cyclops4president's Uncanny X-Force #8 review

Uncanny X-Force #8 Lucky number Weapon XIII


KRIS ANKA provides us the main variant cover for this issue. What I like about it is the use of lighting. It is obviously computer generated but the light emitting from Psylocke's Psy-Knife, illuminating both her and Cluster's face is really beautifully done. I doubt that Kris Anka had anything to do with that part though. What I don't like is that Psylocke looks too much like a young Mexican Man versus the sexy English/Asian ninja we are used to seeing. Nothing against young or old or any Mexicans by the way.


ADRIAN ALPHONA & DALIBOR TALAJIC share in the artistic penciling in this issue. There is a very distinct difference in styles. This is effective for when the story changes locations and when the story goes into a flashback mode. The art is also effective in portraying Weapon XIII's misdirection. What I didn't like was that the art seemed to be drawn on an etcha-sketch. The first page really fools you into thinking this is going to be a very well drawn book, with a semi detailed home exterior. It is really the color that draws you in though. And the next page, the shock page, of Psylocke and Cluster in bed together, just seemed awkward. The color, however, was very well done. This issue's art was not up to par with what I would recommend as it seemed rushed and with the main character Psylocke drawn with such unusual features it is hard to determine it is her other than she has purple hair - again, the colorist saves the day.

STORY ARC: 3.5/5

SAM HUMPHRIES steps up his game a little from last weeks issue as the love triangle between Psylocke, Fantomex and Cluster become just a little more crowded with Weapon XIII throwing his hat into the ring. What I like about this story is that we really see how Weapon XIII uses his misdirection, and he uses it very well. His smooth, meditative dialogue is hypnotic and coupled with his misdirection, I could easily see how someone could fall pray to his charm. What I don't like about it is that at the end of the book, I feel like I have bee misdirected. I mean, this is X-Factor right!? I had to check the cover twice to make sure I wasn't reading the Adventures of Psylocke.

We start this story in a similar way that we started issue #7, with Psylocke hold up in the bedroom with Cluster for 2 days and Fantomex bringing them champagne. Cluster is concerned because she claims that Fantomex really does love Psylocke. Psylocke is concerned because Fantomex has proven right in his assessment of our Betsy, that she loves to steal. Psylocke even calls herself a low-down thief and that she loves it.

There is a lot of misdirection in this issue, which is partly frustrating to read, but also enjoyable because I can understand better how Weapon XIII's misdirection works. I have read this issue at least 3 times and am still unclear on what actually happened and what is misdirection. Ultimately, Weapon XIII woos Betsy enough to make her fall IN LOVE WITH HIM! He claims that Fantomex and Cluster are using Betsy and Weapon XIII isn't there to kidnap her, but to rescue her from Fantomex and Cluster. He claims they love the IDEA of Betsy but don't truly love her. Betsy is nothing but a "rare jewel" to them that they steal from each other back and forth. Is this true? It could be. The last few pages show Betsy climbing some stairs back to the hotel Fantomex and Cluster are staying at, and see the two in a lovers embrace. Fantomex puts a finger to his lips to "shhh" Betsy as he takes Cluster into the bedroom. We next see Betsy back with Weapon XIII. I don't know if that actually happened or was misdirection.

I do like this story arc if it were titled the Adventures of Psylocke. Psylocke is actually one of my top 10 favorite X-Men characters so following her is great, but the book is titled Uncanny X-Force, where is the rest of the Force? On top of that, we have spent almost half of these issues in lala land, either in someones mind or in a projection of someones mind as a misdirection. I also don't like the fact that an Omega Level telepath, or near Omega level telepath in Psylocke is so easily misdirected by Weapon XIII. It just seems ridiculous to me. It makes her character seem so weak, being so easily played back and forth between Fantomex/Cluster and Weapon XIII.

FINAL VERDICT: 2/5There are a lot of better books out there to buy if you are strapped for cash. If you just absolutely love Psylocke, like I do, you may be a bit frustrated with the way she both written and drawn in this issue. If you like Fantomex, Cluster, Weapon XIII, you will love this book. It is full of them using their talents flawlessly. If you are looking for Storm, Puck, Bishop, or any of the other characters of Uncanny X-Force you are out of luck. It is only Psylocke and the split 3 of Fantomex. If you really love these characters, then these are the people I recommend this book to.

Posted by Renchamp

I addressed this in my review for the last issue, but I think a lot of the problem with this book is that it is sold as a team book. There has never been a team. Storm and Psylocke met with Puck for a quick mission and that was it. This has really been a series about what is in someone's head, and the focus has (so far) been on Psylocke.

I love how you address whether you are being misdirected or not. I had that exact same feeling. For me, that's what made this book a five-star. I love that I don't have the answers, but I love that the ride in finding them is so sweet. So, I'll agree with your review despite disagreeing with your reasoning. (The fact that you have reasoning is why it is helpful. Nice work.)

Posted by Cyclops4President

@renchamp: I completely agree with your first paragraph. That is why I stated I thought I was reading "The Adventures of Psylocke"! even though I do love Psylocke, I AM buying a team book right? In this review I also stated how exhausted I am of being in someone's head or in a projected world or being misdirected. If you read all these issues back to back, you would need a drink!

I think that is the saving grace to this issue. The writer did do a good job creating this feeling of misdirection and everytime I read it, I just don't know, misdirected.

I read almost all the big titles each week and that is why I rated this issue a 2/5. I do love what the writers did with the misdirection, but the whole team book vs Psylocke book, plus the way they are drawing Psylocke and portrayer her as some amateur in the mind game realm is slightly insulting to me. I just did a review of Thanos Rising and rated that a 5/5. If you want to read a 5/5 book, read that one, or my review to find out why that is a 5/5 book and this is not.


Posted by Cyclops4President

Other reviews for Uncanny X-Force #8

    Worst series ever... 0

    Sam Humphries is talented, in the way that he can make both lesbians and x-force uninteresting. If you love bad acting day time soap operas you might really like this comic. Unfortunately x-force is not the place for soap opera drama. There's nothing wrong with some romance in comic, and sure as hell nothing wrong with some lesbian heroes in the x-force books. This X-force is all drama, very little action.I've disliked the voices for characters before. Characters Ive grown to love, I'm slowly s...

    1 out of 1 found this review helpful.

    Uncanny X-Force #8 Rating 0

    Cover & Solicit - 3/5Would I pick-up or buy the comic based on the solicit or cover alone?Are the alternate covers appealing?Does the solicit and cover portray what happens in the issue?Do I like the artist's style on the cover?Art, Colors & Inking - 3/5- Weighted DoubleDo I personally like this artist's style?Does the artist stay true to the characters appearance?If there are multiple artists do they blend well and not disturb the reading experience?Does the coloring/inking blend well w...

    1 out of 1 found this review helpful.

This edit will also create new pages on Comic Vine for:

Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.

Comment and Save

Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Comic Vine users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.