I apologize for the last thread about Tim I made. I jumped to conclusions that he was better as Robin when I did not read the Red Robin series. I now prefer him as Red Robin.

I prefer him as Red Robin, but I hate the costume something fierce.

I've liked him as both...I really liked his last Robin suit before he became Red Robin and I really like where they've taken his detective skills since he became Red Robin

Red Robin rules!

Tim has really come into his own as Red Robin, he's gone beyond being just Robin.

Who voted Robin? just wondering,

Reeeed Robins!Yum! O_o

Tim has really thrived in his role as Red Robin and it's much nicer to see him really demonstrate his skills in this solo role

Tim is better as Red Robin. Damian is Robin now and I hope to remain that way.

When I first read Red Robin, I felt it was kinda shady how Dick decided to let Damian take over as Robin. That said, I'm glad it happened because I like Tim in a role where he is able to do his own thing in shades of gray.

Ah, that was why you liked him better as Robin, cause you hadn't actually read Red Robin :P

Peter David's Young Justice and Chuck Dixon's Robin are both more entertaining to me than the new series.

Honestly it was a tie for me but i ended going with Red Robin cause it was just a little more exhilarating than his usual robin comic which was always on point by the way. I don't think the polls take away from Tim as Robin, it just prove that he just has become better as his own man in the Red Robin identity.

" Peter David's Young Justice and Chuck Dixon's Robin are both more entertaining to me than the new series. "

I like Tim as both.

Red Robing but he needs a different cowl because im not a fan of the look of it 

definitely as Red Robin

He's only been Red Robin for about a year, but I have to say as Red Robin.
 
But then again, he made Robin cool again.....I still say Red Robin.

i prefer tim as red robin. i can understand why he isn't robin now. LIke dick grayson he needed to get out there on his own and a new identity. Understandable...sometimes u just outgrow things. Well even tho dick told him, he can't be his robin i think it would of happened eventually.