The writer was Gail Simone. Nuff said.

Why is WW #41 the only thing people ever bring up? Kara was possessed by Dr. Alchemy in The Brave and the Bold #7, and there she one-shotted Wonder Woman. No one ever talks about that. Let's just talk about Power Girl losing to Wonder Woman in a fight written by Gail "Huntress can make Shiva sweat" Simone.

Additionally, this is on the wrong forum, adding "For Battle Threads" there in the title does not make it the right forum. This should be on either the PG or WW thread.

Also, the link doesn't work. Also, I hear KMC is nice these days. Hint, hint.

Obviously Gail Simone is gonna side with WW and not with PG. That's like blatantly obvious

@Jorgevy said:

Obviously Gail Simone is gonna side with WW and not with PG. That's like blatantly obvious

Truth. It's like asking Greg Pak for his opinion on who'd win between Hulk and Thor.

@CitizenBane said:

Also, the link doesn't work. Also, I hear KMC is nice these days. Hint, hint.

Works fine for me?
BB

@Billy Batson said:

@CitizenBane said:

Also, the link doesn't work. Also, I hear KMC is nice these days. Hint, hint.

Works fine for me?
BB

Not for me for some reason.

@CitizenBane said:

@Billy Batson said:

@CitizenBane said:

Also, the link doesn't work. Also, I hear KMC is nice these days. Hint, hint.

Works fine for me?
BB

Not for me for some reason.

Update your browser? :p
Here's what she said:

I don't think Power Girl is stronger or faster than Wonder Woman.
Wonder Woman was likely erring on the side of caution.

BB

@fangirl101: Get mad all you want, honey.

And keep in mind that this is the same Simone who wrote Wonder Woman getting one-shotted and reduced to a drooling mess by a banshee in Secret Six before upholding her view as inviolable gospel.

@fangirl101 said:

@CitizenBane: Honey, PG has the stone in her hand. No one counts that. We all know the stone's power. LOL. WW wasn't even one shot. She gets right up. LOLOLOLOL.

Honey, that stone does not add any kind of strength to the user. At all. It never has, in any of Dr. Alchemy's appearances. LOL. Wonder Woman sure didn't make another appearance until PG was all the way in Antarctica. LOLOLOLOL.

@fangirl101 said:

@CitizenBane: PG does fly rather fast. And The stone adds all kinds of powers. Why else would PG hit her with it? You might have had a case if She'd have used her other hand. But you don't.

PG hit Diana with the stone because Dr. Alchemy always holds the stone in his hand, and since he was in Kara's body at the time..........well, do the math, it's simple enough. It has never, ever added strength to the user. Like, ever. You might have had a case if you knew the slightest damn thing about the stone. But you don't.

@fangirl101 said:

@CitizenBane: You might have a case if she didn't hit WW with the stone. An artifact of immense power, that allows the user to do nearly anything. including change their structure and even the structure of others. The stone is glowing and it hits Diana. Period. If I hit you with my bare fist, it's not going to have the same effect as if I hit you with a brick in my hand. Game over. Please make special note of all the red energy flying around as PG hits WW. That's from the stone honey.

The stone is always glowing, sweetheart. And it still does not add ANY strength to the user. You think otherwise? Prove it. With examples from the Flash comics that Alchemy regularly appears in. Good luck with that.

@Gambler said:

Why is the stone glowing? (gonna move this to the WW thread as well) usually thats a visual indication of some sort of power resonating from the object is it not?

It's always glowing. But it has never added strength to the user so it wouldn't have helped Power Girl.

Anyway, I'm quitting this thread. I'm already well acquainted with fangirl101's delusional, rabid fanboyism. beatboks put up with her nonsense for an admirable amount of time, but I do not have his patience. I can only take so much of the ramblings of children. Have fun. The last word is all yours, since I know it's going to be worthless anyway.

@Gambler said:

@CitizenBane: Does it hold an enhanced properties or is it described anywhere? I believe you, not saying I dont. I just think its odd that it glows just to glow.

It lets the user transmute stuff (hence the alchemy part of Dr. Alchemy). That's about it. It's never added strength.

DC comic powers level are all lame DC says Wonder Woman is only weaker then superman in strength but then they try to power her down all the time. Superman is said to be the strongest but captain marvel and wonder woman can match his strength, it all comes down to popularity, superman and any spin-off heroes should not be able to fight any magic based people like captain marvel or wonder woman.

@fangirl101: The tears of outraged WW fanboys.

Seriously, learn to read, kid.

Anyway, I'm quitting this thread. I'm already well acquainted with fangirl101's delusional, rabid fanboyism. beatboks put up with her nonsense for an admirable amount of time, but I do not have his patience. I can only take so much of the ramblings of children. Have fun. The last word is all yours, since I know it's going to be worthless anyway.

I'm not beatboks. I cannot put up with the ramblings of children. Don't expect me to reply past this point, I don't feel like wasting time on one such as you.

Honey's mad.
BB

@fangirl101 said:

As I've stated all along, Powergirl is NOT stronger than Wonder Woman. The writer says so right here.
http://forums.comicbookresources.com/showthread.php?309953-WW-41-Go-for-it-)-Spoilers/page5

Pretty damning evidence supporting your view. Good find.

@FlagSister: LOL ok you totally settled this debate! Looks like GAIL SIMONE what right after all )

I prefer the term outclasses rather than stronger.

Wonder Woman out-classes Power-girl.

@a88378438 said:

@WDW said:

I prefer the term outclasses rather than stronger.

Wonder Woman out-classes Power-girl.

so,you think ww is stronger than PG?

honestly I don't think the question of who is stronger is really relevant unless the situation is clearly defined. There are many instances where Power-girls abilities would be more useful or considered stronger than Wonder Woman's for example Power-Girl as a Kryptonian, does not need to breath or eat, her eye sight is much better than Wonder Woman's and so is her hearing.

However, for the most part people simply want to know who would win in a fight between the two and I would have to say Wonder Woman. She simply outclasses Power-Girl in terms of head to head combat.

@a88378438: In Supergirl: Power (the one that the scans of Kara with MM are from), Supergirl does hit Wonder Woman near the end, but it doesn't have much effect. And it is implied after that that Wonder Woman is strong enough to keep her subdued

@a88378438: Personally I think Wonder Woman is stronger. Kara in pre DCnU was still a teenager and hadn't reached the peak of her strength. As for feats, Wonder Woman helped pull a third of the Earth along with Superman and Martian Manhunter. Flying through a moon requires speed, which Supergirl has in spades, and density, which she also has being a Kryptonian. For me, it's not really a show of strength, but more her invulnerability and speed.

@a88378438: The scan you posted shows Wonder Woman realizing that she can't talk PG out of whatever's wrong with her, and the next two pages show her subdue PG with ease. The book that scan is from, Wonder Woman: Contagion, is written by Gail Simone who said Power Girl isn't as strong as Wonder Woman.