@Stammer6 said:
I've been really happy with most of the writing so far in the volumes I've read including X-23. Though I won't deny that there are a few things that make me raise an eyebrow. Maybe someone could shed some light on these for me?
WARNING: SPOILERS BELOW
X-23 Target X: They introduced a character by the name of Kimura. They try to RetCon her into the Innocence Lost series by explaining that she was around to keep X-23 in check, to offer a backup in case things got out of hand. She appeared to be completely loyal to Rice and his efforts. I have two problems with this. First, if we've already got someone allegedly superior to X-23, someone with little chance of rebellion, someone older and more experienced, wouldn't she have been better-suited for use as an assassin? Hell, wouldn't she have been better-suited as the cloned subject? Zander Rice could still have made his Weapon X clone, but done other things with her. And the thing that bugs me even more, where the hell was Kimura when X-23 and Dr. Kinney escaped? In Innocence Lost it's clear that Dr. Rice was expecting Dr. Kinney to rebel and take X-23 with her. You know someone who is specifically-designed to counter an otherwise perfect weapon. Don't you think having her on standby would have been a good idea? Seriously, where the heck was she?
NYX Wannabe: Man, I freaking hated this series. Laura acted nothing like she does in any of the other series. I think the only thing I have to actually ask about this is why they would bother RetConning Laura's character in Uncanny X-Men when they wouldn't in NYX? She's as out-of-character in that as she was in Uncanny. And on top of that, I seriously fail to understand at what point the series takes place, since it seems Target X takes place immediately between Innocence Lost and the later series.
Childhood's End: I just got to this point in the chronological order of comics, and have only read the first 2 volumes in the series. So far it's been a great read except for one thing: the way Logan introduces Laura to the other X-Men. I seriously find it hard to believe he would introduce her by specifically referring to her as his clone and then proceeding to say that she could easily kill any one of the other kids, "so don't provoke her". Yeah, because that's going to help her fit in, right? She spends all this time trying to become more human, and then Logan just comes up and basically says "This is Laura. She's a weapon, not a person. Have fun," and then proceeds to wonder why the kids aren't giving her a chance.
Subject nr 1 - Kimura is more like a heavy tank, so she is more capable of doing direct, aggresive attacks on her target. X23 is more efficient, silent and (as we see in Target X) underrated because of her age. No one sees her as an killer, that is why she killed that candidate for president in Innocence Lost and some other targets judging by the page with the flashbacks from her previous missions.
Second - the reason why Kimura didn't appear in the innocence lost might be quite simple - the character was never created at the time. Writers would have to think about twenty scenarios if the would like to make a story without any story complications, like those which you are arguing. Besides, she didn't appear during the destruction of the facility, but seconds after (target X). She might have been around.
subject nr 2 - the reason why X23 was out of character in NYX it's because she was just introduced to the comics, so she didn't have her "character" at the time. We see her as a contract killer, but her origin in comics comes directly from being a prostitute. In terms of chronology I see NYX as the third episode of her story, continuation of Target X. by losing her "master" she lost her way of life - doing orders. She does not know how to proceed through life on her own terms, perhaps that is why she found her new master - her pimp. On top of that, the chronology matches her appearance in Uncanny Xmen, where she worked as a waitress, when xmen found her. Maybe she tried to live on her own terms and got herself a job.
Subject nr 3 - More odd things happened in the Marvel universe. We have a telekinetic, rock gorilla and so on, and you refer Laura for being the only one who is capable of killing? The second - Wolverine didn't want to suprise everybody when the would finally discover that is quite a killer. On top of that I thing he wanted to make her socializing a bit more difficult, but in the end giving effects, that is why he reffered her as an killer right in the beggining.
Log in to comment