48 Comments
Posted by Baddamdog

The art is just awful. The back-up was the redeeming feature for me.

Posted by timrothsays
@Baddamdog: +++
Posted by timrothsays

but the story itself is quite nice, tho

Posted by redbull

WTF? The art looks pretty amazing to me. What, are you upset because there's no traced Land porn?

Posted by timrothsays
@redbull: yes
Posted by Alaric

I love where hope's story is going, the art was good too! Not one of my fav artists but yeah waaay better then the traced crap that used to be in the uncanny issues.

Posted by DH69

i liked the 2nd story a hell of a lot more than the first.

Posted by Baddamdog
@redbull: His art is so ugly, so un-aesthetically pleasing, which sometimes is good, if the story suits it, but this one didn't. Now, Olivier Copiel's art in the second feature is good, amazing in-fact.
Posted by Theodore

It was pretty good. 3.5/5

Posted by Edamame
@redbull said:
" WTF? The art looks pretty amazing to me. What, are you upset because there's no traced Land porn? "
lol
Online
Posted by CellphoneGirl

I didn't like the art, but the story was good :] Glad to see them finally showing Kitty.

Edited by War Killer

I liked the tone of the story, like Fraction said in his interview with G-Man at SDCC, they're geeting to tell the stories of new Mutants and how they deal with now being a Mutant, so I'm glad we're getting back to some of those stories, seeing Kitty again and how they update you on her condition is really nice and makes me happy that they're finally getting to show us more about her and why her powers aren't acting right. The art overall did bother me, some of the faces looked really off, especially in like the photographs hanging on the the wall in the first lights room and the picture Wolverine is holding in one panel where everyone just looks messed up, I would have liked Dodson's art on this book more. And some characters just looked off to me. But with the overall story, I enjoyed it and are looking forward to the next issue.
 
Great review, G-Man! :D

Posted by Icon

Nah I thought the art was one of the strong points. I agree about the inconsistencies though. All in all, good review. 

Edited by Amegashita

  Am I the only one that found it odd that Emma would actually call Scott and Logan's relationship a "Bromance"?  I never thought I would ever hear those words come from her mouth.

Posted by Queen's Halo

The art is just bad, I wanna' scratch my eyes out. Dodson or Land would have been much better choices.

Posted by Gawdzilla

Legacy was 5 times better than Uncanny this week

Posted by Alaric
@Gawdzilla: 
 
YES! Totally true.
Posted by sparty-dbq

Based on her actions near the end, I hereby refer to the new mutant girl in this issue as Bipolara.
Posted by waruikumo

meh alright.  Is it just me or is the house of M stuff starting to feel like a modern clone saga?

Posted by Mutant God

I heard Iron Man was in this issue, what did he do?

Posted by G-Man
@Mutant God: Iron Man hit on Emma Frost basically.
Posted by Stormultt

.......
Posted by CaptainGenisVell

I love Coipel's style, would probably get this just for that :)

Posted by A-Strondinaire

Did anybody else notice in the beginning the unnecessary profile for Iceman and Angel about a three point shooter that was just so dumb.

Edited by Comiclove5

Yeah, Second Coming that story did drag on and I really liked this issue 4 out of 5 fire-powered themed red-heads.
Posted by sora_thekey

Oliver Coipel's art is amazing!
Can't wait to read this!

Moderator
Posted by __transgojobot__

Why couldn't they have had Oliver Coipel draw the entire book? I just don't think Portacio's cutting it here; the interiors were just ...ugh.

Posted by The Average Bear
@Baddamdog said:
" @redbull: His art is so ugly, so un-aesthetically pleasing, which sometimes is good, if the story suits it, but this one didn't. Now, Olivier Copiel's art in the second feature is good, amazing in-fact. "
Very well said
Posted by mdb47

Wasn't it the other arm that was messed up for Colossus? In the Rebuilding section, his right arm was broken, wasn't it the left? I know that is a minor inconsistency... but how hard is that to catch honestly? Seems lazy.

Posted by Planewalker

the issue was ok but art sucked big time! 

Posted by Aspenite

Coipel´s art is really good. He should have drawn the main story!

Posted by Omega Ray Jay

This was the most enjoyable Uncanny i have read for awhile, the only thing i didn't like was the depiction of Tony Stark, didn't seem to fit with his current form in Invincible.

Posted by Rosebunse

The art was horrible. Why does Marvel some of their highest grosssing books horrible artists? I can live with Fraction-we know the guy tries-but the horrible art is such a distraction! I would happy to have the porn artist who drew that Women of X title or whatever it was called draw th X-Books if only because he can actually draw hair that doesn't look like it was cut with garden trimmers!
Edited by mickeyglocks

I thought the art was very mediocre and lazy-looking.  This guy draws one of the ugliest Emma Frosts I've seen. And did you see Rogue's face when she's leaning back in the car to talk to Hope? She looks like she just doped herself up.  
 
Props to sparty-dbq's comment about the bipolarity.  And I agree, the 2nd story was way better. Even for just the art alone. Coipel never misses. Portacio's art next to his looked like chicken scratch.

Posted by Jake Fury

Didn't like the art but I liked the story with Hope.

Posted by AmrKing

i need to ask super man how can i be cam super hero

Posted by Joe Venom

So glad to see the direction they are taking Hope character in. 
 
Question, has Hope ever touched a de-powered mutant yet?
 
@A-Strondinaire said:

"

Did anybody else notice in the beginning the unnecessary profile for Iceman and Angel about a three point shooter that was just so dumb.

"

yea, I agree they took a break from doing them during second coming but they are back and dumber than ever
Posted by Uchiha NeVann
@sparty-dbq: finals will do that to you
Posted by pinchpaker29

both story's art looks good to me, the back up part was just better...

Posted by Son Of Storm
I enjoyed it. But I have a question... Can Hope now activate "the lights" power by touch?
Posted by amc26

I wonder who the next light will be?

Posted by VZA

X-Men just ain't what it used to be.

Posted by X-23_2513

second coming was fantastic but im glad its over.
Posted by rbysjti

looks like the focus is on Emma and Scott

Posted by Fade+

is it ok to hate greg land ? lol
Posted by X-23_2513

I liked it.
Posted by wooodude1

I miss terry dodson

Posted by N7_Normandy
@Son Of Storm said:
" I enjoyed it. But I have a question... Can Hope now activate "the lights" power by touch? "
this was my thought as well 
 
I guess we'll find out as the arc continues