I would definitely love to see an X-men Institute RPG. Creating my own mutant and go through the life as a student up to a full fledged X-men. Not sure how I would prefer it to play out, though Mass Effect will most likely be one of the better ones to take influences from in my book. 
 
Just has to be a thing where they don't rush to things where you become the only one that can save the planet within the first two hours. I would really want to work up to a climax of that magnitude.
 
Also this would probably be one of the best ways to get new people into the Marvel universe by literally taking them to school. To give them lessons taken from the history of the previous X-men and what has happened in comic books and cartoons.

Is there a T-shirt or a sweatshirt with that design at the top?  I don't care how much it costs, I WILL F-ING PAY IT!!!

That would be my dream video game right there.

WANT, WANT, WANT!
I really hope they don't end up somehow turning this into something like a visual novel. That would be so incredibly dissappointing.

" Is there a T-shirt or a sweatshirt with that design at the top?  I don't care how much it costs, I WILL F-ING PAY IT!!! "

I basically want Person 3 with X-People.

It's not a bad idea, its just got to be focused. The only thing is the powers that the player creates at the beginning have to clearly evolve as the game progresses, example: cyclops optic blast- lvl1 straight shot, lvl2 aim (first person targeting), lvl3 bounce surfaces, lvl4 big shot, lvl5 etc...  
 
And traditional turn based fighting would suck, if it weren't an MMORPG. The real world setting of X men demands more physics based fast paced action. The game would also have to have enough events to breakup the everyday routine: Juggernaut smashing though school walls, attacks in New York, Protect Morlock Peace rally, Find Lost Student, Black Bird flight training, etc.  Or if your a rebel: spray paint turf, prison breaks, car theft, gang wars, etc.
 
Then specialized missions based on the makeups of the players powers: bomb defusing=electricity, reconstruction after fights=telekinetic, information gathering=telepathy, house fires=water. 
 
The real question is if the game were mostly school years (Bully), missions as an X man (inFAMOUS), or a hub-world of New York that the player goes on to some greater mission from. 

(For a What If? New Mutant "Squad Era") Your character makeup makes different students like you better starting off, strong friendships make "bonds" that insure students will be on your squad. The team changes and grows-up together. On key missions (Savageland, Genosha, Asteroid M, Deep Morlock Tunnels, Madripoor, Muir Island, Mutant Town, Hell Fire Club London, Mountains Canada, Egypt, etc) characters can die, never to comeback, but maybe replaced with other students. A balanced thought out team would make power combos and that cause additional effects to the enemies and environments.
 
Got to be an action RPG though... 

Actually, that remind me a game like harry potter , 1 &2 on gameboy advance if my memory's well, we growed up thanks to sessions of class , but it was restrictive to the story , so replace it with your ideas will be a good think ^^
 
a french guy .

You should change your direction on life and become a game producer. =)

We've all seen the so-called pre-existing X-men lists to choose from in video games. Normally they include most of the core characters and then add in one or two others just to be different. What the game should do is give you a selection of X-men teams or even better yet, a certain decade and then a selection of teams. This way the game would include a vast array of powers and personalities... After all, what's a Role-play Game without the role-play? Oh wait... it would just be pretty much any other RPG then. The missions could include actual stories from the comics, but perhaps you could also design your own missions... sort of like what City of Heroes/Villains already does.

i love any game where we can create and customize our character. i'm in love with the idea of training to become an x-men. that just means throughout the game we'd be gaining more power and different skills that can be used with whatever certain power your character has. i liked playing the x-men legends games on psp, and how the power system worked on there but if this would be anything like that, except with an oc, it'd be a thousand times better.

Interesting...
 
I'll probably get addicted to this game verrry quickly

i'm really excited!!!! 

It sounds fantastic, so long as it is not a "turn based" fight system. Stick with the MUA style and that is a winner IMO.

I WANT THIS GAME NOW!!!!!!! Go for it!! I need it. I think it would be better if played on a console but could also be played on the computer. Oh and there should be tons and tons of options and designs for clothes, hair, characteristics, etc.

i'd play a game like this. Even though i kind of already role-play  it regularly. But as for video game wise the closest thing we have to the game so far is X-men Legends.

This would be like, the game of my dreams.

X-Men Legends 3: Legends in the Making 
 
I like this idea as a legends but without the make your oewn character option. The other Legends played with continuity (to the point Rogue didn't know Destiny) so just giving the cast of characters and letting the interactions dictate the progression would be awesome.  
 
I could see a online Xavier institute game like what you descrbed, with mods as the original X-Men.

I would buy this without a second thought.

" Just saw there was a cool map of the grounds. Wonder if anyone's ever made a plan of the interior?  

not bad
but wat i don't get is why they have a pheonix memorial statue.
wasn;t it a curse?

this 

would 

be
 
AWESOME!!!!

this knd of a game would be fun. Id play it!

My idea would X-Men Legends mixed with GTA 4.....

Get where I'm going with this.....

As long as it doesn't include those horid Pink & Gold outfits I'd play it

"

My idea would X-Men Legends mixed with GTA 4.....

Get where I'm going with this.....

"

I would love it.  Like City of Heroes, except better!

This is X-men destiny...

I wonder about the genre, is it going to be a tactical RPG (KOTOR, DA:O) or more of an action RPG (The Witcher, Fable).

Personally I'm inclined to go with action, it would just be more fun to aim.

But considering it's Activision, I'll settle for a game that doesn't explode.

 Instead of switching sides halfway through, you should choose one at the beginning so in essence it becomes two seperate games. But yes this would be awesome, especially if there were a ton of powers (not just the obvious popular ones) and a lot to explore.