1 - Scrap the entire concept and creative teams, start from a clean sheet of paper because what we have now is so utterly and completely broken no amount of tinkering can make it acceptable much less exceptional. I understand there are fans of the book and I am not slamming you on your taste in comics, this is just MHO on the state of the title.
2 - Forget trying to do what has been done before (New Mutants, Gen X, Academy X, Avengers Academy, etc.) and design the book for the world of today. Taking into account the state of the Marvel U with Marvel NOW and all the recent X-events and not just ignoring the consequences that happens all too much nowadays. While all of those books were better than this one, they all were designed for a different age.
3 - Hire a creative team that will actually take the book in a serious direction. The current book is damn silly and slapstick it belongs in a What-If? or kids line of books, IMO it is insulting to even read. How can everyone be smiles and giggles after the events of recent years? This is not to say the tone needs to be doom and gloom, but it at least has to show the characters not acting like a Monty Python sketch. If Marvel could grovel enough to Brian K Vaughn and convince him to write this I would tap dance in a tutu on You Tube for your enjoyment at my expense.
4 - The staff needs to be slimmed down to a core of 4 at the most, and the characters used have to show that the X-Men take the entire "training the next generation of X-Men" thing seriously. There are a lot of names that could be thrown out based on how you decided to divide the responsibilities, but the current staff is just a complete joke. If you need to keep Wolverine in the title for sales purposes make him a combat instructor, having him as Headmaster is like having the Punisher take Hank Pym's job at Avengers Academy.
5 - The students need to be slimmed down to a core of 8 at the most, we have all seen what happens when books expand to a cast of dozens by now and its about time to learn from those mistakes. Make the core 8 the group closest to graduating to X-Man status, focusing the action on them while showing other students in smaller roles. Over time students graduate and are put on other teams and background characters take on larger roles. Rinse, dry, repeat. The New Mutants went 100+ issues before moving on and they really never graduated, the current students just get tossed on teams when its obvious none of them have been around long enough to be qualified (Armor, Pixie) its just a popularity game.
6 - The X-Mansion needs to go back underground again, the idea of a public school and having it attacked and/or blown up every 12 issues is a tiring concept and makes the writers and characters looks stupid. There are enough graves in the backyard for someone to realize the world is not ready for acceptance and maybe we should try to keep the kids alive long enough to graduate one day. You can rebuilt it or move it (Utopia) but the end result is still the same, when bad guys know where you live they will attack you there.
7 - The team needs to interact with the other teen teams (Young Avengers, Runaways, etc) on a regular basis. If Marvel decides to not bring back any kind of Avengers Academy training team you could even bring non mutant staff and students into the book. The point of the X-Men was human and mutant co-existence, what a kooky concept to actually put it into practice yourself and live and teach side by side.
8 - Allow the book to run its own course and not get hijacked by events, aka the Peter David HiJack Insurance
9 - Limit the number of new students that appear and join the school. Marvel has now twice tried to introduce droves of new characters at once and neither time did it work out for the better, three is not a charm.
10 - Comments Welcome
Log in to comment