Possibly. The only thing that concerns me about Magneto is that if the prequel were to follow the track I used in X-Men, which is Magneto's history in the concentration camp, then I've lived in that world.

I don't know, I don't know. There are still issues...I just...I just don't know. I don't necessarily...I don't know. It's one of those things where...It's so weird talking about stuff unless I'm about to ramp up and shoot it.

Singer did a good job on X-Men 1 and 2 and I wouldn't mind seeing him return. Also, Magneto's origin doesn't necessarily have to pick up in the concentration camps. I'd rather it picked up with him as the family man. I'd love to see the act that transformed him forever. But thats me.

Ha ha!  He ditched the X-Men in favour of Superman, then when Wolverine becomes a box office hit he wants to go back to the X... what a surprise.

I know alot of people feel the same way as you do. But all I care about is who's going to put out the better film. In my mind that's Singer. If he comes back and makes a hit all will be forgiven.

Brian Singer please return!!!!!!!

The lack of it look at what happened: X3, X-Men Origins: Wolverine and Deadpool!

YES! :D

I think X-Men 2 was my favorite though I loved seeing the Ice Armor in X3

I'm guessing he  "Don't know"

For the love of all things holy keep this loser away from Superman. This tool turned my favorite hero of all time into a little boy watching pansy. Don't get me wrong Singer has done some decent stuff. I love House it is a great show but he needs to let go of the comic book genre. ESPECIALLY SUPERMAN! I for one thought that Ratner's X-men wasn't that bad it was more action packed.

I honestly feel that he did an awesome job on the Superman movie, it always seem to me that he would follow up with another one it  is kind of upsetting that he would not even speak of it.

As for a Magneto origin movie no thanks, the back story in X-men 1 was all that I needed. Now if they want to do a House of M movie I am all for that, at least in that story Magneto wins.

Singer ruins everything so no thanks to this. They should wait for Jon Favreau to finish whatever he is working on and let him take a crack at X-men if we really need more X-Movies.

The Singer Superman was great!  And I don't think the problem with X-Men 3 was the directing, it was trying to do too much in one moive.  Just stick with one major storyline at a time please!  It could have easily been divided into three movies and they could have done justice to each plot.

You can tell by his speech that he has scarred himself with his own works.

I would love to see Singer return to the X-Men.

Honestly I would love to see him return... X1 and X2 were decent movies.

I hated superman... (blah)

Come back to the X-men Franchise, I think we can expect big things to happen within the x-men movie franchise in the very near future..

A Magneto movie is a lame idea.  

I'd be happy with Singer returning to the X-Men franchise.  I'd try real hard to forgive and accept Ratner if an X-Men movie was offered to him, but I doubt many fans would.  

It's similar to Spider-man 3; Raimi followed the screenplay and what the producers wanted.  As you stated, G-man, that's also what Ratner did.

That's the point:  Ditch the writers.  Get someone else.  Someone who wouldn't bastardize and Deep-6 the important points and characters that comprise the X-Men.  I believe it was mentioned here on Comic Vine that the X-Men  writers admitted they "didn't like Prof. X and Cyclops" and that's why the changes occured.  WTF? 

However, how Singer could have been so blind to the God-awful concept behind Superman Returns escapes me.  

I'd consider this whole "young X-Men early years" thing, but I don't know.  They could do that, but what about any future X-men movies that follow after the events of X-3? 
 

I Know a lot of people will say that the first two movies X1 and x2 were good, but i still think that looking back at them They Sucked! Just because the third movie was such a down point dose not give the other two any validity. We need someone to take a good x-men story "not hard, they already exist." and make it into a movie. Why were both punisher and hulk  movies just ok or flat out sucked, they were made for kids or "teens".  Real fans will never be happy with a 50's ideal comic book,   movie instead of taking a comic book  and making into movie. "if that makes sense." we need good dialog and story, we need to feel like it's real.

 I don't think He's are man.  but marvel isn't going to want to either. 

They should just re-do the whole franchise

Honestly, singer isn't a good action movie director,the action scenes in X-Men I and 2 was so flat and boring, and the plot in the first one was crap also.
 X 2 was ok  but nothig exciting
conclusion: i don`t want Bryant Singer in any other future X movie.

Seems like Raimi and Singer want to do justice to their comic book movies

I agree with the others when they say : "They should just re-do the whole franchise".... But considerin how far Marvel has repersented the X-Men in movies so far... with its dead characters an nonscense story lines... I dont really care now, when it comes down to the Movies... If anything Id say NO for Singer comin back in...  not cuz hes a good director or not ... Just cuz actions speak louder than words... hints: leavin X hangin for a Superman movie?

I'm not a real, true die-hard X-Men fan, so I'm not sure there was that much difference between Bryan Singer and Brett Ratner. X3 gave me what I wanted which was The Beast, Iceman and Angel. But at the expense of Cyclops and Jean. Does anybody miss Cyclops? Is there enough of a window for his to return? X3 was action packed and seemed to expand more on the set-up that Bryan Singer laid out. If there were flaws, I guess I overlooked them.

Yes, I would like to see Bryan Singer return to the X-Universe. His vision of Superman sucked. Brandon Routh was just very vague as Superman. Using Luthor was just one too many times to the well for me. I would like to see him working on whatever X-Men movies he would like to because he seems to get the characters. 

Honestly, I would like to see Tom Welling get at least one chance at playing Superman. Give him a haircut. Have Richard Donner direct it and give him room and space to do it his way. Pit him against Brainiac. Make Brainiac more like Ultron. (I haven't really followed Brainiac on Smallville that closely.) Then, if that works, put him together with the rest of the classic JLA. And then, it rained gumballs. The end.    

I'm still hoping for X-Men 4, but Magneo would be cool

I liked the first two X-Men movies and i really liked the 3rd. i don't know why people hate on it so much. Magneto lifting the Golden Gate bridge sold me. i didn't like Superman Returns. two big problems with that movie--Superman is a baby daddy and Lex Luthor seduces an old lady for her money. These two things are not in line with their characters. I think Brian Singer had his chance with Xmen, it's time to move on. He chose to do Superman instead of Xmen. either do the next Xmen or  find another superhero. If he want's to go and do stuff he's done already why not do Usual Suspects 2: the Wrath of Kaiser Soze.

Bryan Singer is sooo hot!
Especially for his age, He looks amazing for 43.

Too bad he's gay    =(
Anyway, I'd love him to return to the X-Men franchise ^^.
And yes, I think he would have made X3 better, He'd have introduced good characters such as Emma Frost which would have made a great storyline.

and he probably would have kept Mystique ! - Which X3 completely got rid of.

PLEASE no more superman movies. how many bad superman movies do we have to see?

I'm mixed on the whole situation. While I liked the X-Men movies he did, I do hope that he has gotten a better grasp of the whole thing from his experience with the X-Men movies he did. Cause there was alot of corn in the first two, but there was also alot more substance too their stories as well.

I don't see why he's worried about the the "been there done that" bit with the Holocaust/Nazis. Look at Wolverine--they spent maybe 15-minutes with him being a young kid and all the wars. Magneto's childhood could easily squeeze into 15-minutes without being too heavy handed.

Maybe McKellan should be more worried playing the "other side" after his role in Apt Pupil.