zack_freeman's Ultimate Avengers #10 - Crime and Punishment Part 4 review

Review: Ultimate Comics Avengers 2 #4

The Avengers get trounced by Ghost Rider, whose nightmarish origins prove to have terrifying implications for the Ultimates' leaders.
 

The Good

Revising Ghost Rider so he's got a specific group of powerful satanists he's seeking vengeance on puts an interesting (and potentially relevant) spin on his origin; making him more of an anti-hero in the Ultimate universe opposed by good guys and bad guys alike. Along that note, I like the range of gray morality presented, here - - it makes characters like Tony Stark and Nick Fury that much more interesting by given them very real feet of clay (even if it doesn't always work.)

The Bad

This whole thing is just messy, and that's especially disappointing in light of how clear and streamlined the Ultimates was when it first rolled out.  I'm especially baffled by the inclusion of "the Spider" as he seems like  just the sort of convoluted, continuity-produced character these series were supposed to avoid. While it's a great novelty to have Punisher included in this line-up, he comes off as way too cavalier for a grim vigilante (even if the Ultimate one's different than the 616 one.) It would've been interesting to maybe comment on how he's a spirit of vengeance too, since Ghost Rider has a unnatural kind of omniscience, but we just get a gag and quip instead. The Punisher and lot of other characterizations' seem to be really out of whack, going for rude shocks in their dialogue that don't make a lot of sense for the characters. I'm particularly thinking of the way Sharon Carter gets pranked, how "Nerd Hulk" is such a moron and that really bizarre revelation about Nick Fury's relationship with the new Black Widow.

The Verdict - 2/5

 I get the sense that this was written with an aim to see what ridiculous things could be gotten away with, rather than truly trying to tell new,  continuity-free stories with these concepts.  It's a real shame, since it flies in the face of what this whole imprint was designed to do. Instead of clearing things up and getting to the core of these characters, like Ultimate Comics Spider-Man is doing, this is just mess of "shocks."
1 Comments
Posted by brewski420

after reading your review i'm glad i didn't pick this issue up. i actually removed this series from my pull list after issue #2. Mark Millar's writing hasn't been that good for awhile

This edit will also create new pages on Comic Vine for:

Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.

Comment and Save

Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Comic Vine users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.