johnkmccubbin91's The Wolverine review


I have been a Wolverine fan most of my life, being introduced to the character at a young age through the 90's Animated series. I have also loved seeing him in the movies, as although not all off them have been amazing, with X-Men Origins: Wolverine having a lot wrong with it I still love to see the character, and hope that he's shown well in this film.



Wolverine travels to Japan to pay his final respects to Ichirō Yashida, a man who he saved from the atomic bomb. He then lands up trying to save his granddaughter, Mariko Yashida from Yakuza, whilst finding out that he's lost his healing factor.


This was a very good film, and although it was far from perfect, it was a vast improvement over X-Men Origins: Wolverine, as there wasn't much that I hated as a comic book fan. The main thing that let the film down however was that it was a little too slow paced at times, centring more around character development, and interaction that story. It did however have the explosive fight sequences that you'd expect from a Wolverine film, and there was plenty of it. James Mangold did a decent job at directing this films, as although it's not quite as good as some of his other films (eg. 3:10 to Yuma, and Knight and Day) it wasn't the worse film that he's directed, and he showed that he understands the tone of this story.

The cast was something that I had mixed feelings on, as although I liked most of the chosen cast members, there was a couple of choices that didn't work in my opinion. I'll start with the star of the film, Wolverine, who was once again played perfectly by Hugh Jackman. Jackman has been playing this role for thirteen years now, and although he's slightly taller than Wolverine should be, he's perfect in all the other categories, showing the emotions, and broodiness perfectly, as well as giving explosive action performances. This film would also see one of Wolverine's love interests shown in the form of Markio, who was played by Tao Okamoto. Okamoto did a great job of the character, showing the kind heartedness of her character, as well as the strength of character, and was perfect in the role. The other cast members such as Haruhiko Yamanouchi as Ichirō Yashida, Rila Fukushima as Yukio, Hiroyuki Sanada as Shingen Yashida (though this character wasn't as you'd expect), Will Yun Lee as Kenuichio Harada, Brian Tee as Noburo Mori, all did good jobs of their roles. It was however Svetlana Khodchenkova as Viper that disappointed me, as she didn't suit the role.

The Feeling of Mortality

One of the key concepts of this film was a mortal Wolverine, without his healing factor. Now this is a very interesting concept, and it was done very well in this story. With Wolverine being a man who hasn't had to worry about getting injured in the past, as well as having not felt the full pain that something like a gun wound, or a cut will give it was nice that they showed him having to get used to this, feeling strange, and out of his element. This did however make me continue to question the logic behind Wolverine's hair, as when he was burned to a crisp early in the film it grew back to the same length, the he had it, and his beard much longer. The film would also show him shaving whilst his healing factor was gone, which would also suggest that his hair in connected to that, making me continue to question the logic.

This issue would also show the start of Wolverine's relationship with Mariko. To be fair this is the only part that is taken from Chris Claremont, and Frank Miller's Wolverine series, with the rest being fairly original. The relationship itself was however shown perfectly in this film, as although it was the main thing that slowed the pace of the film, it was still very emotional, with lots of depth. I also liked how it gradually built, and how it was put into a modern setting, which was also handled perfectly (though some other transitions to the modern setting in the film didn't work as well).

Rise of the Phoenix

It was advertised for a while prior to the release of this film that Jean Grey would appear in it, with Famke Janssen reprising her role from the other three X-Men films. Now after hearing this I was wondering how it'd happen, or work for that matter, due to her dying in X-Men: The Last Stand, and this taking place after. I did however come to one conclusion prior to seeing this film, and it turned out to be correct. If you want no spoilers at all skip this paragraph, otherwise stay (it's not a big spoiler). It turned out that Jean was never actually there, and only in Wolverine's head, being a sign of his guilt. This worked very well in the film, as due to the feelings that Wolverine had for Jean, as well as the fact that he was the one that killed her would lead to him having guilt over her death, and what better way of showing that than to have her haunting his sleep (it also gives Janseen a nice paycheck as well).

The Viper Strikes

The main villain in this film would be Viper, better known to most comic book fans as Madame Hydra. Now for starters I don't know why this character is in this film to start of with, as I would have thought that Marvel would have still had the rights to her, even though this film has made her a mutant. That was another thing that I didn't like about the character in this film, as she was so different as to how she was in the comics, which was very disappointing (though not as bad as Deadpool in X-Men Origins: Wolverine). I also didn't like how she was portrayed as Khodchenkova acted more like a spoiled mutant, wanting what she wants, opposed to the strong leader of HYDRA that she is in the comics. I did however find it interesting how they made her similar to a snake, even though it was way off character.

Clash of Adamantium

The Silver Samurai would also feature in this film, being a giant armour made out of Adamantium. Now although this film features the character Kenuichio Harada, who is known as the Silver Samurai, he isn't actually the Silver Samurai. Now this slightly disappointed me, and although I easily forgot about it to enjoy the film, it was still annoying. The Samurai itself was however amazing, and brilliantly designed. I also liked how it gave Wolverine a very exciting match, contributing to an amazing fight scene. There was also a slight mystery to the Samurai, and although I won't mention what it is, as to avoid spoilers, I will say that I kind of suspected what it was at certain points of the film.

There was also some other great action scenes, including a phenomenal scene with Wolverine fighting Yakuza on a bullet train, as well as other scenes that would see him against samurai warriors, more Yakuza, and even ninjas, making for some of the best action scenes in any of the X-Men films.

This film would also have a mid-credit scene at the end, and although I won't go into details as to avoid spoilers, I will say my thoughts on it. It was a very interesting scene, leaving me with even more questions than I already have. I also thought that I'd mention the scene so you don't walk out of the cinema and miss it.

Final Verdict

Although this wasn't quite as good as I hoped, it was much better than the last Wolverine feature film, as well as X-Men: The Last Stand, being a very entertaining film. It also had some of the best action that I've seen in an X-Men film, with very explosive, and at times humorous scenes. It was however slightly slow at times, and the villain Viper wasn't portrayed well. Besides this I'd still recommending giving this film a go, as although you may not enjoy it as much as I have, I'd be surprised if you liked it less that X-Men Origins: Wolverine, or X-Men: The Last Stand.

Rating: 4/5

Posted by TheAcidSkull

totally agree with the score

Posted by johnkmccubbin91
Edited by Cyclops4President

Great review! As always

Edited by johnkmccubbin91

@cyclops4president: Thanks very much. Have you seen the film, and if so what did you think of it?

Posted by Cyclops4President

@johnkmccubbin91: Wolverine just came out yesterday where I live (Florida) so no I havent seen it yet but will probably this weekend

Edited by johnkmccubbin91

@cyclops4president: Was just asking as you said you'd not read the review until you'd seen the film. Hopefully my review helps though. Also let me know what you think once you've seen it?

Posted by Mr_Colossus

You hit all the major points of this movie. Using Viper as a main villain was questionable to say the least. I wouldn't have taken her to be a major Wolverine villain. Also, I was very afraid for the Silver Samari in this one. It was not done as it was in the comics, but I think they did save it some by making it armor over robot. Another thing that was a bit different from normal Wolverine stories and the movie was the lack of death for a certain character that never seems to make it through to the end. I rather enjoyed this movie and glad I didn't leave majorly disappointed. I am interested in seeing where they go from here with his claws. I have an idea of how it can be done, but how they will do it I am unsure. Excellent review with descriptive key points. Keep up the good work.

Posted by johnkmccubbin91

@mr_colossus: Thanks very much and I agree on all your points. One of my theory's one the claws is that Magneto may help. I just hope they show how he gets them back though in Days of Future Past as I have a funny suspicion that they won't.

Posted by Brightseid

Great review! I agree with all your pints but as for the verdict, I'd remove a star or 2. I didn't go in expecting a lot but claiming to be a stand alone movie, I think It should've had more depth accompanied by a faster pace. I watched the opening show here in Fiji and I was kinda disappointed with the 3D (I guess that made it worse for me). Adding on, I think the Silver Samurai looked moreso like a borrowed Destroyer idea from Thor then a reinvention of the character. Don't get me wrong; I agree with your points on the nice designs and all but replacing Harada may have disheartened me at the first glance at the final fight scene.

Cheers and keep up the good words pouring out bub

Edited by johnkmccubbin91

@brightseid: Yeah I was thinking that as well, but it had so much character depth, and emotion, which made for good storytelling, and if it wasn't for the slow pace, and bad villain it could have easily been a 5 star film, though I can see why some would give it less than 4. I was also just wondering if you'd mind recommending this seems you liked it?

Posted by Brightseid

I agree. Though I also wonder how the Madame Hydra thing is gonna play out in the marvel universe now. I was kinda hoping to see her in CA: Winter Soldier.

As for the reccomendation - Just did :D

Posted by johnkmccubbin91

@brightseid: May still as that's why she was called Viper and made a mutant in this, though I think Winter Soldier will have enough villains anyway.

Posted by Raw_Material

I liked the movie, woulda gave it the same ratings probably. Nice review.

Edited by johnkmccubbin91

Other reviews for The Wolverine

    The Wolverine trugges onward grappling with if he wants an empty life or a meaningful death? 0

    The theoretical Darren Aronofsky directed Wolverine film would definitely have been a more auteurist take on the character than previously seen. Something that is becoming more of a must as various franchise continue on year after year. Replacement director James Mangold(Walk The Line, 3:10 to Yuma), whose filmography I would describe as studio eclectic might have found his auteurist self in The Wolverine. Capturing the quiet moments from lead Hugh Jackman and melding them against the old and ne...

    4 out of 4 found this review helpful.

This edit will also create new pages on Comic Vine for:

Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.

Comment and Save

Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Comic Vine users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.