keith71_98's X-Men #15 - First To Last Part 5 review

Satisfying ending but it should have been more.

X-Men #15 brings the conclusion to Chris Yost's roller coaster "First to Last" story arc and while the ending is fairly good, it's not completely satisfying. The last issue ended with a riveting cliffhanger of sorts found in the question "What have you done" directed at Cyclops. Unfortunately that question's answer isn't as profound or controversial as the buildup and neither is this finale. 

Yost should be given credit for his creative approach to telling his story. He's telling two stories that have converged during the last two issues and there's some genuine and significant new information given about the X-Men's past that could be built upon in the future. And while the past and present stories do meet with a reasonable amount of clarity, as I read this issue I found myself constantly waiting for something bigger and better. It's certainly not a bad issue or a bad series but it didn't feel as though it lived up to it's potential. 

Medina and Talajic continue to split the art duties with one handling the past and the other the present day work. While their artwork isn't horrible, it's seemed to have digressed as the story has moved along. This issue had some interesting panels and the Evolutionaries look really cool. But many panels look cluttered and the characters look even more stylized that before. There are some snazzy looking action sequences and some crisp, vibrant colors. But as a whole I wasn't that impressed with the look of this issue. 

"First to Last" has been an arc that's certainly worth reading. But it's also one that feels like it could have been more. Yost's mode of storytelling is layered and creative and, for the most part, he pulls it off. But I still found myself wishing for more.


Other reviews for X-Men #15 - First To Last Part 5

    Evolution - Whether You Want it or Not 0

    In Christopher Yost's "First to Last" conclusion the X-Men finally make their move in the past and the present to take on the Evolutionaries and save mankind. While the Evolutionaries want mutantkind to take its rightful place as the dominant species on Earth, Cyclops and the X-Men don't want all of the normal humans to pay the price for it. In a last ditch effort by the Cyclops of the past and the Cyclops of the future, a machine that can separate the cosmic power from the Evolutionaries. But i...

    1 out of 1 found this review helpful.

    Review for X-men #15 0

      A very well done ending to a good story-line, although it may be a little hard to follow at times due to the two different times in this story.  I enjoyed this one, it revealed a lot about Emma Frost that we didn't really know. It also showed what lengths the team leaders and members would go to, to protect humans, even though they are very different. The Evolutionaries can be quite the villain at some points, at other times they seem like they are doing what is necessary for the survival of m...

    6 out of 7 found this review helpful.

This edit will also create new pages on Comic Vine for:

Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.

Comment and Save

Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Comic Vine users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.