A lot people think Grant Morrisons and Joss Whedon were some of best writers for the X-Men. I think they were pretty much overrated. While Morrisons portray Emma Frost really well, the best I have seen from her character so far. I felt he had no understanding of Cyclops and Jean Grey marriage and I didn't think he understood Cylcops character at all and he made him look like a total jerk as well. Then Whedon, while the portrayal of the characters was written well, like the interactions with kitty and Emma, they were really good. The stories he wrote was nothing really special and while he return Colossus, he sent Kitty packing, make sense much.
So are they overrated, are they actually better writers, then the writers from the 80's and the early-mid 90's. How many of you think so?