@McKlayn said:
@Osian2 said:
A. Morally wrong yes but it was necessary. Let's not forget that Logan is continuing X-force
B. This decision worked out fine didn't it? (Struggling to remember)
C. He did care, otherwise he wouldn't have even bothered to rescue them. He assembled his best team (x-force) and sent them to rescue them immediately
D. He did use X-23 to kill but it's not like he forced her it was her decision to be a member. Logan even tried to convince her out of joining but she made the decision on her own. He did not "use" Idie at all he literally said "Do what you feel you have to". It was Idie that made the decision to kill she could have stayed hidden or even escaped but SHE did what SHE felt like SHE had to. If Jubilee were in Idie's place do you think she would have killed?
E. Finding out that he was messing with your mind warrants getting kicked out. Xavier preaches responsibility and control but doesn't follow his own teachings.
F. He could have just incapacitated him so Scotts reaction was extreme but he was acting in self-defence and he even gave Xavier multiple warnings about what would happen if Xavier didn't stop.
G. This was IMO his worst decision but Cable was acting crazy.
H. On the brink of extinction it's a smarter choice to defend yourself on Utopia than stay at a school.
I. Scott did try and stop the schism. He offered a change of leadership via election but Logan didn't want anything to do with it.
J. Being Naive about the phoenix? Unit proved Scotts faith to be right. If anyone was naive it was Tony for shooting the Phoenix and the Avengers/X-men for provoking Scott constantly until he became Dark Phoenix.
K. Because Jean never and I mean never disrespected her relationship with Scott right? How many times did she kiss Logan again? Hell if Logan didn't refuse her she would have had an affair with him. As for kissing on her grave I agree that it's a douche moment but it was because Jean altered his mind. He would have rejected Emma and left otherwise.
L. He doesn't use children as cannon fodder at all. He let's them be team members but he doesn't push them in front of the enemy. They have a choice he's not forcing them into anything. Schism showed that the kids are free to leave at any point. Just because Wolverine made a big deal about not wanting kids to fight it doesn't mean Scott was throwing them into the fire. Even during schism he was prepared to fight the sentinel by himself and didn't even ask the kids to fight, they volunteered.
uhmm yea what he said
Bravo, bravo!
Log in to comment