keith71_98's X-Men #18 - Betrayal in the Bermuda Triangle, Part Three review

Decent, but lacks the fun factor & visual appeal...


The coolest things about writer Victor Gischler's current X-Men story arc has been the great character moments we get with the X-Men's team-up with The Future Foundation and the fact that this story has felt fresh and unlike any of the other X-books. Issue #18 gives us a few good character exchanges and a little bit of the cool and fresh world, but not enough to make this quite as enjoyable as the previous two issues. This isn't a bad book and Gischler does move his story along. But as it unfolds and the focus moves more toward the alien races, I haven't been able to stay connected to it. The Scorpius and their king don't do a lot for me although their connection with Doom is pretty cool. 

The art in this issue also fell off a bit. Pierfederici takes over for Molina and it's quite noticable. The book lacks a visual consistency both in the environments and especially the characters. Costumes look different from one panel to the next and there are occasional issues with body proportions. Also I couldn't help but notice Pierfererici's weird version of Wolverine's mask. But he does do well drawing both the Scorpius and Kaddak. I only wish the human interpretations were as consistent as the aliens. 

It sounds like I'm really railing on this book when it's actually a decent issue. The story still has some intrigue and if Gischler gets back to the fun character moments, this thing could finish well. But this issue just wasn't as satisfying and it left me wanting more from it.

0 Comments

Other reviews for X-Men #18 - Betrayal in the Bermuda Triangle, Part Three

    Not as Bad as it Could Be 0

    The previous books in this story arc (after the first one) were so bad that my brother refused to even pick up this issue.  I definitely saw this arc (plus the fact that the book seems to have morphed in to X-Men teamups) as being the biggest reason I was going to drop this book from my pull list and just pick up trades of whatever stories seemed good.  So it's somewhat faint praise to say that this book was better than the previous ones.  I have to say that a lot of that goes to Doom having a m...

    1 out of 2 found this review helpful.

This edit will also create new pages on Comic Vine for:

Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.

Comment and Save

Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Comic Vine users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.