@oldnightcrawler: Mystique is a great villainous leader but i wonder what her motivations are besides causing chaos. I would love for her motivations to go beyond being a mutant terrorist with no heart. She must have one, to have loved Destiny and her children the way she did. But writers tend to neglect that in favour of depicting her as a psychotic killer. It's seems like such a shame that she isn't given more shades of grey, especially with how sympathetic of character she is in the movies. If she could perhaps follow in the footsteps of Magneto as some kind of "anti-villain" who's bad deeds can be justified by good intentions, I know she would be a far more compelling character.
I think in some ways the way that Mystique was written when she operated with Destiny fit this description even better than Magneto ever did, in so far as Magneto didn't seem to think of himself as a villain until recently.
Take DoFP: Mystique and her Brotherhood are attempting an assassination, and, in that way, don't seem especially dissimilar to several other fanatical X-men villains. The X-men stop them and become the heroes. But if one considers that, on some level, Destiny must have realized that they would fail, it certainly brings the subject of her motive into question. Looking at it that way, it almost seems that they were attempting an assassination so that the X-men would be the heroes, which obviously makes mutants look better than if they had succeeded in their assassination attempt.
But it goes a bit deeper with Mystique herself; because, as readers, we can't know how much she knows of what Destiny knows, making her motives as questionable and mysterious as her namesake. Remove Destiny from the equation, and Mystique seemed like a more methodical version of what Magneto had been; but, given that we know Destiny is Mystique's confidant, we have to constantly second guess what she thinks she's doing and exactly what her motives are.
In the first story I read with Mystique, I watched her cunningly kill all of the X-men, only to have it be revealed that of course they were all robots. Ostensibly, she seems to be training to fight the X-men because they had taken in Rogue, who she wants to come back to her side. Except that, when fighting the robot X-men, she kills Rogue with as little hesitation as the rest. It makes it clear that she feels she must be willing to kill any or all of the X-men, regardless of her personal feelings.
Later in the same story, the Brotherhood has laid a trap for the X-men which, as readers, we are led to believe is only a distraction so that Mystique can infiltrate the school and talk to Rogue alone. Except that, if defeating the X-men has already been established as the mission Mystique's been training for, it makes it seem as though Mystique is really just distracting Rogue from being involved. Yet, when infiltrating the school, she shoots Xavier with a gun designed only to knock him out; so, if she actually wanted to defeat the X-men, why not have just killed him?
My point is that, with how Mystique was classically written, as partners with Destiny, you could never really pin down what her actual objective was. Was she simply a more methodical and pragmatic version of what Magneto had been (which, in itself would be interesting), or was she a character repentant of her past, willing to be the villain in order that the X-men would have an arch foe to become heroes against? That we could never know for sure was really what made her such a complex and interesting character.
Log in to comment