etragedy's The X-Men #12 - The Origin of Professor X review

  • Score:
  • etragedy wrote this review on .
  • 1 out of 1 Comic Vine users found it helpful.
  • etragedy has written a total of 1072 reviews. The last one was for

Prof X's Origin and Introduction of Juggernaut Can't Compensate for Poor Art and Story

This issue of the X-Men is notable for a couple of reasons - first, it contains the origin of Professor X; second, it contains the origin and first appearance of The Juggernaut.

But the execution of this issue is very poor. First of all, Jack Kirby's attentions were probably elsewhere during the creation of this issue. He just provides layouts which Alex Toth finished and Vince Coletta inked. But Kirby's layouts must have been very preliminary indeed, and Toth doesn't really build much on them, resulting in many very static posed characters - even during battle - made worse by the fact that most of this issue is the X-Men listening to Xavier tell a story about his past, with very little actual fighting until the end.

That brings up the second really big problem here - the plot. Cerebro wails, off the charts, and Professor X knows that means his old nemesis is attacking. Trouble is this contradicts Cerebro's functions - it's supposed to detect mutants, and from the story we are told in this issue, The Juggernaut is not a mutant! Then, the X-Men spring to action, building a thick ice wall around the mansion, a covered trench, two electrical barriers, and a series of gas grenade mortar ranks - all in exactly 5 minutes! And yet, they forget to use the mansion's already existing steel barricades until near the end of the issue when it's almost too late!

If that weren't bad enough - rather than try to stop The Juggernaut, they sit around Xavier's study whilst he relates his past history of pain and woe for the whole issue, while Juggernaut breaks through defense after defense.

There's also a bunch of mild annoyances here too - Iceman starts using gravity-defying ice slides with no means of support, and there's some general buffoonery with Iceman, Angel and Beast all spring into battle and running into each other like the 3 Stooges.

Even the backstory of Xavier and Juggernaut, to which so much time is devoted rings as false, with all the characters (particularly Cain Marko) acting in such stereotypical ways.

Although I'm glad this issue happened, I can't really say it's a particularly 'good' issue.

0 Comments

Other reviews for The X-Men #12 - The Origin of Professor X

    Red-headed Stepchild 0

    Ok...I have passed on talking about this particular thing for far too long, but how many slip and fall accidents have been caused by Iceman's ice slaloms?I mean, even if it does melt, he still leaves gigantic puddles of water everywhere he goes. Those puddles could cause people to unsuspectingly injure themselves or do a bad bit of property damage. Forget them blasting their way through your living room, the water damage to the furniture would be disastrous, and I bet his room always smells like...

    2 out of 2 found this review helpful.

This edit will also create new pages on Comic Vine for:

Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.

Comment and Save

Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Comic Vine users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.