thatlad's X-23 #3 - The Killing Dream Part 3 review

  • Score:
  • thatlad wrote this review on .
  • 7 out of 7 Comic Vine users found it helpful.
  • thatlad has written a total of 38 reviews. The last one was for

I take it back...

Well I hated this whole Wolverine goes to hell crossover in both x-23 and Daken, two series with great writers which in my opinion should have stood up in their own rights but got dragged into Wolverine's storyline. I thought it was unecessary and bored me, it gave me pause to think about dropping the Daken book. 
Anyhow, Liu has pulled it out of the bag. I loved this issue, so much so it made me overlook the whole wolverine angle.  
The Good 
 Art gorgeous absolutely beautiful and perfect renditions of the characters. Storm looks regal & maternal, Cyclops looks like a leader, Emma looks like a bitch and her posing is great like she's whispering in Cyclops' ear, Gambit well it's just gambit all over but most importantly X-23 looks like X-23!!! She's got the look of a young girl, something a lot of artists screw up by making her look like a late 20's porn star (Greg Land I'm looking at you!!), this artist gets X-23 and conveys her emotions perfectly. Bravo good sir, bravo! 
Marjorie Liu has nailed X-23's character here, she's not emotionally helpless, just lost she's been brainwashed to believe she's only a weapon but Liu makes a point out of showing us she wasn't born like this. It tooks years and a lot of effort to turn her into a weapon.  
I love this issue and this arc overall has been used to demonstrate Laura's motives. Her choice, an important word here, to leave utopia and the x-men needed to be explained and I'm glad Liu took the time to do this. It took remy to spell it out but let's face it he's the perfect choice, he understands what it means to be distrusted by his friends 
The Bad 
Me. Me for jumping to conclusions I should have trusted in Liu 


Other reviews for X-23 #3 - The Killing Dream Part 3

    Laura fights back in Hell. 0

    Laura faces her demons. Pros: Marjorie Liu continues give Laura more of a personality. While she's running in "Hell", she discovers some sort of light that I'm going to assume that it's her "Soul", that shows her a bit of Laura's past when she was part of Weapon X. It does gives off a sense that Laura is more than a killer and that she can choose her own path. That is what she decides to do, and ends up leaving the X-men. Since Gambit isn't doing much these days, I'll be glad to see him tag alon...

    7 out of 7 found this review helpful.

This edit will also create new pages on Comic Vine for:

Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.

Comment and Save

Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Comic Vine users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.