The downfall of the emerald archer...

Posted by sj_esposito (457 posts) - - Show Bio

I've made very clear my opinions on The New 52 before, but I've centered most of my arguments and/or complaints around the Bat-family and related titles. I've always been a Batman fan through-and-through, so that's probably the reason why; however, there's a character that I've always loved that's getting a really crappy treatment in the reboot that I've yet to really speak on: Green Arrow.

Every once in a while I'll pick up the Green Arrow book--I suppose in total I've read 5 or 6 of the new issues--and each time I'm more disappointed than the last. That's not saying much given that fact that I hated even the first issue. Ollie's already had a creative shift--which did nothing to help the miserable situation that is the Green Arrow title--and, so far, his strongest appearance has been in Justice League recently. This doesn't bold well for the book or Green Arrow as a character. How long until Green Arrow is canceled? And, worse, when it is, what will come of Green Arrow as a character?

The sad part is that we're not talking about a character that has never held his own ongoing, or one that doesn't have a strong fan-following: Green Arrow is a beloved hero in many circles and has had numerous long-running series that have a left their mark on comic book history (The Longbow Hunters, Green Lantern/Green Arrow, Winick's run) and has been involved in nearly all the important events in the DCU (although, one should ask: do they even matter anymore?).

So how is it that such a strong and well-storied character has gotten such a dismal treatment in The New 52? The obvious answer is that he's been changed too drastically. However, this is somewhat of a cop-out. There's absolutely no reason why Ollie couldn't have undergone drastic changes and still hold a good, solid series. Would this be ideal? Not in my mind, no. But it's not out of the realm of possibility. Instead of telling a compelling story for a character that has so much potential, DC editors and creators decided to try and make him into a weird Iron Man ripoff. They totally missed the boat; the most compelling parts of Oliver Queen are not his wealth and tech. Queen is compelling because he's a very human character that's been shown to deal with loss, depravity and scandal, make the hard choice when the situation called for it, and always fought for the people. He's been criticized by some as a 'liberal hero', and I understand that making a character adhere to such values potentially cuts the readership, but that was such a big part of his character--and worse, today, in an era where we have left-wing movements happening across the world, he could've been probably more well received than ever.

But, alas, DC cut Green Arrow to ribbons, stripping him of all the aspects that made him interesting and compelling in the first place. I just can't see the reason why... why de-age him to a point where he just seems like an angsty Backstreet Boy? Was it Smallville? Why take an opportunity to add to character's depth and dimensions and waste it reducing him to cheap rip-off of other characters? Before The New 52, Green Arrow occupied a unique place in comics; he stood out amongst all the other milquetoast heroes as someone who was so many interesting shades of grey in the very black and white world of superhero comics.

I do fear for the future of the character, because recent history has not proven there's much hope. It will take a good writer who knows the strengths of the character to come on the book and get it back on course--essentially, a reboot of the reboot. I'm not saying Ollie should go back to his pre-DCnU characterization in totality, but there should be a concentrated effort to tell new stories with him, without losing the essence of the character.

#1 Posted by The_Tree (6400 posts) - - Show Bio

Agreed. I keep saying that DC has swept all of Ollie's problems under the rug. Which is what they have done, and the thing about him is that his problems are what make him such an interesting character. I can deal with a costume change, but when you completely take away what makes a character unique, and replace it with some run of the mill Joe Average superhero, you've gone too far. I just hope that DC will eventually see that they're ruining this character and do something about it.

#2 Posted by FullmetalChobit (218 posts) - - Show Bio

I couldn't agree more. 
 
The New 52 GA is just a completely DIFFERENT  character, he holds none of the personality traits or history of the old (and well loved) Ollie and quite frankly has NO personality.  
 
The storylines are lack-lustre, especially with the Skylark sisters and the fact that Ollie sleeps with all of them which adds nothing to the story and just makes him out to be a pathetic, idiotic man-whore who's more interested in getting some than being a superhero.  
 
The artwork started off well but has also become pretty shoddy. 
 
All-in-all  the N52 GA has been a complete nightmare.  
 
I'm giving it three more months to sort it out otherwise, I'm sorry Ollie, but I'm gunna have to drop you....  
 
 

#3 Posted by FullmetalChobit (218 posts) - - Show Bio

ALSO  Ollie looks a million times better with his goattee, I know it's not an original trait of his but yeah, it's super hot!
#4 Posted by The_Tree (6400 posts) - - Show Bio

@FullmetalChobit said:

ALSO Ollie looks a million times better with his goattee, I know it's not an original trait of his but yeah, it's super hot!

I'm also a fan of the goatee. Don't know how, but it just adds to his awesome factor.

#5 Posted by FullmetalChobit (218 posts) - - Show Bio
@The_Tree: Yeah it does! But noone seems to recognise that Ollie Queen and GA have the same beard, are built the same and have the same voice??? It's no the best disguise going but I love it <3
#6 Posted by jrock85 (2874 posts) - - Show Bio

Gimme some Ollie by J.T. Krull.

This edit will also create new pages on Comic Vine for:

Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.

Comment and Save

Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Comic Vine users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.