The Walking Dead Recap & Comic Comparison: Season 2, Episode 6 "Secrets"

Posted by inferiorego (24971 posts) - - Show Bio

Did you catch this week's episode of 'The Walking Dead'? The sixth episode, "Secrets" did have some of those. The main thing is last week we finally got confirmation on the barn, just as in the comic. Rick and the survivors have been staying at Hershel's farm while Carl recovered from accidentally getting shot. Sophia is missing. Glen and Maggie secretly hooked up. And Lori found out she was pregnant. See our recap from last week if you missed out.

As it is stated every week, this recap is filled with MAJOR SPOILERS, and they will not be blocked out, so you all have been warned.

== TEASER ==

The Barn

Carl, apparently well again, is feeding the chicken with his mom, Lori. When it's noticed that a mother chicken is missing, Carl makes a note how it probably was eaten and everything is food for something. He was right as Patricia takes a chicken into the shed, breaks its legs, and takes it to the barn. She's feeding the walkers.

Glenn stares at the barn through some binoculars. Maggie says he's making it obvious and he has to keep it a secret. Maggie tries bribing/convincing Glen to keep the secret. He doesn't understand why they're keeping Walkers in the barn but Maggie insists it's best if the others don't find out.

At the farm, Dale finds Hershel with Nelly, the horse that bucked off Daryl in the woods, and the horse found her way back. Dale says he heard moaning the barn and knows about the Walkers. Hershel considers the Walkers people. Hershel's wife and step-son are in the barn. Hershel wants Dale to keep it to himself.

The Pregnancy

Glenn asks if Lori has told Rick about the pregnancy yet, she obviously hasn't. He knows that she needs things like vitamins and a comfortable pillow but she keeps tight lipped over it all. Glenn tries to give her food because she's too skinny but she won't take it. Glenn says he'll go into town to get her supplies.

Later Glen is caught in a lie with Dale and tells him about the pregnancy. He later talks to Lori to try to help. She tells Dale that she hasn't told Rick yet and Dale asks if it's because of Shane. Lori is shocked and asked if it was obvious they were together. Dale said it wasn't and he was never really sure.

Carl Wants to Shoot

Carl asks Shane to help him shoot. He makes it clear that it's up to his parents. Carl asks if he'll talk to them since they'd listen to him. Shane sees that Carl has a gun. It turns out he took it from the RV and Lori is mad that he took it and that he lied about why he needed to go inside.

Shane says he'd be happy teaching him to shoot. Rick thinks it's a good idea because he'll be protected. Carl wants to step up and protect the camp and be a part of the group. Rick makes the point that it's good he wants to learn to use a gun rather than be afraid of them. Rick also points out that Shane is a great instructor and has taught kids younger than Carl. Lori lets Shane teach him, but is very weary about it.

At the lessons, Carl does a good job. Andrea also appears to have improved her shooting skills and Shane takes her lessons to a knew level.

This is different from the comics as Rick was the one to give Carl shooting lessons and they started well before ever going to Hershel's farm.

Another Trip Into Town

Glenn apologizes for telling Dale about Lori. Lori asks to make a run into town for her, and he will. Maggie and Glenn get on some horses and ride off. Maggie won't talk to him. She finally opens up and says she's mad because Glenn betrayed her trust. Maggie hates the term "walkers." She still calls them by their names. Maggie goes in back and grabs things for Glenn at the pharmacy. A walker grabs Maggie's arm. Glenn runs over with a shelf and half chops it's head off, it gets back up and Glenn uses a machete to end it.

This makes Maggie take a new look on things including what she feels about Glen and the others.

Shane and Andrea

Andrea and Shane do some advanced shooting. Walkers don't stay still and neither should the target. Shane gets intense and says "thats the walker that got Amy, shoot him!" Andrea stares at him, offended, and walks away. Shane apologizes for bringing up Amy and wants her to back him up while searching for Sophia.

Shane and Andrea continue their search in a residential area. Shane finds a pile of dead bodies and the two find a burned down room with skeletons in the garage. Walkers come from outside and they'll soon be overrun with them. They run towards the car a shoot walkers down. Andrea is having trouble putting them down and reloading. She finally gets a kill, and after that it's easy for her. They make it back to the car, but instead of getting in, Andrea shoots another one.

As they are driving away. Andrea puts her hand on Shane's crotch. Shane pulls over and they apparently get it on. Obviously this is something that never happened in the comics.

When they return, Dale tries encouraging Shane to leave. Dale keeps pushing Shane more and more. "I know what kind of man you are."

Dale also brings up the fact that Shane pulled a gun on Rick. Shane's reply is he loves Rick like a brother and if he thinks he would shoot someone he considers to be his brother, imagine what he'd do to "some guy" he doesn't even like when he starts throwing accusations his way.

Which Pills Will Lori Take?

Lori is still trying to decide what to do about being pregnant. She has both "abortion pills" from Glen and Maggie's trip into town. She also has some prenatal vitamins Glen later gives her. Lori takes a buttload of pills. Then she runs away and pukes them all up.

Rick finds the empty medicine containers in the tent. He walks to the field that Lori is in. He confronts her. Lori confesses she's pregnant and that she threw up the pills. He's pissed that Glenn knew before he did. He wants to understand why he didn't know. He asks if there is anything else he should know about. Lori just says "Shane and I." Rick understands because Lori thought Rick was dead and that the world was turned upside down.

There's a lot of crazy things going on and you can imagine that things are going to heat up even more in the next episode now that some of the secrets have come out.

Staff
#1 Posted by wowylied (238 posts) - - Show Bio

Did not see the first season, the walking dead is about zombie and the survival in the wasteland or more about the different people with episode full of flashback like in lost (and so not a zombie thing anymore) ?

#2 Posted by haydenclaireheroes (9073 posts) - - Show Bio

I did not get to see this episode yet but I am excited to see it.

#3 Posted by ARMIV2 (8554 posts) - - Show Bio

This episode had my mouth agape several times. It was amazing!

#4 Posted by RedheadedAtrocitus (6885 posts) - - Show Bio

Shane's days are numbered after that encounter he had with Dale. Things are coming to a head. As for Sophia...I have my suspicions now where she is. Gosh, Sunday can not come soon enough! Just sucks there's gonna be a winter hiatus of the show after this Sunday until next February...

#5 Posted by The_Tree (7491 posts) - - Show Bio

@wowylied said:

Did not see the first season, the walking dead is about zombie and the survival in the wasteland or more about the different people with episode full of flashback like in lost (and so not a zombie thing anymore) ?

It's about surviving in a zombie apocalypse, and what it'll drive people to do.

There are some flashbacks, but they're not included on a regular basis.

#6 Posted by Duncan (11445 posts) - - Show Bio

Those poor chickens..

#7 Posted by perry_411 (428 posts) - - Show Bio

This show has gotten very boring. I'm going to watch just to see Shane, but the writers aren't creative enough to split the group up with Shane taking one crew and Rick taking another and then showing both stories. It will become a very bad show after they kill Shane.(see him giving a Fear enema to Dale this episode?) Jon Bernathal is the shit. The Rick, Lori, and Dale are d-bagging it up.

#8 Posted by illmatic06 (52 posts) - - Show Bio

The show is more about character development than the onslaught of zombies. The interpersonal dynamics are the focus. The show can go 15 mins without even the appearance of a zombie.

#9 Posted by Ganthetsward20 (687 posts) - - Show Bio

golly i think dale best watch his back, Sofia has been gone an awful long time if she's a live I imagine she ran into Tyrese or someone. Lori and Glen are friends...yea right. Zombis in the barn...I hope they eat Shane.

#10 Posted by laabitres (416 posts) - - Show Bio

the ep was pretty good cant wait 4 the nxt one

#11 Posted by Decept-O (7278 posts) - - Show Bio

There was plenty of drama, mind you, but not much else. Could have used a bit more action but simultaneously the episode did offer up some key moments.

In this episode at least, I was a bit more concerned with Glen than anyone simply because I hope his new possible relationship will be good and he isn't getting played by the farmer's daughter. Shane's threat may come to reality. Being cynical I guess. While I understand Lori's actions in the past and present, she still is making things more dramatic than necessary. Wished they would tone her down a peg.

#12 Posted by Nefilim927 (357 posts) - - Show Bio

I'm still thinking Sophia is in the barn and Shane will not be with us in February. Carl learning how to shoot an episode before the mid-season finale plus Dale calling Shane out...not looking good. As much as I enjoy the human drama I really wish we had some more zombie action.

#13 Posted by Baron_Emo (3570 posts) - - Show Bio

@Nefilim927 said:

I'm still thinking Sophia is in the barn and Shane will not be with us in February. Carl learning how to shoot an episode before the mid-season finale plus Dale calling Shane out...not looking good. As much as I enjoy the human drama I really wish we had some more zombie action.

Exactly. I thought this episode was a great lead-in to Shane's fate as depicted in the comics.

#14 Posted by danhimself (22565 posts) - - Show Bio

if you think the show is boring then you don't understand the show

#15 Posted by Bigheart711 (2206 posts) - - Show Bio

Still continuing with the show, but there were complaints with the pacing and thankfully, this episode covered some emotional ground. Unfortunately, the missing person was gone for 3 days and there's a chance that most of the characters would assume that she was zombie chow, but there's another chance that she's still alive and unscathed...

#16 Posted by G-Man (34542 posts) - - Show Bio

@Duncan: That first snap of the chicken made me cringe in disgust. Who cares about humans getting chomped. That chicken part was gross.

Staff
#17 Posted by Vormun (7 posts) - - Show Bio

@G-Man: Agree. That chicken thing was aweful.

#18 Posted by Vormun (7 posts) - - Show Bio

I haven't read the comic series.

The thing that scares me most about TWD is that it might turn into Lost. Lost started out great and became unbearable to watch with those flashbacks and flash-forwards.

I currently like the show, but already think that season 2 is not as good as season 1. I wasn't too excited about what Shane did to Otis, the scene with the well and the chicken leg thing.

Yes, I think the main topic should be survival in a wasteland.

I like the flashbacks, but those flashbacks are also dangerous as that was one of the things that majorly screwed up Lost.

So I hope they use those flashbacks wisely to tell us how the shit hit the ceiling, without turning the whole show into a big mess.

#19 Posted by Eyz (3095 posts) - - Show Bio

Keep doing these recaps/comparisons! :D

#20 Edited by The Impersonator (5483 posts) - - Show Bio

Andrea puts her hand on Shane's crotch.

Didn't see that coming. :P

#21 Edited by ThomasElliot (362 posts) - - Show Bio

I would like to think that those who think it's 'too slow' are the comic fans who know some of the major plot points coming. Thats the thing about Walking Dead... its NOT just a character study... the comic has a lot of 'Breaking Bad' moments where something you didn't expect just totally knocks you on your ass. Characters you get used to, to the point where you think they are untouchable, end up dying and you're sitting there with a book in your hands going, "WTF?!!".

THAT'S what the show has been missing so far. For example, I was waiting on the edge of my seat for the reveal of Hershel's secret. And when it finally came... it was so uneventful. I use my wife (who has never read the comic, knows nothing about WD) to gauge these moments and she was like, "Oh... that's his secret? He keeps zombies in the barn? That's stupid". Her stupid was referring to the character keeping zombies in the barn, not that the idea/story of it is stupid. But she commented that this revelation didn't seem to be a big deal. That's WRONG... the TV series should be taking those moments and twisting it in a way where you never saw it coming. Again, this is one of the reasons Breaking Bad works so well and hooks people. The twists, and they are SMART twists, not cheap one, keep the story going and fresh.

#22 Posted by mrmarketcap (1 posts) - - Show Bio

Does anyone know what comic issue # the show is currently on?

This edit will also create new pages on Comic Vine for:

Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.

Comment and Save

Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Comic Vine users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.