raven575's The X-Men #11 - The Triumph of Magneto! review

Magneto Takes a Sabbatical

I started to get my hopes up to early it seems. The first couple of issues were not good, then it seemed to get a little better, and then the last couple of issues destroyed my hopes again. Damn you Stan...I know I had heard that you're writing was not good, and that you got by on your family connections and an admittedly good business sense, but really? This is just awful.

Homo-sapien: 0

Homo-superior: 1

Issues like these really makes me wish I hadn't like Stan Lee so much. I should have know better from having seen some of his more recent movie and animation creations. Stan Lee, with help, can come up with some great characters, but that is all. It takes a much better mind to make those creations iconic. That being said, each of these issues that suck, steal a little bit of my soul.

Anyway...they debut a new character which apparently can do anything he wants to. Most likely a cosmic entity, "The Stranger" doesn't seem like the type of character to have needed a room to rent. Which makes me ask the question...was "money creation" one of his powers? That whole situation seemed weird. You might be asking, "why aren't you saying anything about the first 6-8 pages?" Because nothing happened and you might as well have ripped out random page 2's from some of the previous comics and reworded them. Same crap writing with almost no purpose.

So this cosmic being, "The Stranger" shows up, finds Magneto and his BoEM and their first thought is, "Let's show him our powers by using them on him." Yeah, that would make me trust you. After you wrap me up in flying metal pieces and show me visions of hell, we're gonna be best of friends. So, naturally, he retaliates. Instantly taking out Mastermind, then the X-men barge in and take out Quicksilver and Scarlet Witch stops fighting.

Magneto, Toad and the Stranger escape only to find out the the Stranger is taking them hostage. Then he wraps them into a nice package and flies off into space. Goodbye Magneto. See ya Later.

Final Thoughts: Why did we need a whole book devoted to Magneto leaving the series for a while? Did they really have to "Soap Opera Kill" him to get him out of the way? Maybe this was just a plan to turn Quicksilver and Scarlet Witch into good guys. If that's the case, they should have come up with a better idea.

TLDR: Cyclops and Jean should just get it on and over with, Quicksilver and Scarlet Witch Switch sides (kinda) and Professor X doesn't want his ugly mug in the papers

0 Comments

Other reviews for The X-Men #11 - The Triumph of Magneto!

    The Stranger Appears 0

    Though this issue relies on the too-familiar structure of most X-Men issues to date, it breaks the mold (finally) by the end for an actual satisfying deus-ex-machina ending.  The cover sets the tone for something different: finally Stan and Jack did not clutter the cover with the juvenile slogans and graphic art that have distracted most of the Marvel covers up to this point.  By this point, the reader base had to have been big enough that they didn't need to draw childish attention to themselve...

    1 out of 1 found this review helpful.

    One of the worst issues of early X-Men 0

    Issue #11 of The X-Men is one of the worst issues of the early X-Men comics. The writing here is abysmal, particularly where it concerns the sci-fi elements, including the various characters powers and how they use them. Here are just some of the problems with this issue:the thing starts off with pseudoscience on the splash page with a 'radar image beam' that Professor X uses to, "detect the presence of other mutants" (isn't that what cerebro is for?).The functioning of the radar image beam is w...

    1 out of 1 found this review helpful.

This edit will also create new pages on Comic Vine for:

Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.

Comment and Save

Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Comic Vine users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.