@Avenger85 said:
Hank must be regretting his little time-travel stunt now. Who expected Jean to start controlling ( Yes, CONTROLLING via brainwashing/mindwipe like Xavier did ) the team via her telepathy ? This seems like a start of a more ruthless, darker personality for Jean. She now has something in common with Current Scott's team. She might even join that team after mindreading Current Scott and what he's gone through. Seems like young Jean Grey is the new Emma Frost/ Bad Xavier ? The look of shock/fear on both the current and young X-Men teams in the last panel says it all.
Also, Little Scott really is becoming a badass leader now. The way he confronted Captain America and talked to him, shows that he's becoming the alpha male that he became in Whedon's run. This guy is going places, as he just grew a pair of BALLS. Logan, of all people is really IMPRESSED with him, that says it all. This issue shows why Cyke will always be a better leader than Jean, for the O5.
But since last issue/s final panel and this issue, I don't know where the relationship between young Scott and Jean will go. Maybe she will use her telepaty in a more aggressive way to help young Scott get stuff done ? Can't say wether that wedding invitation he gave her had a positive, or negative effect on it.
Bendis seems to be really twisting the characters here, making them alot different from their original versions. I have mixed feelings about this direction that he's going, TBH lol.
@Veitha said:
I've also thought that Jean Grey is very Emma Frost-ish... well, without the sense of humor, the revealing costumes and the murky past. But I really can't see her using her TP that way, maybe the Phoenix Force is coming back(I hope it's not returning)?? Or maybe it's just Bendis writing Jean as a young Emma Frost, and Emma as an old Jean Grey
Yeah, I had mentioned in another thread that Jean had actually done this before: she had altered Kitty Pryde's mother and father's memories during the "Dark Phoenix Saga" and it was a sign to Ororo & Scott that she was becoming darker. Which is very interesting because Professor X used to do it all the time in the Original Team days and he did it again to Magneto years later, leading to the events of "Fatal Attractions".
To be honest, though, I always think of this as a logical endpoint for a telepath in the same way that characters with super senses use it to figure out what someone else's emotional state is or an empath would use their powers to calm down someone who is irrationally angry. I don't necessarily think modifying behavior is bad or dark - it's bad because it is very rarely by choice and is less effective than doing the same to a person who honestly wants help modifying their thoughts and behavior. Forcing someone to do something else or altering memories is actually a high level telepathic feat (most telepaths can only read or project thoughts), but characters who do something by their free will tend to make longer term changes than if a psychic forced them to do it. They can debate the morality of it all they want, but when you have mutants with larger scale powers who probably trigger larger scale damage because they use their powers in combat, I'm not convinced this is an evil or dark use of telepathy.
And the issue definitely shows why Cyclops is the best leader in the X-Men stable, IMO. Different characters bring different strengths, but Scott never took the shortcuts other X-squad leaders did, and he put in the work.
Log in to comment