zack_freeman's X-Men #9 - To Serve & Protect, Part 3 review

  • Score:
  • zack_freeman wrote this review on .
  • 13 out of 15 Comic Vine users found it helpful.
  • zack_freeman has written a total of 351 reviews. The last one was for

Review: X-Men #9

The X-Men gets their hands dirty in the sewers as they discover that Spidey's foe, the Lizard, is in cahoots with an old mutant enemy.
 

The Good

I can think of no other artist save Bachalo who can deliver such kick ass superhero action with such flourishing artistic panache. The expressive palette he uses in the coloring just kicks up the detail, weight and texture of his already superlative work. And I was pleasantly surprised by the reveal of the old foe who returns in this issue - - it's felt like an age since I've seen him

The Bad

While I have just waxed rhapsodic about Bachalo's coloring, I will say that it's still a little rough around the edges at parts, with colors spilling past the lines of where they'd ought to be. If that's price of such inventiveness, then so be it, but I'd really love some tightening to put it up and over the top. The surprise guest's voice also didn't sound as diabolically erudite as I'm used to.

The Verdict - 4/5

The mission statement of this book seems to be about putting the X-Men against monsters totally unrelated to the mutant world. Putting aside my love affair with Bachalo's art (if only for a moment) I'll say I'm digging this book just by the merit of how it plays the children of the atom versus lizards and vampires - - creatures totally alien to the rules of their little pocket of the universe.
2 Comments
Posted by Blue_Shield

Good, straight to the point review. I liked it, and agree, it's nice to see the X-Men out of their "normal" element.
Moderator
Posted by Nasar7

Funny you mention how good the art is; it wasn't really doing anything for me.

Other reviews for X-Men #9 - To Serve & Protect, Part 3

    Revenge of the Nerds 0

    I guess what seemed like a good and interesting arc story turned out to be just another batch of the same old, same old dull "let´s fight the lizards in the sewer and now Spider must battle with his mutated friends" kind of story. The characterizations of the X-Men weren´t good, the dialogues weren´t interesting, even the atempts of emulating Logan and Spider jokes and banter didn´t work. The only thing interesting in all this mess is actually the whole nerd kids that will serve as good experime...

    6 out of 8 found this review helpful.

This edit will also create new pages on Comic Vine for:

Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.

Comment and Save

Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Comic Vine users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.