harleyquinnhawkgirl's X-Men #1 - Curse of the Mutants, Part 1 review

Let the war of the mutants and vampires BEGIN!


Story: The story starts out with Pixie and Jubilee hanging out together. Jubilee is no longer a mutant and has been ignored lately. The day quickly goes awry when a sucide bomber for the vampires detonates where they are. Jubilee now has a virus that the bomber set off. Downtown Wolverine, Pixie, and Angel are scouting out for a hideout. Wolverine finds it and it soon turns into a vampire versus mutant battle. Wolverine finds out that they've established a beachhead and that Dracula is in town. 
Writing: This story kind of feels like a quick big story arc to throw into the Marvel universe. I am a vampire fan and I was looking forward to this issue but something felt missing. 
Characters: I wasn't impressed with the character roster in this issue. It was cool to see Jubilee but I felt Pixie was just a random choice. I was actually looking forward to seeing Emma Frost but she wasn't  in it. 
 Dialogue: There wasn't anything too special about the dialogue in this issue, but I did like the dialogue about Dracula. 
 
Art: It felt cartoony. 
Cover: I thought the cover was really good except that over half the characters on the cover weren't in the issue. 
Penciling: This issue felt very cartoony. I was hoping the art was going to be more serious. 
Coloring: I thought the colors should of been darker and mysterious not bright and cartoony. 
 
Favorite pages and why. 
4: The explosion was pretty cool. 
15-17: I loved the fight scene. 
20 and 21: The beachhead was cool. 
 
Reasons to and not to pick up. 
Reasons to pick up:
To see the vampire war begin and because this is a new X-Men title. Some pretty good references to Dracula and nice action. Also to see Jubilee.
Reasons not to pick up: The art really didn't work here and this story is being rushed. Also this wasn't the greatest cast. 
Verdict: Don't pick it up. 3 OUT OF 5. For this rating I was on the fence on wheter to say barely a 3.5 and barely pick it up or not.
1 Comments
Posted by TheWiFiJedi

Great review!

Other reviews for X-Men #1 - Curse of the Mutants, Part 1

    Un-fun, uninspired and ultimately unnecessary 0

    Maybe the title of my review is a bit harsh, but after reading the first issue of X-men, I can’t help but think what the point for this book to exits is?   I suppose the same could have been said for Astonishing X-men when it first arrived on the scene, but unlike Astonishing (at least the Whedon/Cassaday run which was amazing) this title brings nothing new or exciting to the world of X-men. Cover/Art Really like the cover, it’s bold and the great coloring really makes it stand-out. The artwork ...

    4 out of 5 found this review helpful.

This edit will also create new pages on Comic Vine for:

Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.

Comment and Save

Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Comic Vine users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.