raven575's The X-Men #4 - The Brotherhood of Evil Mutants review

Evil Mutants

The Brotherhood of Evil Mutants (BoEM) make their debut in this book and it has inspired me to do something special. From this book forward, until it stops being so prevalent, I will be doing a count of how many time the phrases homo-sapien and homo-superior get used in each book.

Homo-sapien: 6

Homo-superior: 3

I do this to shed light on the ridiculous overuse of a word/phrase. Once you use such an interesting word/phrase too much, it tends to lose its impact, and therefore becomes mundane and boring. I don't know anyone that uses scientific terms as much as the random characters in these books seem to, and I hang around a fairly intelligent group of people.

Next topic...IT'S BEEN A FUCKING YEAR!?! Ok, seriously? Why would you just skip ahead a full year? I realize that by doing this we may get to stop setting as many ridiculous "training scenes", but we've just lost a ton of time in getting to know these characters. If you want a reader to get behind a group of misfit superheroes, show them struggle to win in situations, and more importantly, show them struggle with their powers and how that affects their connection to humanity. I realize that up to this point the X-Men haven't had a ton of clear victories, but we haven't seen hardly any personal growth. If you spent a year training with someone to fight evil, would you tease them during a training session? Well, yes, you probably would, but it would be about their performance, not something about their personality. You shouldn't want to piss of the guy who watches your back when you're out in the field.

We haven't really been given much info on the Brotherhood yet, other than they bicker and fight almost as much as the X-Men do. I'm still not sure why Magneto stole a Destroyer when it seemed to have no connection to them taking over a town. There were a lot of loose ends and unconnected plot points in this story. They should have gone into more detail in this story and split it into two issues.

Final Thought: I realize the time in which this was created and the amount of time that each creative team had in which to create, edit, print and distribute a book was very small. I also realize that many people had to work on multiple books simultaneously, but seriously... if you are that strapped for time, then drop a book. Better to put out two great books than three crappy ones. Just my opinion.

TLDR: Writing still sucks, Mastermind hates Magneto's kids, and Professor X likes to throw himself at exploding doors for no good reason

0 Comments

Other reviews for The X-Men #4 - The Brotherhood of Evil Mutants

    The Brotherhood of Evil Mutants 0

    An exhilaratingly action-packed issue for the X-Men this month as they come face to face with their arch nemesis, Magneto and his newly formedBrotherhood of Evil Mutants. Slowly but surely chipping away the broad corners, Lee and Kirby continue to develop the X-Men mythos away from your standardised superhero group tact and more towards what they would become known for. The heroes are still kind of undefined at this stage, but it's still early days, and progress is definitely being shown.What's ...

    1 out of 1 found this review helpful.

    "You have made your choice - forever we are mortal foes!" 0

    Meanwhile, one year later...(have the X-Men really been training for a year since Jean arrived in issue 1?)  With this issue, X-Men begins to hit its initial stride.  Lee and Kirby finally deliver an issue with layers of conflict, genuine motivation, and a satisfactory payoff.  The House of Ideas was big on beginning their new series with origin stories, but the X-Men did not really get one, nor do the Brotherhood of Evil Mutants.  Though Xavier told us a bit of his origin in issue 1 (being born...

    2 out of 2 found this review helpful.

This edit will also create new pages on Comic Vine for:

Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.

Comment and Save

Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Comic Vine users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.