Is Schisms the worst X-Men story, ever. Looking back at X-Men history, can anyone think of a story that more poorly written than Schisms?

@time: Onslaught, and the entire X-men run of Chuck Austin.

Idk, AvX is taking the cake right now.

Have you bothered to read Avengers vs X-Men?

Along with AVX yes, yes it is

X-Men story? X-Men story!!  AVENGERS FANS ASSEMBLE!!!!!! :p

@BlackArmor said:

Along with AVX yes, yes it is

Pretty much I sure as hell can't think of any

@Dman1366 said:

Idk, AvX is taking the cake right now.

Y'all better listen to him.

@x_29 said:

@time: Onslaught, and the entire X-men run of Chuck Austin.

You beat me to it.

@BlackArmor said:

Along with AVX yes, yes it is

I'm inclined to agree.

Does the Ultimatum event count as the X-men were apart of it?

Most of everything involving Madelyne Pryor was fairly ridiculous

@x_29 said:

@time: Onslaught, and the entire X-men run of Chuck Austin.

I liked the premise of the first Onslaught story but not the execution, particularly the final showdown.

@Dman1366 said:

Idk, AvX is taking the cake right now.

I think the first AvX was actually better than this newer one but we'll see.

@MarvelGrey said:

Does the Ultimatum event count as the X-men were apart of it?

*Cringes* We shall not speak of such horrors.

I didn't really see the point to Schism. I suppose now Marvel is happy they now have another major selling book.

AvX...no words...

Schism is the most rushed x-men story ever written. Just four issues and one tie-in for the so-called biggest X-plit? Give me a break.

No.

@John Valentine said:

No.

My goodness no... there have been plenty of awful X-men stories... Schism just seems to have that reputation because of how recent it is... if anything, it is most in jeopardy of simply being forgotten in time, rather than remembered as being particularly awful... even in the most glorious of glory days, there is always some form of bad X-Men story being written...

(And I like the Chuck Austen run! Albeit from a semi-giggly standpoint...)

Now that I was going through my collection Quarantine belongs on the list as one of the worst stories.

@time said:

Is Schisms the worst X-Men story, ever. Looking back at X-Men history, can anyone think of a story that more poorly written than Schisms?

No, AvX definitely takes the cake for that one