thatlad's Uncanny X-Men #1 - The New Revolution review

  • Score:
  • thatlad wrote this review on .
  • 0 out of 0 Comic Vine users found it helpful.
  • thatlad has written a total of 39 reviews. The last one was for


I really have a strong belief that characters should drive the story not the other way around. I think this issue represents that in two ways. Several of the characters act totally out of context to how they have been portrayed in the past, Emma and Magik are nothing like their characters normally act, their speech feels like someone else and just used to bring the story along and accentuate the plot points.

Then you have the big reveal, now this is very much character driven. I can totally see this character acting in this manner, both for the reasons he gives and also because it would just be like this person to act in this manner and turn a situation to their advantage. I'd like to explain my reasoning in more detail but it's difficult with spoiling the reveal.

Art wise, I love Bachalo's art. A lot of people complain about it, in fact my first encounter with Bachalo was reading the Messiah Complex trade. Going from beautiful art to Bachalo's jagged format was jarring and I hated it. But as time as gone on I've come to love Bachalo's art style. It's an acquired taste but me personally, I love it. I just wish the costumes had better designs. Magneto's change makes sense in that Cyclops is now in red, two character's in red doesn't make sense, But Magik's costume is both good and bad, I like that there's a hint of her growing up in her attire but I hate that all character's seem to have revealing outfits. With Emma it makes sense, that's her identity, with Magik it seems like laziness. The other two characters's don't even look properly designed yet.

I hope this series improves, there's clear potential here. But Bendis needs to go back and read up on his Emma and Magik. Go read New X-Men (Morrison and Yost/Kyle runs) there's a start, get an understanding of both character's 'voice' then come back and think how the recent events will have affected those character's as the ones he's wrote here are cookie-cutter female character's. And definitely keep mystery on the big reveal, whether it's for the reasons described or something more sinister, keep it ambiguous I like the idea of grey around that character.

0 Comments Refresh

Other reviews for Uncanny X-Men #1 - The New Revolution

This edit will also create new pages on Comic Vine for:

Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.

Comment and Save

Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Comic Vine users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.