being said, I think the one who rirses is Robin (to the leader position as Nightwing) the one who "falls" is Aqualad (pretending to join forces with his father) and the one who "dies" is Artemis (she fakes it, but, to most characters, she's really dead and she's gonna be treated as if she was by the other from now on)

And honestly I think we've had enough of these speculations...

Thank you, sir. This series seems to be riding on that, and in my opinion, that is what is dragging this show from being great. It is just okay right now. Some episodes are good, but nothing separates as great from the rest of the good shows.

#9 Edited by Impulse_KidFlash (2 posts) - - Show Bio

Only part I am kinda not sure about is the rises part the rest is officially solved(in my mind anyway):

Tim Drake rises to Robin(reason why not sure is because he may already be Robin at beginning of game...though I doubt he is), Aqualad "falls", and Tempest(if he's playable he's a member) dies. Makes perfect sense to me.

I think Tim Drake is already Robin in the game and I think it`ll make more sense If Aqualad Falls to the villain`s side as a double agent, while Nightwing rises as the team leader. As to who dies, It can`t be Tempest because I checked the young justice wiki and he appears on episode 20 of season 2 "Endgame". I think the one who will die will be the twelvth mystery villain that they haven`t revealed yet. I read from some places that he`s an exclusive to the game. So if he doesn`t appear later in the season, then he`s probably dead.

#10 Edited by jorok_goldblade (69 posts) - - Show Bio

We know from producer comments that the team members who came and went during the five year gap were: Tempest, Aquagirl, Robin (Jason Todd), Troia, Sergeant Marvel and Lieutenant Marvel (assuming those are the YJ versions of Mary Marvel and Captain Marvel Jr.)

Of those characters, Tula and Jason are known to be dead. I'm assuming the "one will die" is one of them.

#11 Edited by Magmaster12 (56 posts) - - Show Bio

@jorok_goldblade:

We know from producer comments that the team members who came and went during the five year gap were: Tempest, Aquagirl, Robin (Jason Todd), Troia, Sergeant Marvel and Lieutenant Marvel (assuming those are the YJ versions of Mary Marvel and Captain Marvel Jr.)

Of those characters, Tula and Jason are known to be dead. I'm assuming the "one will die" is one of them.

I think it's been pretty clear from Tula's the one that will die since Tim is already Robin.

#12 Posted by jorok_goldblade (69 posts) - - Show Bio

@jorok_goldblade:

@jorok_goldblade said:

We know from producer comments that the team members who came and went during the five year gap were: Tempest, Aquagirl, Robin (Jason Todd), Troia, Sergeant Marvel and Lieutenant Marvel (assuming those are the YJ versions of Mary Marvel and Captain Marvel Jr.)

Of those characters, Tula and Jason are known to be dead. I'm assuming the "one will die" is one of them.

I think it's been pretty clear from Tula's the one that will die since Tim is already Robin.

Yeah- knowing where things were at the start of season 2, I'd say:

Tula dies

Kaldur "falls" into the hands of the light

Nightwing rises to the mantle of leader.

#13 Posted by MESBD (12 posts) - - Show Bio

This edit will also create new pages on Comic Vine for:

Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.

Comment and Save

Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Comic Vine users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.