dark_noldor's Young Avengers #1 - Style > Substance review

    Avatar image for dark_noldor

    Don't play with alternate dimensions

    Young makes me think of cool, younglings, fresh from the oven, without the harsh reality crust that envelops people (and characters or at least it should) as responsability and experience claim their toll. Young also rings a bell to the synonim of "new": ideas, concepts, characters, creative team, narrative structure, way of organizing a book and so on.Taking this two thoughts together, it's safe to say that Gillen's revamp of the Young Avengers sums up some of the fresh and new I mentioned before, especially if you consider the storyline,the narrative structure and that the characters are really young. Though I enjoyed the dialogues so much, it really reminded of Gillen's JIM, especially the ones between Noh-varr and Kate Bishop, unfortunately what started as a mind blowing issue, felt apart after the initial pages, proving that there isn't any really new or fresh about this book. Sure, the plot is mildly interesting, but I was really into the initial five pages, they were exceptional, then deliver all the atention to Hulkling and Wiccan (though I liked these characters in the initial volumes of Young Avengers), just to see another alternate dimension story, it felt a little boring to me, but new kids will definitely enjoy this book a lot. I feel I'm not being quite fair with Gillen and McKelvie, it was a pretty decent first issue, funny dialogues (even laughed about the J.R.R. Tolkien remark), but just not enough to capture my full atention. Also, I wasn't very happy with the lack of explanations regarding: 1) Loki's role with Wiccan's powers are yet to be explained; 2) Noh-Varr's relationship with Kate Bishop (did I miss something?); 3) Wiccan's intolerable and unforgivable desire to get into trouble, eve after all his past life experiences (he changed his mind quite easily right? From lecturing to sinning in a blink). If the plot didn't please me very much (I didn't like Wiccan's actions), McKelvie really delivered a spectacular issue, changed my whole concept about him as an artist and just for the first five pages showing Kate and Noh-Varr I think it was totally worth it buying this comic book.

    Other reviews for Young Avengers #1 - Style > Substance

      Terribad? 0

      This is probably the Marvel Now! Series I was most looking forward to I am a huge Young Avengers fan and they haven’t ever had an ongoing so when this was announced I couldn’t wait.PlotNoh Varr and Kate Bishop are in a spaceship but they are attacked by Skrulls soon after Kate wakes up. Hulkling disguises himself as Spider-man and takes out some thugs but he encounters Wiccan when he gets back to his house.ReviewThis was a really strong start to the series and it is well worth picking up and thi...

      13 out of 13 found this review helpful.

      Finally the Young Avengers are Here 0

      I've never really been a fan of Young Avengers having never really read them, but after hearing that Loki would be joining them, as well as Kieron Gillen writing I thought I'd give it a try, and have been looking forward to reading it.PlotThis issue is split into separate stories that introduce the characters, which includes former Young Avengers Wiccan, Hulkling, and Kate Bishop, and the new additions of Noh-Varr, Miss America, and Loki.ReviewAlthough this issue wasn't quite as good as I expect...

      11 out of 11 found this review helpful.

    This edit will also create new pages on Comic Vine for:

    Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.

    Comment and Save

    Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Comic Vine users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.