Poll What if Magneto had a human son/daughter? (31 votes)
Do you think it would make for a good story if Magneto either had a new kid or finds out about a past child who is human with no powers?
Team » X-Men appears in 13416 issues.
Do you think it would make for a good story if Magneto either had a new kid or finds out about a past child who is human with no powers?
Something about this seems familiar. Not sure if it was Magneto, or at least 616 Magneto, but I think someone was ashamed of their non-mutant child. I'll look into it.
I'm not much of an X-Men reader, so maybe this isn't my area of expertise.
Edit: I think Scarlet Witch was said to be human during House Of M.
@v_scarlotte_rose: It was Quicksilver
EDIT: Also, Magneto DID have a human daughter
@night4345: Luna is a telepath.
@fallschirmjager: Your one of those OsbornStacy shippers aren't you?
Negative.
I ship Batman and Superman though.
@fallschirmjager: Superman would have to carry the child thought, since he is an alien and all.
Kryptionians come out of "birthing matrixes" where are kind of like washing machines.
@fallschirmjager: Superman would have to carry that child thought, since he is an alien and all.
Naw. Batman has prepped for this encounter and created a surrogate mother for it.
@fallschirmjager: Wonder Woman? This all sounds like the plot for Batman v Superman: Legal Custody Battle Over Super-Son.
The opening scene is a NC-17 three way with them double teaming Diana.
@papinacho: Batman likes gadgets to much to not build a bat birthing machine.
I read somewhere that Briar may be his daughter. I don't know if it's true then.
nah briar is another mutant and also she probably will be magneto's next lady love
I click here because i thought Magneto already accepted Luna as human .....I left because some combination of Batman, Superman, and a birthing chamber were having a custody battle with Wonder Woman.....I now need a drink
LOL
@goonage: To be totally fair, we don't know for sure that she was human.
Magneto has had four human children over the years. Mutants are human.
took the words right out of my mouth.
It might mke for an interesting story if Magneto were to have or find out he has a child who is not a mutant. It could end up being somewhat similar to the situation that occurred when Graydon Creed was around being the child of Sabretooth and Mystique. In my opinion it would be far more interesting for Magneto's daughter Anya to be brought back somehow or be discovered alive. I've thought that it could be interesting to delve more into his relationship with Astra and why she was so obsessed with him to go as far as making a clone. Briar Raleigh would also be an interesting twist if she were his daughter, but like someone mentioned she may end up being a love interest.
This Briar seem to be a little spooky. I mean, I know she want to help Magneto, but why? Why help him when because of him she almost lost her leg (I think). Magneto having another kid would be good to see and a human would probably be a little tough to deal with. Maybe the human son or daughter can unite the mutant and human. How cool this would be? I'd think it was cool.
@v_scarlotte_rose: It was Quicksilver
EDIT: Also, Magneto DID have a human daughter
we don't know about Anya... she could have manifested powers once she aged... she was too young when she died to be sure
@devilsgrin81: We've seen other mutants use their powers in cases of emergency even before they hit puberty.
I remember Wanda was human in House of M, and Wolverine was really surprised by it. I thought it was an interesting twist!
Plus Magneto's children looked AMAZING in House of M.
I think it would be a cool, story triggering plot device to have one of his children, or a new child, be human, considering how he feels about them.
I suspect he'd be in denial and try to force train and overstimulate the kid to see a mutant power manifest, which could lead to one heck of a crazy human and potentially an interesting solo comic. I'M ON BOARD.
He will kill him or she , without thinking
This I doubt it. You people think everyone is really evil. If something like this would happen, it would change Magneto for good. He characterisation will change for good. And I'm sure you wouldn't want that (in this case you probably want Magneto to kill him lol), but that what would happen if he got a human son. He will try to live in peace like he always wanted but only this time, siding with the humans. The human kids would probably be the one who's going to change the world just like Magneto wants. Sharing the planet together in peace and there would be no war unless if the political corrupted between nations. You know like now, people still have conflicts and disagreement for over oil, drugs, economic ect. But he wouldn't kill him you silly person lol :)
Please Log In to post.
This edit will also create new pages on Comic Vine for:
Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Comic Vine users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.
Log in to comment