X-Men's monthly voting thread (November)

#1 Posted by time (5173 posts) - - Show Bio

Following in the same footsteps as the me and have decided to create a monthly voting thread for the X-Men comics. Giving people the opportunity to vote for there favourite character of month, favourite title of the month etc.

We have decided to do this to celebrate the changes coming to X-Men comics with Marvel Now.

As with all voting threads, there always a time scale, when people can cast there votes.

The voting starts today. Today date is :

15 November 2012 and the closing date will 15 December 2012

After the closing date we will presents those results.

If your unsure about what titles are release this month, here is a link to a website that list those titles.

http://www.comicbookresources.com/?page=article&id=40453

At any time untill December 15th, you may edit your vote. If you have any questions, feel free to ask! :)

Here are the categories :

Best Writing

1st

2nd

3rd

Best Interior Artwork

1st

2nd

3rd

Best Cover Artwork

1st

2nd

3rd

Favorite X-Men Comic

1st

2nd

3rd

Favorite Male Hero

1st

2nd

3rd

Favorite Female Hero

1st

2nd

3rd

Favorite Villains of the month

1st

2nd

3rd

Best Moment of the Month

1st

2nd

3rd

Best couple of the Month

Not sure how many couples will be in the X-Men comics in Marvel now, but we given you the opportunity 2 vote for two couples.

1st

2nd

Best friendship of the month

Best friendship of the month is any interaction with the X-Men characters.

1st

2nd

3rd

Wild Card: Best Ending of the Month

1st

2nd

3rd

In most categories, we have given people the opportunity to vote three times, to make it more fun. Please only vote on this thread for comics release in November.

We appreciate if people take part in this.

Let's start voting.

#2 Posted by The Poet (8170 posts) - - Show Bio

Well, this is cute...

Moderator
#3 Posted by McKlayn (1120 posts) - - Show Bio

I want to start off by saying I am all for voting like this, seems really cool but you got to make the next one Longer then a month. Some books only release one issue a month, at most two and that's if nothing gets pushed back. Also trying to look back and remember what came out when and how, it's a bit of a pain for something that should be fun So a wider range i think should be used, with that in mind i did the best i did without trying to hard :-p

Here are the categories :

Best Writing

1st - Rick Remender - Uncanny X force

2nd - Kieron Gillen - Uncanny X Men / AVX: Consequences

3rd - Brian Wood - Ultimate X Men / X Men

Best Interior Artwork

1st - Stuart Immonen - His issue of All New was stunning

2nd - Phil Noto - X Force

3rd - Carlos Pacheco - Uncanny xmen

Best Cover Artwork

1st - Stuart Immonen (Cover to All New)

2nd - Julian Totino Tedesco (Uncanny X force)

3rd - David Curiel (AVX Consequences 5 )

Favorite X-Men Comic

1st - Uncanny X Force

2nd - AVX Consequences (IT SHOULD COUNT!)

3rd - All New X men (yes i know its only one issue but we are only talking about issues released in Nov so some books only get one a month soo lol)

Favorite Male Hero

1st - Cyclops (He was right :D )

2nd - AOA Nightcrawler (Go go X force )

3rd - Magneto (Villians it is!)

Favorite Female Hero

1st - Magik (Breaking out Scott and being a total Bad ass)

2nd - Domino (Her work in X men is fun, and her team up with Daredevil was great)

3rd - Ultimate Shadowcat (whats not to love right?)

Favorite Villains of the month

1st - Sinster

2nd - The Avengers?

3rd - Hellfire Brats

Best Moment of the Month

1st - "Villians it is!"

2nd - the Return of the Original 5

3rd - Wolverine telling Cyclops he looked up to him

Best couple of the Month

Not sure how many couples will be in the X-Men comics in Marvel now, but we given you the opportunity 2 vote for two couples.

1st - Kitty and Iceman win by defualt?

2nd

Best friendship of the month

Best friendship of the month is any interaction with the X-Men characters.

1st- Mags and Scott :-p

2nd - Beast and Iceman (it's good to at least see them talking again lol)

3rd - Uhmm Kitty & Storm ?

Wild Card: Best Ending of the Month

1st - Consequences #5 "Tell me what you have changed"

2nd - All New X men # 1 Ending

3rd - Not sure if this was in November? But the ending of Uncanny X men

In most categories, we have given people the opportunity to vote three times, to make it more fun. Please only vote on this thread for comics release in November.

We appreciate if people take part in this.

Let's start voting.

#4 Posted by MadeinBangladesh (8070 posts) - - Show Bio

cool

#5 Posted by time (5173 posts) - - Show Bio

@MadeinBangladesh said:

cool

Well I hope you take part in the voting.

#6 Posted by Queso6p4 (1465 posts) - - Show Bio

@time: I definitely have to come back later on and put in my three votes.

#7 Posted by time (5173 posts) - - Show Bio

@Queso6p4 said:

@time: I definitely have to come back later on and put in my three votes.

cool. Hopefully before the closing date.

#8 Posted by broo1232 (1520 posts) - - Show Bio

Best Writing

1st Rick Remender Uncanny X-force

2nd Kieron Gillen Uncanny X-men

3rd All new X-men I liked it!

Best Interior Artwork

1st Stuart Immonen All new x-men

2nd Carlos Pacheco Uncanny X-men

3rd Phil Noto Uncanny X-force

Best Cover Artwork

1st Julian Totino Tedesco Uncanny X-force

2nd Stuart Immonem All new X-men (connecting cover was great.)

3rd Carlos Pacheco Uncanny X-men

Favorite X-Men Comic

1st Uncanny X-force

2nd All new X-men

3rd Uncanny X-men

Favorite Male Hero

1st Wolverine

2nd Beast

3rd AoA nightcrawler

Favorite Female Hero

1st Psylocke

2nd Shadowcat

3rd Rogue

Favorite Villains of the month

1st Daken

2nd Skinless man

3rd Sinister

Best Moment of the Month

1st Evan putting on the Apocalypse armour

2nd Sinister s return

3rd Return of the orignal five

Best couple of the Month

Not sure how many couples will be in the X-Men comics in Marvel now, but we given you the opportunity 2 vote for two couples.

1st Kitty and Emma

2nd Northstar and Kyle (is this allowed?)

Best friendship of the month

Best friendship of the month is any interaction with the X-Men characters.

1st Kitty and Storm

2nd Beast and Iceman

3rd Kitty and Iceman

Wild Card: Best Ending of the Month

1st All new x-men #1

2nd Uncanny X-force #33

3rd Uncanny X-men #20

#9 Posted by time (5173 posts) - - Show Bio

Best Writing

1st - Bendis - All new X-Men 2

2nd - Kieron Gillen - AVX: Consequences 5

3rd - - Bendis - All new X-Men 1

Best Interior Artwork

1st Stuart Immonen All new x-men 2

2nd - Stuart Immonen All new x-men 1

3rd Phil Noto - X Force

Best Cover Artwork

1st - Stuart Immonen (Cover to All New)

2nd - David Curiel (AVX Consequences 5 )

3rd - Phil Noto - X Force

Favorite X-Men Comic

1st - All New X-Men 2

2nd - All New X-Men 1

3rd - AVX Consequences 5

Favorite Male Hero

1st - Magneto

2nd - The 2 Iceman's in All new X-Men 2

3rd - Beast or Cyclops. I will go with Cyclops

Favorite Female Hero

1st - Jean Grey, glad she back

2nd - Storm, in All new X-Men 1, she was pretty cool.

3rd - Magik

Favorite Villains of the month

1st - Daken

2nd - The Avengers

3rd - Prison Warden in AVX Consequences 5

Best Moment of the Month

1st - the Return of the Original 5

2nd - Magik and Magneto breaking Scott out

3rd - Magneto threating Cyclops

Best couple of the Month

Not sure how many couples will be in the X-Men comics in Marvel now, but we given you the opportunity 2 vote for two couples.

1st - Past Cyclops and Jean Grey

2nd Kitty and Iceman, cause there no one esle.

Best friendship of the month

Best friendship of the month is any interaction with the X-Men characters.

1st- Mags and Scott

2nd - Beast and Iceman

3rd - The past X-Men were pretty cool

Wild Card: Best Ending of the Month

1st - Consequences #5 "Tell me what you have changed"

2nd - All New X men # 2 Ending, The Original X-Men take off on the X-Jet

3rd - All New X men # 1 Beast meeting the past X-Men and telling him why he came to there.

#10 Posted by RedQueen (1171 posts) - - Show Bio

Best Writing

1st Rick Remender - Uncanny X-force

2nd Brian M Bendis- All New X-men

3rd Kieron Gillen- Uncanny X-men

Best Interior Artwork

1st Stuart Immonen- All New X-men

2nd Olivier Coipel - (Has he done an issue for November?)

3rd Phil Noto

Best Cover Artwork

1st- Scottie Young - he counts right?

2nd Stuart Immonen

3rd David Curiel - Consequences 5

Favorite X-Men Comic

1st All New X-men 1/2 ...can't quite decide

2nd Uncanny X-force

3rd Uncanny X-men

Favorite Male Hero

1st Beast

2nd AoA Nightcrawler.

3rd Magneto

Favorite Female Hero

1st Jean Grey

2nd Emma Frost

3rd Magik and Ultimate Kitty tied for third place.

Favorite Villains of the month

1st The Avengers :p

2nd Daken

3rd "Rogue" Cyclops

Best Moment of the Month

1st Past/Present X-men meeting their counterparts - so awesome!

2nd Gah, I was going to say AoA Nightcrawler destroying Blob, but that happened ages ago...

3rd Magik breaking Scott and co out of prison/sending some inmates to Limbo

Best couple of the Month

1st Past Jean/Past Scott

2nd Kitty and Bobby

Best friendship of the month

Best friendship of the month is any interaction with the X-Men characters.

1st Beast and any of the other X-men, more so Iceman

2nd Magneto/Cyclops

3rd Annnddd....?

Wild Card: Best Ending of the Month

1st End to All New X-men #1

2nd Ending to Uncanny X-men? Did that happen last month?

3rd End to All New X-men #2

#11 Posted by tomlikesfries (4884 posts) - - Show Bio

Best Writing

1st Remender - Uncanny X-Force #34

2nd Bendis - All-New X-men #2

3rd Bendis - All-New X-men #1

Best Interior Artwork

1st All-New X-men #2

2nd All-New X-men #1

3rd Uncanny X-Force #34

Best Cover Artwork

1st Immonen - All-New X-men #2

2nd Immonen - All-new X-men #1

3rd Tedesco - Uncanny X-Force

Favorite X-Men Comic

1st Uncanny X-Force #34

2nd All-New X-men #2

3rd All-New X-men #1

Favorite Male Hero

1st Wolverine

2nd Deadpool (Uncanny X-Force)

3rd Iceman (present)

Favorite Female Hero

1st Psylocke

2nd Jean Grey (from the past)

3rd Magik

Favorite Villains of the month

1st Daken

2nd Present Cyclops

3rd Sabretooth

Best Moment of the Month

1st Magik, Scott and Magneto recruiting that mutant girl in All-New X-men #1

2nd Wolverine's fight with Daken

3rd Return of the original 5.

Best couple of the Month

Not sure how many couples will be in the X-Men comics in Marvel now, but we given you the opportunity 2 vote for two couples.

1st Yeah, gonna put the same as everyone else - Past Jean and Scott.

2nd Kitty and Iceman

Best friendship of the month

Best friendship of the month is any interaction with the X-Men characters.

1st

2nd

3rd

Wild Card: Best Ending of the Month

1st All-New X-men #1

2nd Uncanny X-Force #34

3rd All-New X-men #2

#12 Posted by AgeofHurricane (7303 posts) - - Show Bio

Wow.

The votes so far are somewhat cringe/chuckle-worthy.

#13 Posted by TheCannon (19462 posts) - - Show Bio

The most recent X-men comic I've read is from 1998. Sorry.

#14 Posted by HopesummersFORtheFUTURE (4178 posts) - - Show Bio

Best Writing:

1) Kieron Gillen

2) Jason Aaron

3) Bendis (ANXM)

Best Interior Artwork

1) Carlos Pacheco

2) Stuart Immonen

3) Phil Noto

Best Art Cover:

1) Carlos Pacheco

2) Stuart Pacheco

3) Phil Noto

Favorite X-men Book

1) All new X-men

2) Uncanny X-men

3) Wolverine and the X-Men

Favorite Male Hero:

1) Cyclops

2) AoA Nightcrawler(uncanny x-force)

3)Teen Iceman is hilarious

Favorite Female Hero:

1) teen Jean dream

2) Hope summers

3) Storm or Kitty

Favorite Villians of the Month:

1) Daken (new leader of the Brother of evil Mutants

2) Hellfire Brats

3) Mr. Sinister

Best Moments of the Months:

1) Return of the Original 5

2) Teachers being brainwashed by Frankensteins murder circus

3) Magneto and Scott break out emma frost ANXM3

Best Couple of the Month:

1) Teen Scott and Jean (are they a couple yet???)

2) Iceman and Kitty

3) Emma and Scott ( the break up)

Best Friendship of the Month:

1) Kitty and Iceman

2) Scott and Erik

Wild Card:

1) ANXM #2

2) Uncanny X-force #34

3) All New X-men 3

#15 Posted by thespidey307 (177 posts) - - Show Bio

Best Writing:

1st. Bendis (All New X-Men)

2nd. Remender (Uncanny X-Force)

3rd. Aaron (Wolverine and the X-Men)

Best Interior Artwork:

1st. All New X-Men

2nd. Uncanny X-Force

3rd. Uncanny X-Men

Best Art Cover:

1st. All New X-Men #2

2nd. All New X-Men #1

3rd. Uncanny X-Force #34

Favorite X-Men Book:

1st. All New X-Men

2nd. Uncanny X-Force

3rd. Wolverine and the X-Men

Favorite Male Hero:

1st. Cyclops

2nd. AOA Nightcrawler

3rd. Wolverine

Favorite Female Hero:

1st. Past Jean Grey

2nd. Shadowcat

3rd. Storm

Favorite Villians of the month:

1st. The Human Race

2nd. Daken

3rd. Mr. Sinister

Best Moments of the Month:

1st. The Original 5 coming to the present

2nd. Past Jean putting Wolverine to "sleep"

3rd. The Original 5 confronting Cyclops and Magneto

Best Couple of the Month:

1st. Past Jean and Scott

2nd. Iceman and Shadowcat

3rd. Wolverine and storm(?)

Best Friendship of the Month:

1st. Cyclops and Magneto

2nd. Iceman and Shadowcat

Best Wild Card of the Month:

1st. All New X-Men #3

2nd. All New X-men #2

3rd. Uncanny X-force #34

#16 Posted by oviouslyjeangrey (400 posts) - - Show Bio

Jean grey

#17 Posted by HopesummersFORtheFUTURE (4178 posts) - - Show Bio

@oviouslyjeangrey said:

Jean grey

LOL is everything to you Jean Grey???? :-p

#18 Posted by oviouslyjeangrey (400 posts) - - Show Bio

@HopesummersFORtheFUTURE: Obviously

#19 Posted by dangallant984 (1282 posts) - - Show Bio

@time said:

Best Writing

1st - Bendis - All new X-Men 2

2nd - Kieron Gillen - AVX: Consequences 5

3rd - - Bendis - All new X-Men 1

Best Interior Artwork

1st Stuart Immonen All new x-men 2

2nd - Stuart Immonen All new x-men 1

3rd Phil Noto - X Force

Best Cover Artwork

1st - Stuart Immonen (Cover to All New)

2nd - David Curiel (AVX Consequences 5 )

3rd - Phil Noto - X Force

Favorite X-Men Comic

1st - All New X-Men 2

2nd - All New X-Men 1

3rd - AVX Consequences 5

Favorite Male Hero

1st - Magneto

2nd - The 2 Iceman's in All new X-Men 2

3rd - Beast or Cyclops. I will go with Cyclops

Favorite Female Hero

1st - Jean Grey, glad she back

2nd - Storm, in All new X-Men 1, she was pretty cool.

3rd - Magik

Favorite Villains of the month

1st - Daken

2nd - The Avengers

3rd - Prison Warden in AVX Consequences 5

Best Moment of the Month

1st - the Return of the Original 5

2nd - Magik and Magneto breaking Scott out

3rd - Magneto threating Cyclops

Best couple of the Month

Not sure how many couples will be in the X-Men comics in Marvel now, but we given you the opportunity 2 vote for two couples.

1st - Past Cyclops and Jean Grey

2nd Kitty and Iceman, cause there no one esle.

Best friendship of the month

Best friendship of the month is any interaction with the X-Men characters.

1st- Mags and Scott

2nd - Beast and Iceman

3rd - The past X-Men were pretty cool

Wild Card: Best Ending of the Month

1st - Consequences #5 "Tell me what you have changed"

2nd - All New X men # 2 Ending, The Original X-Men take off on the X-Jet

3rd - All New X men # 1 Beast meeting the past X-Men and telling him why he came to there.

yeah, pretty much.

This edit will also create new pages on Comic Vine for:

Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.

Comment and Save

Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Comic Vine users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.