20 Comments Refresh
Edited by rmanthorp

I'm excited for this!

Posted by Dark_Guyver

So is this canon or set in its own universe?

Posted by batmannflash

can the X-Men (Cyclops and Wolverine) finally reunite when this end and bring everything back to normal?

Posted by laabitres

im excited love the narrators voice

Posted by StMichalofWilson

can the X-Men (Cyclops and Wolverine) finally reunite when this end and bring everything back to normal?

Maybe so. Maybe not

Posted by RowdyFromScrubs

@dark_guyver: OGN's are not canon. They are based on canonical events, but then they change course. I'd think of them as really long 'What if...' books

Posted by lifeboy

I wonder why they didn't just do mutants killing humans. That seems more to the point.

Edited by iceslick

@g_man: I'm dying to get this since the day I heard about it! I was gonna ask you how you felt about it in the podcast, but I kept forgetting. I'm just excited to explore more about this future and hope to get a better hand treatment in telling a better story than Battle of the Atom because that story did feel rushed.

@rowdyfromscrubs:@dark_guyver: No, this OGN is in canon unlike the others it details in this article and states why it's put in an OGN rather than a mini-series or an actual event which in my opinion makes better sense since the last story turned out pretty bad because it was rushed. Here's a quote from the article that states it if you don't want to read the entire thing.

"Nrama: You’re doing X-Men: No More Humans as a graphic novel rather than a miniseries. What opportunities does that open up for you?

Carey: I think it does two things. The first is that it sets your stage for you, a little differently than if you were writing an arc in a monthly book. It says this is something that will involve all the X-Men, and have implications for all of them – that it will have something to say about the characters and the themes that are at the core of all the books. Whether I lived up to that challenge is another question, but that was how it felt going into the planning and the scripting.

The other thing about an OGN is that you have much more freedom when it comes to pacing. You can build the story more organically, because there’s no necessity to have episode breaks, cliffhangers, recaps. It’s all cut from one piece of cloth. That meant for example that we could change pace and direction and even cast members without feeling that we needed to anchor those changes to any arbitrary break points. It’s not better or worse, necessarily, but it’s a different sort of storytelling and it gives you different tools to use."


Posted by Lykida

So, after their bro-mantic moment in "Wolverine and the X-Men" #40 Cyke and Wolvie are finally pulling themselves together?

Posted by TheBlackHood

I honestly would rather that Cyclops and Wolverine never reconcile. I enjoy the book with Cyclops, Magneto, Emma Frost, Magick, and zero trace of that overused Mary Sue - Wolverine.

Edited by Dernman

I would have prefered this not be canon but I'm still interested. It's depends on the price if I'll get this.

Edited by Dark_Guyver

@iceslick: Ok, thanks! I'm sure I'll pick this up.

Posted by MadeinBangladesh

WHy are Marvel production team so bad?

Posted by Djainess

Really looking forward to this, hope it's canon too.

And if it isn't, it probably will still be a great story, because, you know, Carey :)

Posted by Jonny_Anonymous

Who needs humans anyway?

Posted by oldnightcrawler

seeing this art and these characters together is exciting..

seeing any connection or reference to Battle of the Atom is a warning flag, though..

I'll probably give it a chance..

So is this canon or set in its own universe?

does it matter?

Posted by Dark_Guyver
Posted by oldnightcrawler

@oldnightcrawler: Does it matter to you why it matters to me? Don't be an a$$.

it was just a question, there's no need to be nasty.

Posted by Alak

I enjoyed Battle o the Atom, and I'm really loving the current Uncanny run right now. This book's a must-buy for me.

Posted by himynameisciara

Looking forward to this!